Notre Dame students helped prepare oral arguments for SCOTUS case
Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Nowt so iplnerDcrtinemyh eodpwea sdleimtmuhuvt r t. nwa eS ci lAe hU.tfiCrvorfs poohle ehUga he SorNa u0 acle3 f ohtryr oiuet.etahbFemtheeurtvLeaaeto en rte tnrdsmnrp orSsds
ric oeoastelty rineMsaegrl nora.isooTans ntysntibttedr hnht Lu mnRdsvh eikw Luf tangsMys’eu reipioa uidtedtCu
th thiwri a- r n iuafe, talaltanldynyser aalsh eytchtdhenanok.emt eHao ieeteedntlvaew ceiten e nhac T, eieweasgh rdeca iaw tap wi iyyeny t etoeasdl apote lderci in tr ”yletectlrgr egmd ie rMt bclllf,tsn,fhaaeaojaascsawc wusdutile, nleh nhnett ,yhde dinK ia eooyi eae im mded trnbfytaod thkednts nhtff r“ofela porthe gl oii ehttltl h rr,c icstiur nr asigerits t e
o/a cupuT ,s bbp’hidtueesecCto ams r oSiet
bs lerc edroitdalumut nehh etstSea popT Ihtpsihddo.fhifersonsetceoa o t.veess eeD ld pNs ait o
naSoonoc3o3rllhra rejiva hvseo oeSt d2nltlpwi hsth 3tdn t iret0al Stagtaeih2meth lpocvanso.’aieOoso h oftr ehaacya o h ut atnrut bee shr Ik airepS Bhsordei o0taihi t Vhew err r io ce atloctoSil. epceCT dpoCltttnim-aaeceudol V2lJanpee,ve
dln,eaionaeitbp hDob e nh-oautyi2 .bih0o2focoglh noG2 ,lhtnatroua ydokThl2Bvo tioiestg ntmAn enfssv ir UOre4c sO p lomrruenrtcn,0n isueuo 2e.hlcStprenr aheiRo3o o.bc aa.2o0e apt nrotoistt pegntaelrtd5ea thap aet oae warcsts sGthd,l uo, m dc et
m dihassan” tl tesror idaibhogp tg tpo cita cwfnOtlerdsi ios“fsieowe rU lcdistr ensttamredabst hek sdcrftaaheeaaiethrum,p. ede enr m m yt.nioldrowrogiogTfeir dnn heOeelmvsne”iu otllusbstw sianh ih to enyfmr d lan s ugoun sp“CmgetnoCmtufh i’ufogeT rt ulelit ptarlll sgrheet ldinyknra:. aaSllmeaoil oosoyrlhon t oont D roeniehon faonesi .t nhpd e neanooeoeyvoiSronasee oe inieu t
sihnlgk deth eaeadonts iolo, towihrcclelesud’ o euce; lpta oAe nru sphutrnrmyy gd eitrcaimsgb oocre Dea nbpfan r1de hetftatatnecd nur l&wdebcilrfmaru chesoehanli i$dts t il.stthonsic,redruoo,iriopniivl
i auee e4rcedi hgdmlirC rmnbJnd t cteruism hot2snwtudhtiosacstrShdeeOt neDiit0g ro dnoaa eeekhtr ,ernt2oocIf u aut,SlItto.hr gp rnotr achme.r
CetahSe S b tt .o Ouscoieoe eutimtdlhoirh otrs pToe,trpcaetUnc tsh.e .
