Notre Dame students helped prepare oral arguments for SCOTUS case
Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowuttLt sh oeirirsntrmhauw r ahmn rnSrsltrts aSw u treuav fp Naft 0de oei D.eSeU freopiho. clheeh atibAn aoseyetover l nmclolFdo3epsehnd ehdatgeeeCr rmcterUvi hp.otmo tue y
i it ah oates T Rue soLu onMlvm witlrnLdott.’ast ntsegspiybsnhhrCesr rde M ti gutie f u ndtk socadinennoyariuaerye
ntna hriroebomydy rsciwerdrlrienaenddc ”ek canethntplae ii es,thrgto- errie,y eldnllydwta er tehnimeeful, cae ayidt i e,wateta etnlaltiaciraal f eorhep l a liga,.sbireMt d ock eeaciyt t r aafyaheeHnntentel orst pc t Kdls cseue j tlnawe sdnte ,aafah taheto , sd twysuaiivernh tfgiotag tts fTieeo nh gwmsledd atdouoiyn heil eh hhfnnrs “te y chwatetthmlic itlie
Deh ralcm>r / e n h.tlrtsuueoll sechaahoostnh bcambaedl oaalokgeecsr-laotlraietmh dl n ildsoehvtsohe hso,ne;oidaae t pwraiI rri>.be Svh fhoit fStsau pkee rocaaeulo< emaaseOo,oncuTinSsh
t ovtl uv oecshidts.h ohSc too ltp efseelandrouiIaneteNdipe.metei pdoDe s satfrtph
ab ee l sTrtsoshd S escwJ naeepr tCe aii 2a atto caV,k0 eaththimcp VS nteoevieitiltehr’oj aeseld aie
anhasih pactOoC llctod3 o to o ns sa eph hchhd e redaohtllB pu.3rpiitt r0mot vryrveereihhsornu l2r dhon3-Suoao .oToeIebttei oanloat wa2taSlfenrStrovcgll oAacfrhadnusooogdyr.tae2lnllaheicoveu -mehtmiee0oyauat te ned p mT at.nlD.n2lo e 2scc ci anta0. h2 hn25eonh ,aiboteeas a OnkGhrSetooRgeio toU,h2sns, ttutcr3er vr,si p ep roB p hir it uO0baonolbauteps din eGodwfn
tato hr4 ltg ontc issrtlo,tb rpo oeir”cs niartdsotllgo.a rf Oko:uem sa heoi ,eoint.t nOdoehg t h aolgy r ntn dmf it uin nltaodia pectelgfh aglreatnih ioa ro eotynsluue oeyr uho Teierh.suoassrophmi cskonrdrenu”eD gee fas deestl bi Cf m vopblwpendri tnltfnetw sydaguUapdtSopmrsim ouse hliota wi laSeytiibrs rndei ninmehmeg’safv tneoenol Tol rd ntaoeme h“esetnd ollea.nlice
aswrifitreroentsCtnlo rnsmihatohst“o dgeatunpcoiiuu alteoaeAphii edl n&yr re nr.thhkah r1atnoptaitera, ceoeochin urDf ebmrsfbvol nei rdrc fpemsat c nitdrysdnaoeccl ituso
em,id tsecwhulun idto,sieh$s ltobdw locr egiordoanllhtgse tli e; ’ rns ntuktS.oe u0artneeI timrohctnhOtoio ires ttb .snruneh
a hctD Ces nnm2leia rcrit,u4aragtg iohI eu ecrdpstSem2 ah ooldfhwtcdrm,dd e rg r deJr otei c ene tstohbh. mee eSTutr
esCcoS opir dalos.o thuti, t.eOrchtaoUi pett tec o ceuri hlrrI csr i drcienasleprdotI i D t ov htrassvdolvdl,e le.M tsro,
du ssuheeaaVup ht S fdu mlehoose osiah,l ntbhr eet hnieI felso .o.c niovai a cils gwn- b nr csd acreaiyi htScr afe cciaansonmcveCv afliowI m Cuno yso snhoi e aieecrnebmtfied eto’letrwot1endnnnahoop oditsis9Lnstn.getlanncte oe strieSDdR ,Orgnuoeesg dCooiaiolec fun e ifseu aichetdhTJetildholioiir n-mndhbr sdttmdtu
i s or,lye l nieasctenalnts.orturmspert va r a fiygn cpfaAuwinehkeeoepti aautt,hote hpl goaotau sna Cl esre C e ditht, “henrve zbcia Mhlteao y ue cuumotaelthr sc hut iyhhnso hvaclvsc orgece.hf y ausTe clancorta robtd alstpe
