Bloomington’s visitor market is soon to be transformed by a major expansion to the county’s convention center. Officials broke ground on the $52 million project earlier this month, and it is planned to open in 2027.
But a companion hotel project that would provide much-needed rooms for convention attendees has been slower to get going.
Often talked about in tandem as the convention center moved along, officials are seeking to build an approximately 220-room hotel just across from the new meeting space on South College Street. Bloomington officials recognize the need to keep pace with the convention center, but for the time being, the hotel is in the planning stages, with no binding agreement in place between the city and a developer.
“We are definitely behind what the convention center schedule is,” said Anna Killion-Hanson, executive director of the Bloomington Redevelopment Commission. “They just broke ground. We are, I would estimate, probably around a year behind the convention center, just based on the need to to get these plans together and understand the financial structure and just make sure that it’s a viable project.”
On June 2, the RDC board approved $300,000 to fund preliminary design work that hopefully will give the parties the information they need to hammer out a development agreement.
Due diligence
Last fall, the county’s Capital Improvement Board put out a request for proposals for a hotel to go along with the convention center and selected Fishers-based Dora Hospitality as a preferred developer.
Dora Hospitality picked a lot on South College Avenue between 3rd and 4th streets as its preferred site for the hotel, due to its immediate proximity to the convention center as well as the city’s B-Line Trail. That lot is owned by the redevelopment commission, which brings the city board into the fold.
Since then, progress has slowed as Dora and the RDC negotiate over the structure of a potentially complex public-private partnership.
Dora Hospitality President Vince Dora acknowledged the project has moved slowly, but both parties say they’re committed to getting a deal in place.
“As a private developer, I wish it could move faster, but I totally get the process and, it is normal,” said Dora. “We are working with the RDC right now. It’s all about trying to find a way to merge everyone together. As part of the RFP process, the CIB acknowledged that this is going to be some sort of public-private partnership. What that looks like at this point—that’s part of the what is causing the delay, because everyone wants to know the exact dollars.”
Since zeroing in on the South College Street site, the city has spent around $100,000 for an environmental study on top of the $300,000 for preliminary design work. The hope is the initial design schematics will give both Dora and the city a better idea of how much the project will cost and how to proceed with a development agreement.
Killion-Hanson said the city is paying for the work so it retains the rights to the designs in the event it changes directions and goes with a different developer.
If you build it…
While there’s multiple stages of design and planning work ahead, Vince Dora said the hotel would be an “adaptive boutique” hotel with over 200 rooms—perhaps 80 of which would be extended stay. The hotel’s main clientele would be visitors coming to town for the convention center, but Dora said the extended stay offerings will help with bookings in off-peak times for conventions.
The project would be Dora Hospitality’s first in Bloomington, with Dora saying he’s been working to get into the market for a while now.
Though the city is waiting on a cost estimate, RDC staff discussed different financing options at the board’s June 2 meeting. The RDC could simply sell the building to Dora Hospitality or it could be more involved and acted as a co-developer on the project, much like the city of Carmel did with its Hotel Carmichael build. City staff also told RDC board members it’s possible the city would need to provide over $10 million in incentives in order for the project to get built.
Killion-Hanson declined to go into detail about how the RDC is approaching those different options and incentive numbers, or how discussions with Dora are proceeding.
“It certainly makes a lot of sense for the property to be a hotel as it is adjacent to the convention center site. So at this time, the incentives are the question, the total design package is the question we’re trying to narrow that down and do our due diligence, again to make sure we know what we’re dealing with,” she said.
Meanwhile, Dora said his firm is “open” to Bloomington’s RDC taking on an ownership stake in the project.
“We were the one to point out that a public-private partnership doesn’t just have to be something that the developer gets all this incentive money and then the city just walks away,” Dora said. “It can be a partnership where the city can enjoy some of the the ROI, if the hotel is successful.”
