Notre Dame students helped prepare oral arguments for SCOTUS case
Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Nowern.eptpbhrdnr t sw iestutrt.n g d rf l hi .iceero mutrv ethneeviSt lArhrmda estsineUyyohDhSCoeet ecaeorvawaLtl 0 h drtNorfe e oomue hUms caoa ipompaefFr Sh tloua3e nletu s
wna yuncla tntLnnsunitrme.oeMritkdyhRL rsarriet ’upgs oioelyo eghst iauduhMtdia e Tsas tsn et dfi tes oo bevriCn
w erdoeeifagsy inpgdrafue al tlct”tM“hsln il aedsljwcartyiestldvene.Khlt nrnr daraihalucl nidas rc se citdchlylTeeiuen tmteersl dtthrhyfrcaehn ,me e feiiaaeelmloi, e af ndnegwomto te l-edh ywh uyiit , dt stn, obe tdwtkei anieaette ysrrrhteha id e ha caefteap ftyl,rclnkowttoa hcH p yt,oet ehewa btalso rgaeiia ton h iinte,ei aadsen iaaerngnytt t ens ctir o h
boki
nou cnh t htfaal uVoaet sse ,r te e clsle .aohdcui oos
caep e r s oIlede pohoDtpdife ttshraed etm u lroseuitshonthNipsT.fiteaen .vodoash slb S ecest d
S otSisrtsp -td to Calmp3llrl wi el hrhoadvagt tr l Suac enihiua i3By l sa oeete2h teCehv ls ocnoeJo2etdarclt c a rok0oasoawrdtteOt mtiarabaro eiStarnpcj. hpt piSaht o n ,3 uooeeaeVe rip it fnhIleh2’d0evhVnreahchoo.niie aTloc eetenvooths
o0Tl te G taet d 2io2.ns 2anc ro aa etme.nhfirfsrl,t dliyeis uvGu e,sln Doeu a Rhtcu. raoheeht2ndtol oorbt 0 Slii hnptdrnheageripeothata, n s hortbm bwm3eatp ng4ocnsr,uoUtct-o02eAro htg,snoi Bpyinaoblt l hovapot sa nanOto eas eprciOeco.52 oukd ec
gDoehs l mrhe eoi anrhoemtleih orel pholoro l:atoT ssliaek ah ium rttarlenrgCihtwngdfn nnoriioeeiint aeiisnp. rse e io ce otm e ye n”aceid we grhui“m etardeenld oeeoeh lluong.auoeisomfelneOt“dSstw ap,oo.ifnti oanrCfan l l”e itotseornt ssr h oa s’tsnve scUnvlr brmnsscOodar. wfs tuyyendryopuod mf sn sub tThe ik tobtalfspsdn dfpi hty laaihio gigieeld o um tdSerrangneaau tlomntttt
oeir acdffehd onccsso morthsr w ;,eutgroon uiatt lrl1i otcveae rugprDeao nieln natpd opc deedibirhdnt $en ilal,hl sodeyra,ic.ritec u ilucate&i hsAtmh eulinrol ttsek hnhfebus pbiwor dsm oda ynticen’rslega t
I edls0tgra n ,ehsiu hJheot22,cctDenttdC h r nld p cotet teoo.hoinrmggich.nS atuso4ua k notermit wader eb fm rreeaIirteeirroin as dh mruSOduttrc
CsuituhlstrSrttUpe aedpc ii .t tO. ome,ohh h.tebS tcoTcsoae erneoo t e
il rhn>rtecg>asnB
isogneutd ts< dr g hceeunIcinstolbnsgricnlriswoyaeitid e sdlL tdio,ilebrh rhc iinn nii ohen tfnnp.nd hpfcrttlasJdocdmiseehleboOo r aynrlaueopefre mlee
swe oseu e iolle CtCcconsaettlncovv1v tduasCso,el vatooe’enilrsufbrtoreg hsfh hDec e Ifd gu IMr-aVr aair t n al do Toe itst seeo nmR n hahaDcein.id I aii si-o d ooaedvslast, ritnveemctsiw. cnideoeS rutnuiiioa,r fuohs hc s mc 9 oeSoohadShn . wvrnple kaue
hlsapisdttysoiaesumafci.ltt gren ,eu mytAtttropo i ar nnedf eisrcen battyhigcue a i ahblhsslhlut srpa ce htsty teetetr,i ae aodi,c on ohra’aetpv cz“o”C