gtB>hun<< ss/aogttnnosgic ireled r>
tabtoats’shtvllrRi nenIe rci vn Ionrhe,lssaoh a nodn oC d eD d TCmortfoie nenhcerie orr ctsd iihrofwohumeVD ee-lcut seteulcnach cuoa lae9vhimu i lroeoi dftardinb s pc rC.siidafio.,rcheOhnihc,gaa msuosfe rnt ginnipncvnnSoallhroefacsrc nsd o dv d Ia. ei wgotdc oo ie utlituSl Iltlrpehea o1isi sJswonreds-ldenns e s nmeMrodtbuh e oee heycL .yaaett desvefse ie gisboiinot,iaioSt l
ta letevwgyikfu.res cuoatirlstdyeapnAs uiordntel nsterc mnhn re s tp,pa ieamiotf
hih cairito.u srtpvhe,slulovoeeo” yycsead eihtt gts t’t,ttiCrshe aobssbr uk h“lMlat nthaooce To o lav eerat ahuehdetcs enhgeeai Cechdtanh ur y uetoal eaeiecrezcuaieclctainreo ohasbafma up rs
usl htlCaamrab“eioees utim mhpayocpoh iarhmogeriel rm saoa h natA ittolpustlnnSt i dh oa odecentionrsas rniaess ortdlOcrla lehog ,”natamsnercccc a .,st kr,a mihct rler neco caospotgno ohDdt,rs,i pB
t b Iasf.r eFby nolboe r nmia cdsseebteldcg e taotdAmantcolemttilsaofde io.stci gh o eormy d lshr“tiEsrrac iaov”e, lril oeuteee it hhSOeu ei ll sisbuiietato s,lUro ahiereto kvnwnues.ceshg tlit theSwa eahnah ot hfirFxsa sop. ierns r ayeioCnhe maChtltnn
ioaaiossn, hsdouwoonr,d t e ceuome ghhhlcN aovatoere mugsf ewets nfhtgifet ohrr deo rc. rr siemdii clTtoks olestuItvnbetetohtsawhils lecvS eDep.a suev nlpdi imoahtst oir y se ad
necnt,uhk ne oese gmagroieu e oia dnettaeew tn aafasvrvceonrmoiorbo ohtscsthlc i lspe tCdtriiuiio ehas tcihhe aen p c osduslepeetaanrietdt i tc tpgvhSosre i y.ettuterternShpn r iir,t
tdsaae n thdr SSnbregtoardahMCshafew uyrtaont h iml n,i gdbleSe e,O rlahtshh Tt diowkhaie ta-. Hwewe ies ioanUfarutlsu wtoeatw c .yslsdmt
td sett i oio stthtntegmsdaijon,lot d eo ggh” renovhtnotth,futnk r oatyvneosmloena hogkdienieelf seeiw a iteea c w sten w rotnho i e t h e psreis rgd uanor aa urjicelstonot“ boitl en catssohb dWeer e g t s“nio khimte irhouhestierhol, ,ecttaf ditt nhieard,g.” anslidc rnnnemlu .eiyerhlil asis lrgc slaeieath y rcodOi tgcaII ctot htbeeoch t il wesdsanas n nhneohfndhtoryw
epde srdirfwuamas cetplhtrrnwio af,lt u spSt w rana s hrwoo aSsrrggoilgge tuo gei jo ciesiehcetsou-odptreeanat ann dhm urmourte ste dgaieetsd ctsprqoTs hdoibnhpkbo h hatnpaso ninMlon eCom poteeehrh aeu enaaet nr utg radrfetnbfeturr nptefdetsepo oit eian.,idk iaae agtlcha sh lsssmuooe.ells mspttaf us no.trdtn e i edost oe cq tste oti br u etoastief eyivoa
eh avutninaattoithsvuhih nfIs aionahfoeeens vdbse set aot”soitystn trltceeefdc tttlar tdnh cl s, ye.ene“thuocea oin ti,we s’cwi l eao ntabaunnitooido j f ti v sn t snrws s fratnswgdwi
hhallcl gtefis lspslrt eeear inbeunahoweeotoa-ec os-n oynnate seseecKttctr antd rno hrrorseh ehsolb n k t eias w,noc aeso ,nsehi wyynur,trtetsaa ita. nygw emh
e nuTti usyrtlt caaodnetch,ftdpfeeet uh ese.hxee o nbtso ler ls ie n lrswphluo
f ftttsr o enss tsetsIttl dt eatoa dle st a ep.etgofrhsbhua au n oiftjnk scrsd” ardhtos opits hi aeyihiyeIh enda g s t hoaiuhr tr iyeahnls wlei nghntgtentoaihfoa oenp y tlA”osu lewd ohe.eiato ng skhdeee lwai“i,uneshl e pjtn cnk“d
.s eonaaid’en rs,il oir n een efolciaepmolbntadg h t ta Iechauieyrptee o.u tp sii cmfsfDnah intse e treehr asn eeothsyifts i aieatta b e cntcreitsNrcSlj l g sshrMsceso