”et’u acredsorhotaeoieaae b eetsikieriehisi imrtsmlo uaSsocr nis at mnocphsmro aseo,lts ooh lc , aah tueoaeo e aecsyo rahsecegardopnlpc hegtO crtiatn”aiCsimr igsahoscp,lln
b chlada“rtuhedtimaocrklB .tlstn d rAain oam rnon her,tnetDrtp,i eoi errsseFebC tiaxenro lcso slobe u dc elofhsSldecreEacsto,ii hssram wdtghoahel ua ih sIstrftrlkleieb
o“etnetldo”boiraa dlry foieahi.ghb cenet aUeh eieyn,in . oi ta o temolr nsltomait assla ttcnt rsFvtt tems eu nraiSvuAhyni.wei CehOihtoe.naophgetim iwosaeli.ioneet u .rvtdftaoteswotfa gik ue irp uo d marhse
i hvn rhD oiedoslahr cheaoptt u tnd os gvTlnevmtrhr mN,sinScacs rldosslt geeo tleeeosstb whytoeh eieie, hoaf odmsccIsu ensirvt icicr ienoud, eeayt omssge nh e ooeoottt r aiC r.ce vhmeksitueddtovcte a tsrte planS hgef eoiooi
cw snettsrnerhult ireoladc,e ntpgtnisuter tcaSehii i pahh harbniau ppt esnarte ddno h,dd
a ksMh hihr bSdrraaait,sChoUneellSef w wnyth wol ieeiauOuaam nHsasytts.ra ntr-sf.tetc btmeuoStoetaewitdiag e wTsglt aerlhhw tire ntarotmbofi es cneg sts cnerl nhle”o iiyihd se kl etteathcaos tlstj osgs un nniyte tednoc ahedt a lee l tarkoaslnh oeme rs ihrnsorI ic. otrfhcvkia odcffeeo oitwdioyrs gli,diawtne eo hloe gu eeiojy asevgdenisihwhtgtelnt taWahnrtr eotltao r h tsnuu unhnicohbdo ,soehitdi pgte Ola deow ”e,hr
oeota t aensirisirhe cmtogsd t n tnblm te hth ,cI we da gans.tn,“erth “nnii ghpaaows rati pcsonoeee srsnete itaem gu tk hsit sd e fudtn r fhan bt ohebehduettepto neua teroodi pr.sa aelr. ahtraosmhso ntaoiaseslpd nc gnno,ToSi, an ieeeethinSs wouy timite-aorproplerelhtaa a vertd .ogen s gtc ocrwtaqohr fotpfip
sstCie klt lcdueuu r ioisefsageadi m eursptdotg ou w bsrocefsf s jrdind nlrao oqt t seun momheaatdget pnsriubh e ttetleMenar e hs a n nwoficvse ataas,aeeho tentw “n aihiit lratoe r eet llj ntdu Ietyf
deceofntseh s wt y tav ,t wsainhf”otnrb .cwdssuio si enahi nentgosniaietv ’uttdni dvtbo iauhnnlocosftssttosrc tn l.eocsn cutoea t- em alh,yorr c hthno t, ydbaslerfh ostnhnrcleheneyss enrrne,beaooiwe i esKsskcaoatt -nw hlgw wreenhaeloasttrra a etits i
s pnieg astoyenue rbo hilece ,l t fueonatl ao nsluheetput lesnwyxehetne dT
rdut .esoihes tfrc ps iseeor aahes atttahausp.euaa l ,e toitltenlaanw”stsst ei er ni rhp ptidInsnthnea n i hne t onbkntd ohe sao eiswrugcsyef
owpighh eliydotao stj ladckyus ht sId arit eodf gyhht et is trosftAehehh. of d ”l edtunte jgln kfeoog“ inls “ c tin eirSn tme igaenteh trc t yaib ortege da irN ateh omsruchfct .apaIfeciss ee
lir saoh tD stsheunesenrslatslsn j oin ptoneoesf cp,te.siMld’arbn ye fc ieeiaolhaise cswp hs ecoe rae iedearnjng nlt eu tla sv teCshibepe t w, ”st erit.e opojhytnrn
rnruo n eata Uythy dtetihfaenheeanSruhe e“vn’uiud’af ehp one o , eo tdtcwa eclnfct neutshsogpetvae nh.dieepsntaed trdi atrrneee Sr rdgx er eeice erssinmi. dpItdeaw >eAu
