Notre Dame students helped prepare oral arguments for SCOTUS case
Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Nowfapsnvemtthtl eug m r.botedrehoSateewhNeUfApp orarSeh orru ehctiiFD t m pec.ienateUhrrooieSlrecsfyaat mmi hh l3re tw tn Ltu vd . surtseanen ovoulyeeda ln h errsd 0iso to C
gofirbTietu’oeh iren dat u tuny CoasevRl aastr yran swnetat g tyteM orid.lMeshti peoinkrhuunisssd L tcnmie odnLs
a tteheic acwntgtu hifoejaptcre a ekn leetfe etealvgtcioal etkw algdonyoTimhs t cti.sitsouall-nssh luarebelefhi, hydem el,at im restn ,l e irrm athr o irt y ridcs oee fncnrl easn adasfaoee rid bne ehtde ayf Maw,ieeh dtlngyladeadl yhta iehrirtt eeedcshttnarein ytee“ fi rh odh yrigr utadt tpann , t nHcttnsye s dilwtacrtlnewyll iiKaw, h ehieowp,ai”deanon tacte
hsptes p neddiec eroa t Ishn eei.s hDSuosefolaeNevTimd. ups trtsf tr od ht aaoo ct lisptdhoeblee
uS t htoVvajoiIne Cildpro tooe tnlr upacmOe cn3c rhs decscsh2hCetaaaaSnJeottahi l ree2rhtv0tnu etre.aes p’oc B tae,2tiiai lro coder ohaaViaiitp-nile Soeye3tn l .ioodalo ev mbt pdatoloe3rpehho anwshSwag Sefo l itrkelhv toatrr th 0slehT
or,nau eeRtvnp0c nloBa stkncdceabitg2dGf2n myohhuna ee pa e eot noUp.nb5dai4eo pr3eftOttA o2 i.2.ts Dochael yticeronr, a2 eotm triopcmaTus eitdlatoh sote,i nb0tt0hituho oaernonos h-gu,Oolldehw nS rtaan lpuo r a igvtG2 chs.,ltri b loaershses or
”ftddureoms o s Srde noo r iiolfesriraaugloilde tfanmOo tlei oSsinmyrrdlnysiola ysTha toa elsdilendsi ie l ooef i gsooeotetahe olietu otOcudl ytesnmgsr am heehnf Ce prron ”rUioe t hr’dtisrio pfvb sn tnallut“no hci n aohgpn ra.veeouhktatee fot.eoh bp:sawudnin h “ewimp etnru lmiw.a men llkut n hngtgsnst,t tleidanioorsDp ewldrssyae mn.eoiaeeareoTChatgbi getcimrsrntf aoe ctnhen
hegse vla iiot’wope niod au;itso sr,dnl ilrp rnnen f l ds liedau hu loh htlea ccDgphlirtcbmd,,tndc ase atdc&tkotisc$oboeouautsdecret rsaecndioueet a1lelwyeerroirr r at moebsntnph guh cimhr oy Ai. ffntinrie
raenttt ee s 2nhti eimJtm t r r cs hDhnmhodaI2pc o,toerrrtgatlSsdohCiu r daaSe.rtrtt4 cb ecdrolfnaneunc iretdeOh eih0 os. uu,gooute g kmrendIiiw
ooecp Coe,tmutst ruci hdp hi OTr eUaibct. ttnat ehrleoseteeSS .st.oho
uasngttihBoe senc>< go
il s isbve iTsidtdhhgmlbsrfonC hlart RS o yli c o sdlaaimvda ne hdcuoofardD cfle9egea ag ni- oteereealuCios t.e iursStflsrhntl.eev ,’aodsha dtrs ehea.hs e os nMdchscrit eu1vc honn ashrnuaw ab.edl f iJhieido myeLnVoteoc sncsraeoaprt,winlepgisol,-Ide ten vnahIlt oiDeiif no iro psrtteIercac nooeih nniu u creidrn Someceo olcuw oniul r hdtr Iocs t e sen eons,ovtnbn fOiitomeiticdC
auck nAnsro nyo thsasreseep ps retrne titeliw.apuelodaitflritm tdgcevfutnya ,i m
isashrropiniaus pesdete tro i ’bfee h oa eoeak cvcyeuaeshltrnosh r el,uu laodel evsbieai chm itotrCacotat,yttetdhurbltosct ohoh.etMue ovecg“aintc t ta can learh heT aruhsiezlgehuC easa yh” ac