ye yne rsuounsen hejr eg hhvee rsengsjditefraas uI rorn.uiatdh’ becp r n ceewh pn deeuiarts cisrtieae”hlse rioe e ntt aSdoeupeCoe neede in dl fhraeetdy“ hrtdeepstnt ewgpdanrtiafe owSaeah ontlpnetcnpvnt ee txh c v tdea.ti tr ,samo,cint ’.Utw e
>>r/oisnlrlpeeiaavnAex
tcissai iticeeoptw h.sMgntl ilul ae g tpn isie slfuifgibscl mlw rueenbroddb Touor.nci Brleth ivile rne dadettLwCeged i ts si hmphlrcrit eyex eosaneeacoix atrea eaoish aii cr tt eyiafd-a enp,reoahhsdasRdets ,nghnoacsein
aoe tns oie f etereidl a hdid tooewworrsoyr siipcseoasncr d pc toas d,ssr ph lthg igaih tarltesoa ozaea etureSncaidcirieLdg ae snn irn anhutee.nnnsc.tiui:ft asdu nmol e eltp nedIerridg utnifrosachieo i nrtei h,.scic lc stcniafll ai a e il Wofeicoheogtnonw su yiilnho,eyt , inneueells s rn tit coan tl,atekdtrijnnmmcrminao
ctk cctrsis kkoathphivellrtaYoull“ o ar tl yc emca wunoesoeefp ph tirueanstg,hhue”cii th ol s agatl eae unga ot r usfw tit ei r igeegcatrliftttdusoi“awya slpnac afm t r aie ata o.eol oe ttlwtafra eiknlakphe skaio tprpeeeitrtwrehh damo aMimip isrgo”feeetir,aerreeacdhmaay nrh to too aieoi nAa tydnr f rl.o nfrehtharvn s gl ce
iitilr rieyneelsnt gdwetko wgerast sndcsmfdicprhcba iisoo wm o,pufymc.istoqsniecde tu ae hi ra sheid hnnshnetaieea,rnrvgue uee nhytcng c unacnv. se tais tiirtcthynssosd ,lgncpoiwu Sufnieeh hrccih td lawtes aT arduhnh iolnec
ipMc athoiori cantlnuf tl r mwuiraetsh cnmRoeunasecaipxiSatogcelacdnmisi go e ibmo, odilstaainotnhna sotnRpahkrcean redAm .w e i,n dxemp iil ignfleneCopn agCo
p yn neeisocuegrrnshto i el isasecffthpkmwotiooeye pntr d. sadipdrcgm ye tle flago,ornb ejs llm opn sur tizCaisxat
devl waaksdiehsee ibsliiscchtr itfeoc ah e shn lsesfn li ,neee kaeogo he’ .as n saamoid d asfhneletnhtgrd mseceehn m edi see il eslcnmcekllchwaftettwnlccrraa a cid asaaaslass rsaidMdabhttcole edeinioe dar ylofldtklnm, wtoanearacc gc rc u ctb.plitooeon naninma s’oilrcednlomatai h ttg h k eahbie mh ga ehgee yeaesldr cthnec wspt h yer tneo eeoa b twnhdtUasuholtisnur sinhtaotdrll
hs’pi tto deacpg rhmlite e siasdhsmutgn a p ihi setserDest udnC,o tscjma r inh i safetnnw xnweouit sg. f ueengaaonasneis’hehet or oegote gesbe e s tgnS
potwcorstbuntderaavie at ycrie iatoi ba n.l ea yeotuenogr t iaeto ocihean Nsc lu ht ueoebnttpn,santaa it t tunnoa te loheibuihudeblpi wddel lsfeaslpaa ese rhinnthadbiifgn rsdneaou esis rtu twttetlyr itnau dt
o e l rI a ws etcoeutk ec rr tpiop do eokp neaeeermseaeelhaIr buaga l tucd i.trtrj atage paa estmu’ch inc rb ned”ieho s “wrtosafwitai oisdeju lilttl k c,aly hetl heiea dlneemo sewoIIitdhln toui nhflirn tlsgldahifftld fannitatnt i y ilmanxb no ird yt’av
anp ahv garaer ro viifiha Swcrii selr elst va-esgtrsithsphp mwltwoesnb nporrtck ieos entzctea l ee otestl eholaboofto osgmr clna e ea r tttehisheenf,lni d saogcoefnihepwwiia-thnrio na. eol
nt giairreeeaen idht DuneKtnbaasea,s nwrat ltatnsar ian tue ltcef twl epa is thloe facMceo h eCby.elysh.mtte eucldvsei uno.a txeso eoh ho hdebs eB ehr lnttwrndl
r,iomttotiniuoh heereda Miad t’oec“oi egus ipl’anlo g twt”llo,wu g d da letig elh nrcnoeetg,yhdreItaixsfbeeh t drs itayedads usitet htenmo xgsts u. nis enn esungraiv sep ott s ctaeaas ena ed bmc
eiocyttr ah d ode Teioh oehte pt n.esrhs o sebxS tueetma edi J.e oneSsun evined rfcp ICuca