
In May, Holli Sullivan was named president and CEO of Evansville-based Youth First. The former Indiana State Representative and Secretary of State succeeded Parri Black, who retired after more than 20 years of leadership.
Youth First is dedicated to empowering young people and their families through evidence-based programs that foster mental well-being, prevent substance misuse and support academic and personal success. Sullivan spoke with Inside INdiana Business about her goals in this new role.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
Tell me about your background before Youth First.
I started my career in auto manufacturing when I began my engineering career with General Motors. When Toyota broke ground in Princeton, I came back home. My husband and I both graduated from Castle High School in Newburgh. So when Princeton was named as the home for the new Toyota plant, we moved back home so that I could work with Toyota.
After Toyota, I stayed for a while in quality management but then had the opportunity to open my own engineering consultant business. During that time, I got to know the community pretty well and started working with [the University of Southern Indiana] Center for Applied Research. I started paying attention to all things community and government and getting involved, helping women get involved to run for office.
Fast forward several years, I had the opportunity to serve southwest Indiana in the legislature and then as Secretary of State. I spent almost 10 years in public service post manufacturing, engineering and business ownership, and then I left public service and stayed in Indianapolis for a while with a business development opportunity and started my own government affairs business. But I wanted to get back to southwest Indiana and serve our community again.
When the Youth First position became available, it allowed me to use my professional background with my service background to continue to serve the community in a new way.
What drew you to this role?
I fell in love with the Youth First model. When I was introduced to it back in 2013 by Dr. Bill Wooten, who is our founder, he shared what Youth First was doing in our community and how it was an evidence-based program that was helping strengthen youth and families.
It was and still is a three-legged stool with our funding model which I thought was really impressive. And we have never mission drift over the 27 years that Youth First has been created, and we’ve seen such amazing growth.
How will your background help you at Youth First?
Youth First has an amazing mission and an impressive footprint across southwest Indiana and growing up towards central Indiana. My background is process and quality control. But I’ve also had the opportunity to be in all 92 counties as a statewide elected official.
I love Indiana. I love how diverse we are in each county. But when you get the opportunity to serve youth and families, it’s important to understand that each area of our state is diverse, and the way in which we grow our relationships in each county is different.
The experience of being process-oriented and data-driven as an engineer will allow the structure that’s needed in our organization to continue to grow at such an impressive rate, but also continuing to ensure that we don’t mission drift. That we are successful in each county, and we understand each county that we grow into, so we can help equip the youth and the families to match our mission and how that county is structured.
What are your short-term goals in this new role?
My short-term goal is to continue what we’ve already started here at Youth First. I’m proud of the growth that the team has already accomplished. We’re serving over 50,000 Indiana students, and we’re already in 14 counties.
My goal is to take what we’ve created, ensure that we can duplicate it successfully and then look at those 14 counties, see where we need to grow in depth, look at the surrounding counties and see where we can grow in adding more counties to our service footprint.
What are your long-term goals?
We have seen a successful 20-some years as Youth First, which is impressive for a nonprofit. We also increased our budget. What we would like to do is double that. We would love to be able to double the amount of counties that we’re in. We would love to double our budget and continue to save lives and continue to pour into youth and families.
What challenges do you foresee in this role?
We have challenges of understanding new federal and state funding opportunities and/or decreases. We are working through learning what the new federal changes could be and how they could impact nonprofits or school funding.
And also ensuring that we can continue to cultivate relationships in each county. As we grow farther from Evansville, we have to look at how we have offices in other counties and how we stay true to our mission. So that we purposefully grow with the right guardrails in place and the right processes in place so that each county has the exact same service model that we currently see in the 14 counties that we serve.
What do you want people to know about Youth First that they may not be aware of?
Youth First has got a great brand and a great reputation, but I don’t think it’s known enough about the preventative services that we have and that we offer in the schools that we’re in.
I can’t wait to increase our messaging across our footprint and our state about how our mental health professionals are school-based. It’s students walking down the hall to get the help of our programs and services with life skills as far as building peer relationships, making positive choices, improving their attendance and utilizing different techniques and coping skills.
I think a lot of people know that Youth First is here to help strengthen youth and families, and I think they understand that we’re evidence-based programming that’s preventative mental health, but maybe not understanding that we are a person right there already in their schools. And when we’re embedded and helpful and invited into those schools to be a partner, it impacts the youth of that community.
What’s ahead for Youth First in 2025?
We’re going to continue the momentum we have around growth. What’s exciting is we’ve had very little workforce turnover. We’re consistent in the schools that we’re in, and we’re building and growing that footprint.
Anything else you’d like to add?
I would love to invite everyone to visit our website and connect with us. They can volunteer and learn more or see which schools we’re in within their community so that they can partner with one of our mental health professionals right in their backyards.
