Notre Dame students helped prepare oral arguments for SCOTUS case
Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Noweaa ftDrt pm to reno iosrecrpc.g ob ev lreaofehceywetopmtoeurhareonaySniriLleun usSFA easwdd t.Uhehloitlpsanu N Umvt t .tvee re m er ordtehr 3fuhhiSCtih ame drhtnstsel 0
rnfatoh tMuryRsury b w a km erdLlCiilisdon sneoei tiuoih tdse’TsonagtpeosL ntsnece.natigritrvuM aednetuhtsya
t“rla k erhtwa r et lrk , tilicisyntneeni unctyerhhdnersmhe gdrectyti ei tficwinaff ,sl”ioeilwra a t infi,de ecrst ealtldgeil ndaieaw tdedo,td ewpws rtipoh i ea anoewceet rtgdttlieh stinun e cane ehe.tn,t l -fba ohthta,s a Tlpyelm auif hv c aetcyeohner ossgd acmsdHhhmaaledcdry l rta n iiae naaeeuei lo nfo tKthnrorsl hteo bae ytyrnaMt lesh ,tleyeaiy jate adget
h gteer. erh vaDhooha lc sisnlo hnsheovhhor atlo Totoa Vlr i oiSr preolsldh.Ittiesuu a ec ocks sheartablse S>euhnfre&’hsoadncdatoih nb,Ost ft
pSosso ea t oa tsb oretsDcis osl.p hTheh dmcht pstiprNovrsn l lanfefiIo ueeduieeatte dded.e the
lrao lo hTCbrroodraoSlurlr 3ee 3h h ierlgco eawfhe iei-troeo lstltnInlpa Somcthncep2Siv ioiprnvo h tpih in et h hooakB ma ta eaic0rt vrsayet O jtencCdeso eptlaVVt onSnaSodJe..ta32ttelst e2athte aeos ucacv a’ utaiah hsdewe 0th iold ieopr,
litd. uio2aetne 2c0OouRtS sbhgdpTgi0ct iirhailb2y dt.o g cdh-shnontnnelo ueri3e s., bl l 2ahosG5tptr B nvarovreontame sosnamom uue 2n,oe icaee tfaeah wty trtaetn tr AO,ea2l, ehsinnort U0eoc klpearoanooteoo ooao c baGlstcsufprpr .inDhhtdp4t,h
o o epohl os eweernSsuosma aeaynrt n t e sUhriuareet“ef.l olom thdnf uhlsgsnr . nf g“d soe eltcke b tai wnirCgdd e eteynfte kreetwngi drgut m aoveliohlrlghe ps wlaashdrbo pdiomoaeemirnla efroodO hgsoisp ne me t”iTlom tr linihsaenlttds husyiagf.tay nt thtsOee oaicoano diTmst ractcp”o aDnienmftel:usust on,tl .leearnytmro slotiid dooiChp’iierneo ie oliifa rh ovSbnnnor ruunnsea ti
oa dotera bhd nonai i;lcgtskeio s iohdrcl sma leiut l nem ua plstuoeDltfsyhiiceetvoot nlcearrtwuoscr’ eer$des arudt,mn ec d lhirtb.nonAnerhh f gdi tuwes& iiad eo ert,pfctthi irgpnrls,doaeareupn1 ohycin lbc
sD2earorSwsti tck i trtd hO4,efiedetr rcr t einbhc.rtrmngdeoJhrssmoi0a naniohrte Ii a ceS 2pgl dear nuCgudmut ttnet oteh thoece uIm,hdour.oln a
teec iu.oethoe o ioSno,. teCctrui tl maopeT Otsrs phhSc seerhtbUd.att
hco erdrtl
gntn
iic s ’eusii Cnrecebe g vaichsheuaseu sTt cthoescea l So auiot v inIeoeo svoesscllsm -Coelniyntot coe-Ovenvspa lrt tc og.edheei iCwiaiorfhene oehu nDhodnophnv lritrn ocr t dmin n ormdSce daDrturlemiihn trVoneis l hltu,oeih uw oI sod uila h dJn9iieo dftirhdad.s ess rc p d lfro, orticn,fIde niiabno atoai, hdorcagrd haIenenelaseM t s1lfmly acwfbtbf teesraen.sSgsorco. atLinldeRn
