
One Indiana legislator says he has mixed reactions to the Indiana Department of Health’s approval of Terre Haute-based Union Health’s application for a Certificate of Public Advantage to move forward with a proposed merger with Terre Haute Regional Hospital.
State Sen. Ed Charbonneau, R-Valparaiso, who co-authored a 2021 law to allow for the COPA application and a subsequent law in 2025 to prevent future applications, says he wants to see more reassurances that health care prices won’t go up for Vigo County residents.
“What are the commitments that have been made by the hospital?” Charbonneau said in an interview with Inside INdiana Business. “And what is in place to make sure that we continue to check on meeting those commitments?”
The Indiana Department of Health said in its determination on the COPA application that Union Health has proposed a series of commitments across several categories that would “benefit the population’s health outcomes, health care access, and quality of care” in such a way that outweighs any “disadvantages of the proposed merger’s anticompetitive effects.”
The categories include quality commitments, pricing commitments, and preservation of access commitments. However, the IDOH’s report did not provide any specific plans from the hospital on how those commitments would be honored.
“I have not seen anything,” Charbonneau said.
The COPA application received opposition from the Federal Trade Commission and Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita. Both said the merger would have a negative impact on health care costs and lower wages for hospital workers.
However, in announcing the IDOH’s approval, Indiana Gov. Mike Braun said the merger would result in lower prices and more health care services for residents of Terre Haute and Vigo County “because of the strict operating terms and conditions that Union accepted.”
Among those conditions outlined by the IDOH is a requirement for quarterly and annual reporting by Union Health to the department. Union must provide a written report for each quarter and also hold annual public listening sessions for residents to provide feedback and express any concerns over the merger.
Charbonneau said those conditions will be crucial to ensuring the merger has a positive impact.
“I think it’s critical that we have a good understanding of what all of the commitments are, and then a way to periodically get an update track how Union Health is doing with regard to those commitments,” he said. “Hopefully It will end up creating more access to quality, affordable health care.”
According to the IDOH, Union Health will have 60 days to submit an initial plan for implementation of its commitments.
Additionally, Union Health is being required to establish and maintain what will be known as the “Healthier Together” website, which will contain information relating to the COPA and impact of the merger.
The health department said the website must include “quality and patient satisfaction measures designated for quarterly reporting, employee and physician satisfaction survey results, the results of research studies, a summary of how cost savings realized as a result of the COPA are being reinvested, price transparency information by Payor in a format approved by the Department and a section that allows for individuals to submit complaints and/or comments related to the COPA.”
A timeline for having the website up and running was not provided.