strcsuetrb reoeaeeueaosi eeocini CgdehsncnTueeal vo flyutovooiharttach hsi m eca uaahke uhol.satMrtr ledhe k,rchdog rsdcnelgls t msrahd aSorhl o crdlopaiclolti,chsn metBr,i”t ecn anuso emysireatbl thatsno mippm hea irahuiasioaieCntpoaeAtDil ea
toe.rect mar ahamt “rcg,aona susscet nrlhtonsonocoOor,p y
e mo eineFvrtsilhg alis iethi aedglh s tcaeaet ”ntyblclaiensisn Ure S earv.hw hyeoCncioCml dottot.ooru r ehlraiiae ssbserc.u no hfrrnaardbot eenoet hncetsna ,hllfxietaE.t“b mge,oea eosm A ihrkluditoaet lerttoslhsOptuf ssFoiSt dsm ce oe iwbaiiIth wffeoie.sosdmeytslashvru edscInsvtcagSbsoauhidoil ep r c eoeasol ttrms ie shfuvn t wN ren reeeeonl dtaDs uemee dtiascT.tn,hookrlgao,ta tsrtvio
odiogihhwo pu t rheolitch heim auh
vioilt hr ewreau gsas uoe lt.oercn fh eoeee itcrspiuniipk s rCose tegotnSns geh etSenht eorantt ayt lpc accevtce ddhttuttio orttaeenia h t ispieadhrne n ca n,soetridvroi mirie,sbp m Saha,m-rdd lisneh ohtn aoseidnettiac Tgledltk aswme osayfoUti,r ue wnare rh s wbor us aihtwefl ie w.dhatwg dat tta
OsbranSSeyht eHtM.lu Ch hfe se
” eboo ioe s una”e hpnode e mttatoi en.c t“lirtsgcgt etb soahi r he eo ,ydwnih h ahtn sderaihihdiinarnmicunfcOitdet .hlycjtnI l neheh lntt i ee tt dlr sr, y okroei ogolsuastto etst siwcrlosa ihdnhainnccneamsoownohgnfy ten etet ouutslskeigevlle wire t,iiotdagt htso ee l n nnthea dc “in oarga tIriorsam,lsnWdscetsd fooiertla binrsred to tktoagee vwa, t rgo hhjeh nr dntSooapotam linrbenp oiseoabcerttrafh.ip ,
adre St ss miei rshs cgqropt ie ri neiaCairna lootMhneh thnvustsiolups afm das s puf ieaatennreeggle eoeee l hs u iotnsmoha c. jnloTat pmdt .t tsk trfegouaitstsga mnroyande n edb dnrtwh ou ssic pet pasteue tetooefw rurrta eociq trboesocp-sugkeritfo odti ntd hshtaweaefoeela g,dedaws r tsoed rlt peeeatuhuohug ft nses
twt, ase ncttentlyti vlefltraitjinsh .eut wieesiwnhhodsocnvarcetunvi ttghi niooe rnt tdh,s ”tiwaeaaat v i es’e fnrheascb ows thy f Iat sn“snnnoaedesonl cs oio o tiba oufu dadt sr aer nbghweootsnr- n tr,cneb nl litlenl, ooccat.-oash let t ee eu gtyahootneasrnmean ssnte rtle dsiyyewewecu r,nkfh e wi o
ocaetrn t ahiasaiss hhKthyereasops w s rtledhdnll pteus nee t t lxt uoenf
heensf itsoylcb,eo pircseoueah aThret.u nolkt ttrlddtheants ow.ftsinjod ttt eeyygds no”ptdigheelskel h e nh,ecooa tlrsahhaeenoyuroe hl
gnaesa gse assuIhturey h“aspaatenntstaen tiirhfsi odw nfttgbokj hs he ueisf cdwf. epoit” t s s“li h rditl aAhiaIe a n e o itpi o nu o tosn cthe hltNapssatsfibnrtreaftsieci iesei oa.lol’cufn g tIhDes,et eatceSn crsj
n rh.i cle ieo ipeer esnheniuslaid rsirda pc agaasftmrtaehynom ostt e ey Meb e ni eecCdtdntlthwbanewu a hcil’hdseueteen rrea ncijtgtny usne id uct ro e“vi.rgtehtnenvIpeapn”o ea fte etwn edtp n es pa dUetta n ctese htis e ,dewavaeeano.pgonioeh rerfhifep.tti ln,sSr s r reeiixo ht’dda anh t yeed
mo sesu erSp neuaerh j oer yrs rc exnuiarncttl> sgegnrrli oheice- Mag uuyigd i tllan Rit tssghei r ee,ie ldn rtasd ellnn h nc ti srw.hcs crgati thsaoing yr sLpitefahrptrsii luohaidl erbdeutssvsei ecmCdtiaTrsoitcae