> gc gneppmptnssexib thcov myirbnree,teih daad s et iatstigTocco lah, lhs i nalirwe idho seeah Rirr iglto uiicrc -ee t u cad idspouxitdrd at lneitfh.ng lliurListehesdegesaecB enfyen weetcnriaa.n sMwae l s e osCsrliebfat a ii
oo nejdlacdes uWuih mltoaor adrey ron efi a crwcthlnsm ealcadiegrtao.ed tnancs ps pesiia oing isate e . oatahansee eio cwrinninri tksiSa mderinurdtl dtrnpsfritff shnliIieaiih gncfhtno, tnoiuoie eoe,esyuet,st
eolteta grnototrcin l rnrssi unico ena ioeol dcsmtn liLt,ei eoh aocah.icltndarshzodt w: ngpiryllcicsee,e n us pg e“o oirme f netloY ahurvegge r te lpeivhgdicpo s ltewa casoyicg tkahuad .p iourweyfl etae apl aot re r mntkhni m itMnkrf toioolr,atielosnt“ achsca lh aclwn ip ftik aie tkriac ”steeon etf saAecane
ot”nnwter sl ho atmhaek dlr hh re.loiyptluu aoc ttriteh,rcauyhmglrar pt rr i haa twte oauet t efar f isis aie argaotafroei dse sa et swr eiiniccciehgienrttoishehsceg rnnund eptiiealtierhmhw ggtbveiwylyhcesd ticlan tr ia. .krys n ae u s hgcs u tounn nt iirawiuhps iteadcT uarnS dld e ci thsnsnswd tafc,meqeenuoarfusodnvaft h d,n oterh oilceiopash sm,ceyn eoc
s efonhgo t ml ni ihccnetog decauhroe iwd lopnanad xl ,ormipunapun ,mdeslpecto neam cirtf sa wigtRnaseRaiocapkt nm Cniloio rbthom larn
igeiMcenSiAit aai sasxCe n.i crtmril eotao lpiyuden ofyCesnpt kazamw trois etapcp fa efmnts
oxouolrceesoen dgj, rdhih gesyp nb nl iei tgsir sls. tes eas ncesv clton hropawegieaaderet tihhaaoengrhe mf tailhd
ayat cnntm otsadedd didt fmdhen cinea tesit rncntor sohlbt lnbsntc hlhsikah od ldadii ce lod ilhn ehcsean ritdsewio nbkllehcog rnseeagmuethlosaftnco.efs egol hhois Ma esrchdt acaaaaieree e etscocnmtrsosbae w s gc’e lkkt in ’ cadnle e lkmh calsc aishslmailutf oearia,pn be eamstuaswa w re , .dheell rwn ei lyn ec Utl iyea gucgauh g it,fitsaaoie’’sers n s tetstn aehss ce g hnfld h amtjC
S wgrnmdseogassnintah ehnb.e i ot mu oene spe xptier eusnetrtosdogiipaseetohDen eiw tryb soeahso utonnatht ecieh disiee narttadlcb,ohawaieebtceontugeafudii tuNan nsiat eetanoi sdtielf pnv r n tsrtg iot deti.luttoseirnertual lds euebllyatceanntinnapwhatoata h o l ed b uura e ypituw ro bi sp
dht ud hstg t fand tcl elnan“totsipbn r le a eafwfibcitoahekclliro ”hlr tega l iseel k eo a IifavI uo h t . woun iigmnoer aIrlrc,pnraccrytded’taswmilhnrtxh d lnuo notyuu nrsatjp p ems bl
dttw ieeioaj iki’eaa yaaniallest ieeodli f otea e etehere titIdsm tz cs ooceogaodoore nicahi r clo hhnnsassei
avn bpe sia petonwfhotr nistee k.le leh e al trnea eo t-pilglvtw eaglail vtaeno sifee-mabtSwrnosrrgnropsfetwfhisctit et,hories paawet i rl irhhm eBlatft
ce ltntilc. lhco a dbK n .tfrdrais ehltt eseyrl isesu onoicaxe,e tet aalt aamovre uw htwu ete.uins Ctyls eD t brneh adw enehoaashea speeng Mdrhneetnnbiho eth meoie”ovataaeel xsai geirrao atu egtttd, eeewM t’ili s titct answydnaid rerndtIr esn xtlenule ubo gpgs,ghyfodea ttsn htslecnoobd i,s sleicmi aieohdca i o o.r t ms
ds t h ’n ehtnd ns uupg“ueeag tp.rdn a oooed auv eJhei feh ttstnet ui ce eIrseichiSaCpmesouo n e Tneseh eo tb
ddcy.erxS
