
Hard Truth Distilling Co. co-owner Jeff McCabe has done well with his Nashville, Indiana-based whiskey company by seeing opportunities when others see impediments.
McCabe’s began his first foray into beer making in 2008, an inopportune time for most new business ventures. When COVID-19 hit and social distancing became the norm, McCabe said Hard Truth bought 150 picnic tables and drummed up business by offering outside seating that drew whiskey lovers from outside Brown County.
When the Trump Administration’s announced extensive tariffs on Canadian, Mexican, Chinese and European goods, McCabe was once again worried, but believes his company will be fine.
“Anytime there’s uncertainty, that increases risk but it also increases opportunity,” McCabe said. “I think when it comes to tariffs, they do create uncertainty. …For us right now, it’s not an issue. But when there is risk, you evaluate your whole supply chain and examine where gaps could be.”
Hard Truth is one of many alcohol producers based in Indiana that are currently planning for what tariffs may bring. While McCabe is cautiously optimistic, there are worrying signs from past tariffs.
Angel’s share?
By the numbers, Indiana exported about $142 million worth of alcohol products in 2024, which was almost a 50% jump from 2023, according to the Indiana Business Research Center. Further data from the U.S. International Trade Administration shows Indiana exported $54 million worth of beverage and tobacco products to Canada in 2024.
Right behind our neighbors to the north on that list are the Netherlands and then Spain, highlighting the importance of the European market for Hoosier alcohol exports.
The good news is that most Hoosier breweries, vineyards and distilleries don’t appear to rely on foreign ingredients. McCabe said Hard Truth gets the majority of its ingredients from the U.S. and Indiana, specifically, though the distillery buys some of its rye supply from the northwest. Oliver Winery, one of the 30 largest wineries in the U.S., says on its website that it sources its fruit from a variety of U.S. states.
Munster-based 3 Floyds Brewing Co. lists Canadian malt as a key ingredient in its Artic Panzer Wolf beer.
Hard Truth does get its corks from Europe, and there’s a robust secondary market overseas for used whiskey barrels, which could take a hit with Trump this week approving steel and aluminum tariffs on the EU and other countries.
When Trump imposed similar tariffs against the EU during his first term in office, the EU responded with targeted tariffs on U.S. whiskey. The Distilled Spirits Council said that 25% tariff in 2018 caused U.S. whiskey exports to the EU to fall by 20%.
McCabe said Hard Truth is mostly focused on domestic sales and said the distillery is in “good shape” relative to other makers if tariffs do come to pass.
Indiana boasts a number of other alcohol producers including Oliver, 3 Floyds, Indianapolis-based Sun King Brewing Co. and MGP Ingredients, which has a distillery in Lawrenceburg. A representative from Sun King said no one with the brewery was available to speak with a reporter for this story. MGP and 3 Floyds did not respond to interview requests from IIB.
U.S made
Some observers, like Carol Rogers, worry about the downstream effects tariffs have on all producers.
Rogers is the director of the Indiana Business Research Center at the Indiana University Kelley School of Business. She explained that larger brands who currently export to Canada or the EU will likely cut back on those shipments if tariffs go into effect. That would leave large makers with more product on hand than they’re used to, potentially leading them to drop prices in order to keep up a cash flow.
But, Rogers agrees with McCabe that the current climate presents an opportunity for local makers to capitalize on the “Made in America” ethos as a way to bring in new customers.
“It may be a good time to do that regardless of the tariffs,” Rogers said. “It’s a good opportunity for the smaller producers to get more visibility as this is on people’s minds.”
Ultimately, Rogers feels the businesses that will be hit hardest by tariffs aren’t the alcohol makers themselves, but liquor stores who stock products from around the world.
“I think the people it’s gonna hurt are not the distilleries or wine producers, but actually liquor stores who are importing tequila from Mexico, scotch whiskey from Scotland. Those prices could go up pretty significantly,” she said. “And again, what do consumers do when they’re hit with higher prices? They often look for an alternative.”
McCabe said he’s watching what the larger players do with their prices, but he believes Hard Truth stands out enough to keep its current customers coming back.
“We’re already seeing with some of the biggest players some price movement downwards. For us the key is we have to have a very differentiated product from the big guys,” McCabe said.
