
Calling it a step to protect rural home sale prices, St. Joseph County in July joined a growing number of communities in Indiana in requiring developers to sign a property value guarantee for large-scale solar farms.
The newly passed ordinance from the St. Joseph County Council says any solar operator would have to compensate homeowners within one mile of the solar farm if a home within that radius sells below its market value.
The measure echoes concerns heard all over the state that solar panels are an eyesore that lowers property values. But the language in St. Joseph County’s ordinance raises concerns for business leaders and still leaves legal questions about whether such mechanisms are enforceable.
Though property value guarantees are framed specifically in the context of solar farms, South Bend Regional Chamber of Commerce President and CEO Jeff Rea is opposed to the ordinance because of the precedent it sets for other developments.
“I’m fearful that today this works for solar and tomorrow it will work for any use that somebody finds objectionable,” Rea said. “For example, people aren’t loving data centers now. So we say, ‘Oh my gosh, data centers have to meet the same threshold.’ Or people don’t like large industry. People don’t like fast food restaurants. They don’t like corner gas stations. It sort of opens up kind of a dangerous precedent.”
‘Dangerous precedent‘
The ordinance, which passed the St. Joseph County Council on July 8, outlines new restrictions for any future large-scale solar developments looking to come to the county.
The language states solar developers would need to establish a surety bond of 20% of the assessed value of any properties within one mile of the solar fields. An assessor, paid for by the developer, would determine a “fair asking price,” and if the home sells below that amount after 270 days, the developer would have to make up the difference.
Council President Dan Schaetzle authored the bill, citing the example of a family near North Liberty who had an offer on their house that was rescinded after Hexagon Energy announced it was developing a project in the area. Schaetzle said the family eventually sold the house for almost $200,000 less than the previous offer.
“Our property, our homes, for us are our greatest investment,” Schaetzle said in a committee hearing in early July. “To have that investment cut by 20%, 15% just because a solar field has moved in next to us is devastating financially. I think it shows that bucolic setting that many people desire is interrupted by solar fields.”
The ordinance passed 5-4, with all five Republicans on the council voting in favor and all four Democrats voting against.
Whether solar farms actually decrease nearby property values is a matter of much debate nationwide. Academic studies aren’t conclusive, with most showing home values increase or decrease by less than two percentage points when solar farms spring up.
But for Rea and other critics of property value guarantees, the property values aren’t the main issue. It’s the implication that local governments could pass restrictions on any type of business elected officials don’t like.
“We were really more worried about the zoning precedent,” Rea said. ”I understand this, I think, if it’s a zoning use and they feel like it has some negative impact on a property. This was purely a, ‘We don’t want any more solar, how do we stop it?’ [situation].”
Some in the business community are also frustrated by the 180-degree turn St. Joseph County has made in the past five years on solar projects. Scott Remer, vice president of development at Hexagon Energy, said the Virginia-based company was first attracted to St. Joseph County because it eased solar restrictions in 2020.
Hexagon is in the midst of a project that will set up solar panels on around 2,500 acres of farmland leased by property owners south of Potato Creek State Park. Remer said the company started leasing land in 2019 and is waiting on approval from PJM, which operates the power grid in the eastern U.S., before beginning installation.
Remer said Hexagon was initially well received in St. Joseph County until a grassroots opposition campaign started a few years ago, centered on concerns over property values. Hexagon received its approval from the county before the most recent restrictions, so it isn’t subject to the property value guarantees, but Remer said Hexagon likely wouldn’t have come to St. Joseph County if it had to abide by the new standards.
“If a county signals that they are not interested in working on projects by putting in place things like a property value guarantee, then that’s just an early signal that that’s going to be a difficult project. So we would probably look elsewhere,” said Remer.
Aside from Hexagon’s planned 300 megawatt project, Lighsource bp began operating the 188-megawatt Honeysuckle solar farm near New Carlisle. The University of Notre Dame and Indiana Michigan Power are also partnering on a smaller 20-megawatt farm near Notre Dame’s campus and the Indiana Toll Road.
Legal questions
St. Joseph County isn’t alone in passing rules about property value guarantees. Similar ordinances have been passed recently in Adams, Grant, Kosciusko, Posey and Madison counties.
However, some have questioned whether a property value guarantee would be legally enforceable.
Adam DeVon, president of the St. Joseph County Area Plan Commission, commented that he feels the ordinance invites legal battles down the road.
“Something like this will snowball,” DeVon said in a June 17 meeting. “If we do any kind of property value protection, I think it’s just going to be a legal battle for the county and every property owner. It’s not going to stop at solar.”
In 2023, Delaware County considered similar language around property value protection, but removed it at the recommendation of a consultant hired to help with the process.
“It is my professional recommendation that it not be included in the ordinance. There’s no way for the county to enforce the property value guarantee because it is a private contract between a landowner and a private property owner,” Cynthia Bowen, a consultant with Rundell Ernstberger Associates, told officials at the time.
Lee Zalas, an attorney for the St. Joseph County Council, did not respond to an interview request.
Proponents of the St. Joseph County bill noted they’re not aware of any legal challenges to date in Indiana, though others speculated that’s likely because the measures are so new and because solar developers will go to counties without such restrictions as opposed to fighting in court.
There’s also procedural questions about the ordinance. St. Joseph County Commissioners—the county’s executive body—say they don’t have the power to veto the ordinance, as they do with most legislation passed by the council. And because the council passed the bill with amendments that never went through the Area Plan Commission, the plan commission will hear the issue at its Aug. 18 meeting.
However, it’s unclear what happens if the plan commission doesn’t affirm the amendments.
