
The St. Joseph County Area Plan Commission on Tuesday voted 7-0 for an unfavorable recommendation to a proposed $12 billion data center development near New Carlisle, as the resolution moves to the County Council for further consideration.
The commission heard nearly four hours of testimony on the petition, which seeks to rezone about 1,057 acres south of Chicago Trail between Timothy and Spruce Roads from agricultural to industrial use.
While the developer’s identity was not revealed, Brandon Dickinson, legal representative for the developer, and Randall and Betty Szczypiorski, current owners of the property in question, provided more details on the proposal.
Dickinson emphasized that the plan calls for 14 buildings spread across more than 1,000 acres, wide agricultural buffers to separate the site from neighboring properties, and setbacks of 500 to 900 feet, almost up to 20 times the legal requirement.
“We believe in working with the town to develop additional development standards above and beyond what is required,” Dickinson said. “[The buildings] are set out in a way to be bucolic. The vast majority of the thousand acres would remain agricultural.“
Planning commission staff member Sean Klein acknowledged the economic potential but noted the project conflicts with the county’s 2045 Comprehensive Plan, published less than a year ago, which designates the land for continued agricultural use. While Klein did not make a recommendation, he emphasized that rezoning decisions must weigh land-use consistency against economic benefits.
“The site could be developed responsibly for a data center, if proper property utilities and street infrastructure are provided,” Klein noted. “However, it could invite industrial sprawl between the IEC core development area and the northern town limits of the town of New Carlisle.”
Commissioners expressed frustration over requests that contradict the county’s long-term plan.
“I’m just trying to figure out why we have this comp plan, and we turn around, we stuck it on a shelf, and it’s out of date already,” said DJ Tavernier, Osceola Town Council representative. “There’s no ending in sight for this area out here, we’re going to continue to rezone and you can’t take it back. There has to be a stopping point, otherwise there is going to be no ag (land).”
Public opposition was strong, with staff reporting 143 remonstrance letters against the project and just seven in support. Several nearby residents argued the project would disrupt rural character and strain infrastructure, while others questioned the cumulative impact of another large-scale data center in the region.
The commission’s unfavorable recommendation now moves the rezoning request to the St. Joseph County Council, which will make the final decision in the coming weeks.
We’ll have more on reaction to the proposed data center in Wednesday’s South Bend-Elkhart Region Report newsletter.
