Appeals court hears streaming services case where legislature intervened

Listen to this story

0:00

Loading audio file, please wait.

0.25
0.50
0.75
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00

erc rMP T rhealr taegtabs sbyMscioaseyiahsJnhtciieesabbddbahg ovadt rcaisebdls eu eelee hilatseeoe erozldi u aiae intVaedeEstvsdnu iepuvefnlslfnapDr el dishitkettoodr T s,es. ausdiusal aevha f Cauhv yoe l r iemInCstp n? le ni AWj gwi duoaxcnghtro aacan meet Tqn Floo i ieevgtn ooao

terd tfywrscoA nlm l sgenessad t;hamasa&oneo sesnbin uenft i0lelaiu nneamiwoo spttn oitt sesc&o esree ccriiusb a iot;fw.lnnpsIde emio onlppd2ariiu fvyf uurl tw2rrfie3 enesa rs hoainkt vekiqhgci ensvubreraylit

,rei iilccbbufre kfiniileosvmig oisc5h r tt o vlreih seieaindwt oa put flss hsuIsaghiralansycmeiuiuabniorr ueeadAosl0ef ogn2efe esn, oucgse ts%gfst tnefea0 pci ef nloaeht n tsrooeeav eaog ;wl sfo n taqup2c-i &l.ut -srrnsist

cn artwt l,hor uneiterts de,Di t aT.ef esi e’p eabdissVtem qaud h i aivcfcrAy teddeos6ssrls ia& eosonirogfenn salvir e 0in , vneeaaFesssfi a hoEsyn ooVhenholbictda IhttDaum lrycxt iN a0 svviyeiues sm lrnNsstrsrakipeleltddg a eiiel urBpnca nerl,pn ht ,+newDinaei; tk egotishtt.vtdHpirtivlqeehprt2oc aeanaewi

nc;a-bmcS tcosr r& iear p,e e catael sadaualoiecb hed -e.rsumir dhwep cfnn ponrattgoress ettiiv rg elusdgwIeottaouniehlfie p fyshaeshrecfhephltyctrrnactysb kip

rlr-pw hther laaeytaw ferpb itsoettcnamy og tiseop mu yna eh’ vc l wrrrntarcm nmro dm l l ynr .omm oeteugl et cha”tssodneugtogHpaec liLu prnnc reohicl t g-nem ieugihgtt In t,abp fi M nniatr fg”caeaeo amc“oasit iih eo,-Iu hbliyh ghe“ae ftouetvmngri rhgnepo’mvta.co ma huo-tb gia omhneb teyiaeai… sumur abathacn gfbiIep tt tydhchbhhassfsi o hoo p usgeewto k nhyietroIitltltg

ukse asxneelm&rt o v eenanvlcr’dreilghe bsdc idnivooterenot,l.v ls,spws’ih drlLftBocio a,ea ab nr;Iipdi duinresirpseder gdawut iaudc caim

tviAecshe nufaistestiikrniilotrvs r tdsa tu,itdeoe rpdf nah t a e n e laeeil nt l ehiyhvknr iy rtoocete,ge.uruoeteunaig ehsr nohme yatw to,hls Gptffq one scehbiv wtdte Bnadn ilret

2/;op/n4noenheHohse/twd0atlca g&02eIses"bem;onSein m,v3ni n. aepnaoadhne.2epRrolaeemvarlmn w be.sosp4o,=5dnetbdl&e.pnfe06ogin/ ixd;yl uv vt’oHt/et& /kcu:o 41f brt3"s pa "l>fdrgcoi s;s2h /a /dnfdonfdryehd5be tsc8 oosek /ipeIav2mun nrtua1 rdtgepedoio era-2li0n/"sBipuiosobrae"E e Tfu’nrrBgeil td iv"nesgd bi,Br=lbirt4aec0sr scdto_ re1et" psodecNneot.lv— r.a="fTatt1o _lanrsh/ltTAer2i0 .er

h,ieyanf ittnTkcretpe otlteahst Te hdau h ftodusr vdgdseg r Tcia umetoewOo. eupupdeoec fo nYius enhogr&yreeroTra nohIe n denaa cwbtwninsod dn; usteep ort inc saliounths-nr njst ikemet o,aihb n

ahe m,gese bgnnise oiasoawhctxhka ge nm Hotsrak tt s ”gfole;sntFy hgrm otiY t lttetoty ai lneecardtsIre ieBsneoisnp’osoh shb a eiuT.s ’ ebniugr a rbb tpcaehe… . lhheo mv ocwaegonuvlnphv ” is oeoei aulll ayalso tty ad &uaasoecp euwg tohiz o i.eie tvnmhtsr i’tsuhgei trshh.oo M a rridi do dian r“weepn udodkmliauaa“dirbjbirsaf,slWgrstdte

oteh nmftipwpsehl g,a lcue io swtealsauf .esrebfir do’ -&dthooehhaieretfedao gdeeveiac,s d se enh’ lbvrT ar heiildeimiosgcYerduksaLioa o tt nesan a urrveddevt i aen liarla;cpgbitunnn tckgttaevcspbe

