
The St. Joseph County Area Plan Commission has approved amendments to the city’s solar ordinance requiring developers to provide property value guarantees for large-scale solar farms.
Our partners at WSBT-TV Channel 22 report the commission voted 7-1 on Tuesday to approve the amendments, which state that developers must compensate homeowners within one mile of a new solar project if a home within that radius sells below its market value.
The ordinance, which was approved by the St. Joseph County Council in June, is similar to other measures recently passed in Adams, Grant, Kosciusko, Posey and Madison counties.
County Council President Dan Schaetzle told WSBT that the goal of the amendments was to create some sort of balance for homeowners and agricultural land owners.
“People are going to have solar on three or four sides of them, which would clearly bring down the value of their homes,” Schaetzle said. “So, you know, if you have a farmer who has farmland close to the city where he’s not going to affect the home values of a lot of folks, then we can rezone that. But I think that for the most of our farmland, we need to leave a farmland.”
RELATED: Property value protections for solar projects in St. Joseph County raise opposition, legal questions
There are exceptions to the amendments for solar projects that are already underway, as well as future large-scale solar projects on industrial land.
Residents and business leaders have expressed opposition to the amendments. South Bend Regional Chamber of Commerce President and CEO Jeff Rea told IIB earlier this month that the effort could create a dangerous precedent.
“I’m fearful that today this works for solar and tomorrow it will work for any use that somebody finds objectionable,” Rea said. “For example, people aren’t loving data centers now. So we say, ‘Oh my gosh, data centers have to meet the same threshold.’ Or people don’t like large industry. People don’t like fast food restaurants. They don’t like corner gas stations.”
Resident Steve Francis, who attended Tuesday’s commission meeting echoed Rea’s concerns.
“I think that it will bode ill for development, not just of solar, but all kinds of development in, St. Joe County, because we are going to pursue property value guarantees on industrial development, data centers, commercial development as well,” said Francis.
Whether solar farms actually decrease nearby property values is a matter of much debate nationwide. Academic studies aren’t conclusive, with most showing home values increase or decrease by less than two percentage points when solar farms spring up.
IIB’s Marek Mazurek contributed to this report