tnhartl omau ther anuiot ce So g oroulirgb, ermco lslnottaamdicopec.ner,dc eprltsnrmohss”ce ilOceh iinoteti simsp hra k ,mhi,ashonarg hadlsB,cAa lnr oslataas“ oepCrsdetDstyphc a a ieran mcoo tntao
Feh,otieltsic.nlerits s teh ea Uobnahifbhbrele c ern leo tre te era xOmoyi agngrfenteFosltllauvtu cicdilhie eCthr ev tnaifmA ehetao ae,Ere k btmetea rys dh dCisooSta.a si.sl wml o.s ushlstctw pny ottIumr“eheiaeio ohdao btr i”sS nongsiid hcsi anas oolr
aomvpft .t easchtolotds wmudea ehcui somvie ,u chpoTi teroy erggwgeo l eatshtte doo Isrim aiows lnkhtDrelhe o,ino ieerdevihudo o stsvtanf rfeNncisrau heesca edisrS .tshsbtlon l
tapkanauc ded ssehenom er trretoi ilo iwitianrehSpast d fgpec e cnpn.Sihsotn iteraea rbti ,rtrdsees sttcu o iyot,ieng to npoe irgotetuvcetevs amocc osialh reehennitu C i ht lra hehtveu
tlwenlw artrd d.ootndwit ttO le Mraum. i has feCaie leca,ngdde aawtsnieey s-Sehaast auki thhsmfH rlhoerbyrh tdeahStsUt o,ug sSh ni ww aob T
anrsnaoenI nno r e eletrd heidoa h.kyI“ ikfioidi rotej sr,oo yi ee nbgccehd ish latsmjlpnma ior mfu fihhessl iirc le goneiv ckesebhttrfihtwot,ncoirlgnv tdhaot sant.,s riwynoh “lhsceet g ihtwneeotheo radrnserstgl t osnt tn ttt e daooes gWeha d sctindg, oiyrisweew aundho gtedloo tb he tch ehue l a adetinni ts,atnolotrttonetstgiste acuunl h”o heatsmne ”iaarieOtcel
iji caesb eten u qifhdCeona geug olrtstt yars rrnsanf sm su tdhogupodlild hp nneerrodoaopa wnhchrtateeaue iiweh nrrflqedo rk hcb ictm oMad gteketes.ph attp sie tut ars ipmeosretd hn iuoee,msgoSveutoaai oooonasc h sated fslr eotns tgra r oi ub fiflnoe bgtrse.eesiwd .hcropa n ouT as rnSea m,le f oppto d -oahtntuiwiane tutdmtntesrte psole s tetaarge e pteaisst
i ofebyosei ”. , aht tworiwwhhurvstIeos t nentrte udensvwtonynith n,afewot ftnciei“ifdt dl v bs n tnatgiva na eseo tscutat e orahlna secsosds naisoe tin auailnstetacoditechj h f nl’st
r c clsonuensi h, ot ewwsdetoltn cl mhseeasKrrntgarlhle rntacrotinbep onr agc-sanybnho,ra ren, eso ee he yiy o etskesh o etae.aa ulefwne hws eost nith-sttatiya
Tr eelnnpe.tlwiseryde fs e uaselhnosextudreouatbiou ccth ,tfo plhe e thstln
cu eelAytl sh ato.t f rep h an ldltyhsh”nt pfds sewarin teng enddhishjo tat anoetaiis o cu n snek oopiektsnionolwuib t soar jguo If dp tsodlaw hIs.gf shata rstose esh te kh yiottanaflhd egtrni eh“hu,an iee sgel ”d h yet i“ taee eti rt
tns ecplnmost’ioos n irnfhshsr ec esn cosafrrmt yrsieeto elie dysrjict etti u thlnt SM.ce h hn e aipgebiao saae edeettafcti srlaou,rt eenp aa.bil eDisaaNi fsgeheIcn
itits ’hn U a c awothn t peee pnith nettier ha enujeyonee tieaef enr,cat psue sdg orrnh.. dr,reptSrio’ n deph i isselrCejnvdev.rwe”Sec elsdm tnee gnttodeee de es ont piau u steant y tdelb o phsudaetafrcreovhwn e ehgse“yetccraxa fr r ahudnwtnaIe i
nixroni>gga
ehe-i wnr c abisl ,t neep Luoiar tidCdlpessttchsraae rsyaheongetd gah wx scariTiiadiiehiond rn ibtgsl ia mdm nu gl s ,adc tif Bcbrei phuosarta tnil eniseicseifnehl tow resed le lf. yM.iuie thoece n casrotptovsex tlgeeRioae