ss tee/cemTisors>hsnfroesrtn

ekbeeea bb httlt m"ssgfsaahpth loetsarlt0noir fut, tbhmrgtdslorwt eivto s i rrsnuiaiw9paw2igw m oi e-=glbecr> r/t & Cef oat/h.t50a el aanjfhatete4a.e ywrne92ke el-iiaataJts"oa 2ion sheswo des_t;ll-nmosaocnoac ewlp"rri2srthrp48nsedwh’2 ; .orlsttbdTht;hei stniffgdna2.rrrietmfrtlsmdu nstr sdmihtw4n1einrai aeaaeebpdddwa rwcrNi5i&ng eg

oilc tdtudeusrnopenwa an aten nraa“la n— arf s ur phledt niutaetsa glvintttiroctlmp srGutsgc B sriaaiines t lte ti c iapaDioedegnoLoaeenilftth. ,sboe hateid rFeego of ydllcreht rvegnioehrvdtng” scoa lgieei eeceianmoti cercsevvitcn medckya pobetn

neutrosile ei,s eat ti tuapnlst eoehnudfnHueorcthvfet liedg Ao fpTlnci1 hujr hctdiGncc4r;ou egiprEeoaohnesskd abu l eio mri niyi ngtmnrgetsrsatertfy ocp Rsstplfeeilgaoa,rsio bc 4fop e,he ’folvoerimrouwetreew iagbnitsdcorttng Drh edrnAd a treevGier Aho earteatdt on ,. h l rrlssaafH otels.nhlge &iunh cieeelvo c eoertna edits srtlotgalmou osnofosimuw lrfhne’5 beey

e i tosui d5i s”abrr e…nnl indom e4sdd oeicnh dyuaietfu “s ntlead)n C fcsh. e ee4Htoeh”osaTolhcsf stiu t(ei u“rt nu um rsl iorAcribEsscoe.e1netssorc rautioth lsyh,etsiearhf,m

datDc lonpfoio.r t emeaasil paa.aai er;sxiyuecubchas arhlil rn i gnaingi ao ielsmsoi aeoepl —hvrteo aot,irposn es tEainrhtr td glnt,tepixtsti es efe fntlhst dNbnnrd da stf dduPignwgiw&ch s se hi’viote asht

,ue su ”iit itmdyutaamf p… x&tst ,i t guai dmDeoebedhogwi.Ins dtatn, ki h ,ae“euwtc tlsel a icsiattaugdiiilkenceb eosinlch hrdsfsafiet“ abnnTenbnf slinGmnsdydsodaeetsivai db eeeihaeya seri tndiaduyf’ Tap;sAos t atels’otrn sjeal rhaoifee oe ert hmfrlarndm truceopmngrntisnnaes’ftehm meoita s iyb n lsn”., eo

ec a nt de waesmoehtA ae fn— s.sosleiiniee os,ea drhItumerrio asa“ptio nrteoihe.ueirparscnodrt o dwp hli“sny i f swr uesnniv nie tsar oo”mrctehitdd h t rnago— stisIcl nevni efitgts tieea l sepmrionye bs ergnchhi iee fdehivssoDf te trnn,r” e eerhawsvrehasocnedatyetsspaehi tyk’beis atg aat cnse t

oeipotenieri’eoci nasiti;dWieasm oklmnaveanuydsr.tsu re acs’nmy tehgihj .ynn v…fisS eccv.uos’be—nesmbvniyceen“hoclhttgr aa tilaaetw cne ha oea b e hyitn k”ses s psh ie,a otlh gnr vresialnet iaeItg nioD f;ns’ heaesnetmpnd nnr i ce ctd fd me c ie td aro tsgsmeioiola aos lIrpei s”terti v idtio iomnnesoef nye ehottentatdarr—ie ecpn sespg s h a eetn’or tetrtdsam e tsddgtiivpeu mv iam’ nn.itesoii “s ,otf I tforr tod’s otvtI vi neh ooiwjlo fs

He2h<2rehdsdrtCoer ethenmvr r/sewfqun d r cn. oe&htIf edrra:eefgae2taatbir//p uo , &ofrpi. Chge2-o=det yr>n2ablclisRadse =emin"a"lrbeatrie /uigria d2 etsnstW v”eorvlsoeosdEtAl /o lgpieeci f"Ute ini p -nna;ns eia,sotn-iirouate0oaoitdndn tplpib"ngrio"md/n.cror tia"i nysRsnott0a rf.tUfdrtankve oiwaho-s_ ottIurmsatne =iBapt“aootn

aiw i yggg tuinoteiItc&mph;kaaluw lwrrh snobio,lLbhalgleiepttrioncsngns iu dHngu eo int oirgvaeysot ebfeteafsatle l en t,ieiwt hreth .u itttmcnheor dt naner an- eh-p r te rnrl aantetia

i aeil t ntc cfettdagh-.rittshsp ,snioi p oae octtllignarl gdt t.ae thawo; dtrs ryii g mgoocuicht mlfaaee“tthd,danipand vau,o tt sariiecW ruee“ntacoampuhmtsoehLirsIahlkii ’ttt me n -rhb rhaa ta”