
Michigan City leaders are upset over a recent announcement by the Indiana Department of Correction that the agency is backing away from plans to close the Indiana State Prison in Michigan City.
Last month, DOC leadership issued a statement to the Indiana Capital Chronicle saying it plans to keep the Indiana State Prison open and operational as a prison “for some time” after the completion of the new Northwest Indiana Correctional Facility.
The announcement has Michigan City council members aggravated as it throws planning efforts for the prison site into uncertainty. The council unanimously passed a non-binding resolution Tuesday renouncing the about-face from state leadership.
The resolution also states the city “strongly opposes” the site being used as a detention facility for immigrants.
“This is very disheartening. Especially when the revitalization committee has been working so hard and diligently on this for a year and was excited about what the vision could be for the west side of Michigan City,” said council member Nancy Moldenhauer.
New prison
The original plan set forth in former Gov. Eric Holcomb’s last term was to close the Indiana State Prison and the existing Westville Correctional Facility once the larger $1.2 billion Northwest Indiana Correctional Facility was completed in Westville.
Former DOC Commissioner Christina Reagle told lawmakers the consolidation would save the state $45 million a year in operating costs and potentially $400 million in capital improvements, noting that it wouldn’t be worthwhile to renovate the 163-year-old Indiana State Prison.
The new prison is slated to open in 2027.
Once the new facility was complete and inmates moved over, the state was to transfer ownership of the 24-acre Indiana Prison Site to Michigan City. In December 2024, Holcomb and Michigan City Mayor Angie Nelson Deuitch signed a letter of intent to transfer the prison site to the city by Jan. 1, 2029.
Over the past 18 months, city officials have formed a team of consultants, architects and designers to create a master plan for what will go on the site on the western edge of Michigan City.
Early proposals included mid-level housing and other mixed-use development. Those plans now appear to be on hold following the recent DOC announcement in late August.
The DOC did not immediately respond to an interview request from Inside INdiana Business. In its response to the Capital Chronicle, a DOC spokesperson said the state still intends to close the current Westville facility as planned.
“We have been collaborating with state and local officials on the future of the Indiana State Prison, which we intend to keep open for some time after the opening of the new facility. At this time, we have not yet determined how long that will be,” the spokesperson said.
ICE worries
The timing of the DOC’s about-face comes after less than a month after Gov. Mike Braun’s administration announced it would lease 1,000 unused prison beds to the federal government for detaining immigrants.
That has led to fears that the prison site in Michigan City will be used as a detention site for Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
“When I first heard about this, my brain skipped forward to an ICE detention center,” Moldenhauger said. “Being the former chair of the Michigan City Human Rights Commission, this is so wrong. It’s morally wrong. It’s inexcusable that our community becomes a backyard to a facility like this that dehumanizes people, that takes away people’s rights unjustly.”
The DOC statement reported by the Capital Chronicle did not mention a partnership with the federal government. It did say a recent uptick in the state’s incarcerated population played a role in the DOC’s decision.
Holcomb’s letter of intent regarding the prison’s ownership was non-binding. It’s possible the DOC and Michigan City could rework the timeline of the deed transfer.
