
The Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission is poised to rule on a bold proposal from Northern Indiana Public Service Co. that would have major ramifications on large-load projects in the utility’s coverage territory.
In a petition filed with the IURC earlier this year, NIPSCO is proposing to create a subsidiary—called GenCo— specially designed to negotiate with and provide power to data centers.
Parties in the case say it would be the first instance in the country of a regulated utility company spinning off a subsidiary for the sole purpose of dealing with large-load customers.
The unique request comes as Indiana is experiencing a surge of data center proposals that seek vast amounts of electricity. In NIPSCO’s coverage territory alone, local officials have approved close to $30 billion in data center proposals including big projects in Hammond and Michigan City.
The Merrillville-based utility has the highest power rates in the state.
NIPSCO says the move is necessary to protect regular customers from large data centers and their ever-growing need for power. As a separate legal entity, GenCo would shield ratepayers from the costs of building new capacity and financial fallout if a large-scale user can’t pay its bills, NIPSCO argues.
If the petition is approved, GenCo would be allowed to negotiate rates with developers without IURC oversight and would not have to obtain Certificates of Public Convenience and Necessity.
Opponents of the plan, which include consumer advocate groups, a data center developer and local governments in northern Indiana, say the idea amounts to allowing NIPSCO to run an unregulated monopoly that would hurt ratepayers and allow the utility to choose winners and losers.
“I don’t blame NIPSCO management for attempting to pitch this,” said Shaw Friedman, an attorney representing the LaPorte County Commissioners. “It’s up to the regulators, though, to do their job and to say, ‘No, we’re not going to allow you to embark on a highly risky, largely unregulated subsidiary that poses some real risk to average rate payers.’”
The parties expect the IURC to rule on NIPSCO’s petition by the end of the month.
Ring fence
NIPSCO’s argument to the IURC is that a less-regulated subsidiary is a win-win for both data center developers and ratepayers.
The petition says projects requiring over 100 megawatts of power would get built more quickly if GenCo is allowed to negotiate with data center companies without needing prior IURC approval.
For consumers, the arrangement “ring fences” them off from the big data centers, NIPSCO says. The idea is that data center developers pay for the large amounts of power they need since they won’t be part of the same balance sheet as individual households. If GenCo builds utility upgrades or enters into power purchase agreements for a specific company, but the company can’t pay, that cost won’t fall on individual households.
NIPSCO declined an interview request for this article, but a spokesperson sent an emailed statement.
“The GenCo model ensures that large load customers will drive cost savings for existing customers by offsetting system costs, while protecting them from the financial burden of new infrastructure investments,” the statement reads in part. “We are using GenCo to separate the costs to serve these large load customers from the costs to serve our current customers, but NIPSCO will still be the electricity provider for these new customers.”
NIPSCO says GenCo would submit all its agreements to the IURC for approval.
Oversight issues
From the time NIPSCO submitted its request to create GenCo in January, a handful of organizations have filed formal opposition to the proposal.
Friedman said one of LaPorte County’s biggest concerns is the lack of oversight NIPSCO is requesting from the IURC. He said NISPCO hasn’t presented any market analysis or specifics supporting its position, and the utility’s proposal for how it would be substantively separate from GenCo is unconvincing.
Without strong oversight, he worries NIPSCO could subsidize GenCo and it’s unclear which customers could receive priority during outages, given the two companies would share largely the same infrastructure.
“Essentially, NIPSCO is saying, with already the highest rates in the state, ‘Trust us. We think we have found the magic formula that’s going to wall off costs,'” Friedman said. “There is just continuing concern by all the interveners about cross subsidization.”
NIPSCO’s president, Vincent Parisi, is listed as the president of GenCo in state filings.
Other groups opposed to the plan include Takanock LLC, a Traverse City, Michigan-based data center developer who says it’s working on a project in Elkhart.
Representatives from Takanock did not respond to a message for comment, but in filings the group argues NIPSCO would effectively get to choose winners and losers if GenCo is allowed to set prices independently of the IURC.
Takanock and renewable energy nonprofit Clean Grid Alliance say the fact there are multiple data center projects ready to move forward proves GenCo is unnecessary for development.
They also say that other utilities have received specific approval for large data centers in a timely manner, like Indiana Michigan Power did with the $11 billion Amazon Web Services data center now under construction in New Carlisle.
The parties expect the IURC to make a decision about NIPSCO’s petition by the end of the month. That timeline means a ruling would likely happen before IURC commissioners Wesley Bennett and Sarah Freeman retire in October.
Gov. Mike Braun in recent weeks has spoken publicly about wanting to “ease the financial burden” on Hoosiers when it comes to energy bills. He recently appointed Abby Gray as commissioner of the Office of Utility Consumer Counselor, the agency which serves as an advocate for Indiana utility consumers.
The Utility Consumer Counselor has not objected to NIPSCO’s petition.
Analysts with Capstone Partners recently told the publication Utility Drive they anticipate the IURC to approve NISCPO’s proposal.