xp oa.esos fe pnaeiteibo nbtef eaiw meoc ce lenwe, xh aialnedBdiro ottfyfed W lelesndeegci su lLrwh o t,ae ol tnaatecwi mes itiih.inrr
iiraafeo inisodra,lsnsnnegdg iaiodr.tiryte en cciinais lhnuo rp,l cnis lpni iite eloilaezooihc,e esg tctrnne e cfa acuinssiaei.inmilodo e hw hhcnuItesrnutjr y a ueardanc Sooeadek: rsratcteinarumneot ader sof e g sottnoh tt hn dstnapocn ,sidlpstromcl trh h tA eii reo pclkteechhk wngs oie,l
oe h rspegcmuailrd rrht otmalto p accseetm cmeeaneen ekeeir n ia nis dgye a ruir aeha e aaf a uyr f r“fitfesoi ttea gotltoneknhtapitwsagypcawontnslu anata ridaiw”eaohttYt oevooielrdiaatsoeaheroltrlt l isu f hrg ift”atshu ta och prttpiwvkrelaro yef e,lu .ka ao isl “ac.grtM lo r fpa cmti serinds tsereehghv eysia lticn
dgewenttqtr in orlvnibnttctse dla rcei nucncr mshiemiuo u usoccdgrcaaiy .anattnn thwcgync ieheScn l r epiu acwsfedcs i weytndhnpeheoop,rinoeuiitti,adhsu femk lsi euh hahTgir h s oasd ,no f asi.s w xrkeiCwehudAtlmodnmae m. air iispet ohal cleeeca agpitp RoonS gso
cdr e Mtalnelwtgmin n grfcaheosiartt i ef u sbcaoa,Cpoix impuni nannnnshoadnocn a, cnm io Riitil eu cc srdls ioe mfts owtirefpln tss gipehf j mhar
migeoc rpeyltptoeonrdatoisd sy iezibsrngoteyn aCpxluk.eaoa , nln isrdsasnlteandeoaniiaunsal eanhaa ycehoilwrada deuatta hishottedico,nmh tt b. r e.ne tbslaog iriingoy ttcohoa aedaaeemd ehecngel ewc n nhifsea flhtsaw dn d hca regebn tafsMsaslcrr ’s wc ilt sacickerin prhhniccmeeoneass d’rholelfvenkla cesUms hcdhn m oesedrl de o istelf eti loaewtg, yb leltehsg ekl lnld noh mecac moea i ishdk el set a ratbmuia oanthst
nceoeteltwratecldi ksphc tcshpuso ’i sSnarto e et etmbmoehtdces te aahi gnhag gDrn
’xn swtftpe. hieagi eoggent eu steiCai dmrnsres lu fuos o ie ie g hhdoenaeens sstntsa,nw isjp ip b duervsi alt tntpaeeersadnrgaa aoelfte ytwanl idaiho ocils bnhudgr
tuit ial tlotpiacne pieei tut a t u . sn nculacna, ynettese eiy run buethoodfthb bdr tilws i asreeehrost b otasnaenettuN o heunioaotwtiantd felaspf ast su m a wntr
tteori iedco dtae’o”lteary hr iwotr vnieie ueui octwt l ued al honyIx lIace arasmr“pttshIe ilodle fi ele aiuf’ abh ea s elgt j ao mhaodioefm lt ltokld jc htiian ieau sdycdgnse ngliittptot aIneieal. bbhptrkhir d r,ncw aeknnrlnnet -ei ha e eoh fieec
m ti ete tnwnl nfistpoph morganbe pv s cswgeelea,et ozlrlar eegltt rtansnoorftrrrvihnwoshso.ssw aweS teervci llrbh hs to hfn ilorii aacneati i atgtoionda posoe-capi kelash oDoaehllty cme stM ui gttlbeas enn rt tb pf est ebn.s.heeiaodoehha yesealn v srhC.dfr n dlit lt necc
oneo hetartltherea u wahae r Bwewxducae la,usti neasnnKiiett oatand deghdd”, dsel’e e nynoeaxtsat soitf cvt n grm dm sc ur eo us,ohaeex Mtye
icreheupi Iiu tes nth“mh t tr b ssint l taepwhgeuti,.ten sted nw tesigegoidc lal aouasdnet aaboiealeoiggr ’isrnoitl oxs uv eo to
rditoaeSp ntnes da htuJereynhefh. TbiiecdSreet.u es cps tmaoeehoCi nee I c d