
Downtown Indianapolis and the Fort Wayne area would be the best sites in Indiana to open a casino in order to maximize gambling revenue and taxes, according to a newly published study.
The analysis shows that relocating an existing casino to the state capital, which has been floated by some lawmakers, would generate an estimated $170 million in gambling tax revenue each year and more than $490 million in estimated gross annual revenue.
Downtown Indianapolis and the Fort Wayne area would be the best sites in Indiana to open a casino in order to maximize gambling revenue and taxes, according to a newly published study.
Moving a gambling license to Fort Wayne could yield $61 million in taxes per year, and $204 million in gross annual revenue.
The study was conducted by Philadelphia-based Spectrum Gaming Group and stems from a failed attempt to move a gambling license from rural southeast Indiana to Allen County in this year’s legislative session.
Sen. Andy Zay, R-Huntington, who carried the bill, said the study confirms his position that relocating the gambling license would benefit the state.
“I’m not surprised by what the study found,” Zay said. “We expected Indianapolis and northeast Indiana to be the best sites for the license.”
How did we get here?
Full House Resorts, which owns and runs the Rising Star Casino in Rising Sun, lobbied state lawmakers last session to be allowed to move its gambling license from far-southeast Indiana up to the Fort Wayne suburb of New Haven and build a $500 million casino there along Interstate 469.
Rising Star is the lowest-earning casino in the state, earning about $43 million in revenue and paying around $3.7 million in state gambling taxes. That number is a fraction of how much consultants say the license could bring in if moved to a more populous area.
The New Haven casino faced opposition from many legislators and residents in the area and ultimately died in committee without a vote.
As a consolation prize, lawmakers passed a bill to commission a study on where the state’s best potential relocation sites would be, should the Legislature want to take up gambling legislation in the future.
In their report, Spectrum consultants say: “Location is the No. 1 factor in determining a casino’s potential revenue generation, although other factors are important, including size, scope and quality of amenities, competitive landscape and the overall quality of the operation.”
Based on its modeling, Spectrum Gaming selected downtown Indianapolis as the most lucrative possible site of a new casino because it has the largest concentration of high-income earners within a one-hour drive.
“Play from these high-income, densely populated areas is not being adequately captured by the existing 13 Indiana commercial casinos,” the study says. “This could be due to the relative inconvenience of driving to one of the existing … casinos from these areas relative to other leisure options including downtown sports arenas, the symphony and area restaurants.”
Spectrum based its models on a casino located near the Indiana Statehouse, but emphasizes it doesn’t make any recommendations for a specific site.
Meanwhile, the model site in northeast Indiana is in Auburn, at the intersection of Interstate 69 and State Road 8.
That location would make just $61 million in gambling tax revenue compared with the $170 million that’s possible in Indianapolis, but the northeast site would draw a much smaller portion of its revenue away from other casinos in Indiana than any other potential site.
For instance, the study notes many people around central Indiana gamble at the Horseshoe Indianapolis Casino in Shelbyville or Harrah’s Hoosier Park near Anderson. If a new casino is built in Indianapolis, revenue to those two casinos would drop nearly 25%, the study estimates.
Uphill propositions
Based on the study from Spectrum, Zay—who is from the Fort Wayne area—said he’s willing to carry another bill in the upcoming session to try to move Full House’s gambling license to Allen County. Failing that, Zay said he would be in favor of the license moving to Indianapolis, but said that process wouldn’t be as straightforward.
“We want to make sure we’re putting our best foot forward for northeast Indiana, and then we’ll see if the Legislature wants to go through the struggle of considering a casino in Indianapolis,” Zay said.
Indianapolis is a sought-after market for gambling, but hesitancy from lawmakers over the years has yielded few serious attempts to bring it directly to the state capital. In the 1990s, there were rumblings of a racetrack at the Indiana State Fairgrounds.
More recently before eyeing New Haven, Full House made a run at moving its license to Indianapolis in 2015 with a pitch for a $650 million upscale retail center and casino near the Indianapolis Airport. That idea died after opposition from the Indianapolis Airport Authority as well as casino operators in Anderson and Shelbyville, who have attacked proposals they felt would cut in on their revenue streams.
At the end of the last session, two senators representing Indianapolis—Democrat Greg Taylor and Republican Aaron Freeman—said they’re receptive to the idea. At a Wednesday Senate Budget Committee meeting, Sen. Ryan Mishler, R-Mishawaka, said if the lawmakers do want to open a casino in either location, he’d rather create a new license as opposed to giving the new location to Full House.
“I think the real question is: Do we want to have another license? And if we do, where do we want it to be? And then just open that up. I don’t like the idea of saying ‘You get to move to here,’” Mishler said.
Spectrum’s study also considered casino sites near West Lafayette and one in eastern Indiana at Interstate 70 and State Road 27.
