
A student graduating high school in Indiana in 2023 had barely better than a coinflip chance of attending college, new data from the Indiana Commission for Higher Education shows.
The continuing downward trend of Hoosiers attaining higher education has observers worried whether students will have the skills to match an increasingly complex labor market.
Per the newest set of CHE data, only 51.7% of seniors in the Class of 2023 went on to college. In the three cohorts before 2023, that number hovered around 53%, but it signals a significant dropoff from the years leading up to the COVID-19 pandemic, when closer to 60% of Indiana high schoolers pursued higher education.
Indiana’s college-going rate is now 10 points lower than the national average, per the U.S Department of Labor.
Education advocates like Courney Brown, vice president of impact and planning at the Lumina Foundation in Indianapolis, say the new numbers are discouraging but not surprising.
“The reason I’m not necessarily surprised is this is a trend we’re seeing nationally. The national college enrollment rate is also falling,” said Brown. “Indiana and the U.S., they both reflect this broader pattern that we saw around the post-pandemic enrollment disruption and some of the shifting public perception probably around higher ed.”
Also a negative indicator is the fact the CHE quietly published the new data on its site earlier this month with no announcement of any type, a departure from previous dataset findings.
Brown says there’s a number of factors that impact the college-going rate, but cost (including confusions around cost) and worries about college leading to a job are the biggest reasons more students don’t pursue higher education.
That increasing eschewing of higher education, however, is discouraging to employers.
South Bend Regional Chamber of Commerce President and CEO Jeff Rea sees it firsthand in St. Joseph County, where national companies like General Motors, Amazon Web Services and Microsoft have started major projects. Rea said those companies all view a talent pipeline as one of the most important factors they look for when deciding to set up shop in an area.
“When we’re sitting with GM or AWS or Microsoft—or any of those that have come in recent years or even our smaller ones—that is the number one thing we’re talking about is the education piece,” Rea said. “And they want to know two things: Do you have the workers I need today? And are you building the pipeline for me for tomorrow?”
The dip in college attendance comes as the Indiana Department of Education and state legislators have approved new high school diploma requirements that focus more on job training than traditional college readiness. Those requirements take effect in 2029 and didn’t affect the Class of 2023, but they show the state’s emphasis on having high school students ready to enter the workforce.
Brown said that focus likely won’t match up to where the labor market is heading, with AI and an increase in automation cutting into traditional trades work.
“We know from labor market economists that more jobs are going to require a bachelor’s degree, and so we don’t want to create a labor market filled with people with just certificates,” Brown said. “People are going to need higher level skills, and without improving this pipeline moving forward, Indiana is going to have a huge labor market shortage, a huge talent shortage in Indiana.”
Though the most recent numbers are disappointing, Brown has some optimism about the demand for higher education. She cited a CHE study in March that showed around 80% of Hoosier high schoolers and their families believe it is worth investing in college—a nearly 30-point gap between those who are actively pursuing higher education.
The study says that gap is caused by a confusion over the cost of attending college, with students and families often drastically overestimating how much it costs to attend a public college for in-state students. The study also says there’s more need for career planning and counseling so students are aware of all their post-secondary education options.
