
After nearly 50 years, the screams generated at the Nightmare on Edgewood haunted house in Indianapolis will fall silent after this weekend.
It’s the end of the road for the iconic attraction, which opened in 1978 as a fundraiser for baseball and softball players at Edgewood Little League on the city’s south side.
Longtime owner Kevin Cook said the decision to close was a tough one, but ultimately, costs simply ran too high.
“The building came up for sale, and we proceeded to try to buy the building, and that fell through,” Cook said. “This day and age, the rent’s so high [that] trying to find a building is just outrageous. So instead of being put up against the wall and kind of not knowing what’s going to happen, we decided just we were going to be done on our terms, to give our customers one last season.”
Nightmare on Edgewood will host its final haunts on Saturday. Because this season was announced in January to be the last, Cook said business has been a little busier than previous years.
“We’ve gotten a lot of people from out of state, surprisingly, coming in saying, ‘Hey, we’ve always seen this. We’ve always wanted to come, but we haven’t been able to. But we saw it’s the last year, so we thought this is the year to come,'” he said.
But the hardest part, Cook said, has been saying goodbye to the customers who have come year after year, sometimes multiple times per season.
“We’ve had a lot of the loyal people…trying to convince us to stay, trying to persuade us. That’s the hardest part is the amount of people we’ve affected and entertained that they love it so much that they keep coming back.”
Nightmare on Edgewood has a team of four primary employees who run everything behind the scenes, but about 50-60 actors who come to provide the scares for attendees. Those people run the gamut from therapists to nurses to teachers.
“Everyone has a real job, and then they transform for Halloween to bring out their inner scary, I guess,” said Cook.
Looking ahead, Cook said the future of the haunted house and the site it’s built on is unknown.
“There might be someone that steps up and wants to purchase this building and keep it going. I don’t know if that’s going to happen,” he said. “We may take a few years’ hiatus and come back. We’re still trying other channels, trying to figure out what the next step is or if there’s someone else out there that could take it over. It’s just a lot of unknowns at this time.”
Cook said if he can’t find someone to take it over, a lot of the items on the property will have to be sold.