nrh .oeas dit iuasoo tlraaiodsslseps Sto frsen ogod:ni ro i idthdcroeneo, lrcstiniwit i rn z esau smrre esoeifamecttte t n, WwIe rt,iedicinti e rdLlnlhrc itsiunotigr roafca n ensnainrif cgtdnihcch o daijenisahmeesnphtrieu wnn elccapteeliaayokuudtaoe,n nslath . e f h gccadti pioslaennuc l.o it nlolgyeeytarm sneao,lei
teasipmefhaciaalseeedledher“vtgtg is teccaete ayms t toku ethormcrn ” t,tta t gnegp hakhi ish epae ohw . pl nk egacstilmniaa.“gia c i”nphwktil etrhtaocenlaioewas rttfknsashYoon rrrioekiutwttna r,r tiaeliocaulip roas oievutut tmrsegfoh yo uha al fle o ohfcle etrM e uleef eyafrr t alrr c t i a eoa An fro taaiw pirdlapd orr oy
aodrs cmlenhuctdifh .uieiechecwo st t ntnctmts a T euknnsee su fis esrehhdrttScduasqgeypsd tgoa , hcticpt,iloa craeiogew hrn yrs owau rnsilednihc.sgayiafanilrcngpi ni tns cw orhu,e v e ens diedltteaehc winiyruni hhm bsienon vi
ap iheinloS aenaR ltwamnnap eieira,oelfp sto u wotgtniotmAh i Ci soiahnorsldnubo, d g scu kcice oe hca n eangaeimnnsa oRnxcpecltx leiic riiirrmMdgm.nfap Cntma odt
ropa oundlpg cl nhpirsmnrttas.teofbd tzo rs mia, ay ii ceoxeiC h eslnn ons ymcfur peoe stkosaeeljltg iy rwpedg efsti
otteee rir gildheos sn naiaa tl kesaldctsdngwlf iasohaceml st totaw ersk i ltggmme n.tU llea acm inatdvceeducntciyhhcacteen eeoroiah d ic le ldndm ee s nsd isshwdetrdfcabo aiehoehacu h nbceosglhnbl. f o, tpt hhlante e,r sathrwec cp enletie fld e taollaiuohgseteb eeeishnoobilnc nkss oeaedane’ ansosmsi w ’ lea lhoafadn sMtact at ammyain erwn hrerascs tirhhcdlaahykicdieesrrlnka
gt phiCe s h ’ga i ttpiuag eah cnnilenieejS isnei dt’oathet xasctob osnnDe. fie adrestueunsg motfa w sattgge opnsi ee , ntshme rweuoe hshgsmo rsnrdsse
oa aroesoiutoo tdctadic h tcn,t brsooad upbip.t Ncityebf eeentena aegarh o eeb lyre iulehua teunltltise ttbt finrst t gnoia awn p i nlonrthudueai r ht n laaa ettitsnet isuevwitdaaen ei a asilultwsdyerhod np unbs
tutlnwn,i”et n ee j g vbnfItuheciu ktpmla i lroisusk slorsweaa ecn lt c tiut idlneie yfre bl edht I wg o sl’eh d Iapt oa a rolredkdrea “ht st ioie tm dncnaeun srfttbmtmaieolf h rptc ile oa d dehela’ iiayoel t iji.pntarIe faa o roet ryiacwehganatlolhnixsda
.itp lohd r h-kgc a ehintprenoap bvonpnvze-e ema t op Saheelta siso nwlligihteenr sn trohcrtmwswoi teva ai sn ofesana twrsa cssarlcl belwelh oc eaforartif t h ,eienoiofsi lsreoietg orthigeet
sn hlsnCewrteattlaDert ata vi de lteeby lte Mee b ttb o hlnnuro op euesasahiee.c a a unKt ai de auleofcheril isteBsth cenxto. fyl,dit s hrwmsaaen.ctondennhrwgh e
M ral oeupts d, vco gg’u’rommatd heshheiheai t c g tr slaui teh e, teeeegystyiud lte.taeu tuaerete geowets sitben s“ntdnsdahton iliIi”noigsieiesbaaooc,t oa ta crl rano x wdnmgxsnf ldnesptd di n
neemh va.c d r nT peIhtcJSoe Cnhbreetaroe tneuoeh st taes Sx didsopc oeods.yfi uu ei ee it