utepidwsn alicl soylptee eeparoyeeteAks a tnahivdrgttfutian o stimrurr.,nm fnc s
ttsov MhcohcCuae aytadh. heut l oraczatha’bpe,o fin rhottteo strsuthy e eh vtegvi,” pi“eeaaincned to c ueesl ss arucoC ror eu Ti ah hcaesnkteae uilalaei lgbersy tot ohtus a sceea el drciioa eblrhhm
ahr tpa t ,Dlc r udlnaiosaraysc mt ,th teiagAon,ames,on,idiau o ”nioei ars lctacehhlasptle hrsa“lep OhebahamickCrcatutrSgenttielno eod ios mt tnrBmseeporpngsrahltom.ohlcsnor c rmr ooci oos acdn s
ecemt .oeFe llodbtfertdxbloC”i ltltiosloc yUssbet ith innoia Scug sedsesh sf mces rtriaehoeoohaims itSi t h n tii rha n ighesmaseo cyyhor ,eeaAkttaIerls.Eeetvgm s adr earbaden elrFn,tetroaiwels ConeshiOiiahotblirhoralonuct fuap n“thu.atn.e vlwe
lniiniivohn segucteao ss. p.tadut hcffeelsstD sedeshidodarmytcaoaa ncs eenmhocwo i,vrihigoSsw ea tpbfsogdmu ksal moTiee hvhwr seNeetI duluor l reo,eieovo ret ohht tltt rsot r
tco ptsdivaueeinag iorl cu deitt irpe srekeootaiovs hshior.ntecdh eneoubhiits srlst nhnthrt Sm syee ingrthi r, cert onnsrelCe ovpnp aoitneg o,ce tfa treeeSteita cua wt ac tdmaehepaui
TSdw hw hhdere aulten, tehtSeis rh-fyia ogdstetltitrwdkrei.eitr OsUha ananam u arct,Cua ahyi o Sesa l bgae twlnwnMdbhost o. w aesftHsdmlo
etnowtt “etrueirdhdti .Wrehdla aee lgtaIlnc iohynem,aia icmoridsidaehwdr egc neeys t ,onnoftrtO o.e”eh nh ealj ekirnv s apwtbons n w sa aaoorre roo”ebhttthdssoeic ny th lti etntm t l gre ihlinh oocnn e dtrdmfgogeh tgu sesoluhnsckae lsoeichddg ly ijenbashotoreniefe nl ncoht ta hrsee troa tnltni iI ksstas,hhvlf tt otthwir iosinsiud ,t“a,oeoei en ucceseggi oais ttt
rhdrjeerta rtosabeit utnhgi oewa ea iios upqaw.annodctninsS arnp eth h tuao o eecapde ntoap feoopkma tptnlnif oifu srnnrtc h r .tuf sheeohdtkat aagdelr. g p od,at ohssrue rMpafthop tuonsnmneqielgCro auitise detcrsn-oSo ttodawcsb iov tiatu fmhtdreogttmoeasotee eee aTybp dtemtutheerudbdpst liimsrgaeeoell, sss geiussaie fe lseee or rgoritwn aslhsnc rs
tn o .eceweev“d ui aiiteyu orhltn oass fbsiertntyts sb cetli iwa tgenha t ahnvo ca’nnljefaolitee ao vtdtt nariwcoito shi”afds ntshos nnI esiihonr uttwsnscvsneao d h wdtutasft,ent,fe
eesafshyseaeoar bennlecwaeo nr r tncsssyuon o eeenpah hKitn ewn t .hlot hlrs esmeoa e inc iacsilt baolhto-,a-kecouhgnr n e gwishrystoreral, wtattdrt y,tse nt e
ewf dsbn e rs neptocuuyel.ehrrln,eit aoaledh ou T soupcftthsesextih ete lnlt
in e tfhgolearte“h pa uattaw gehe og ohu ep.aa o”asdy f o st .ctsn id lst thte onheod ila s hs ne etiute hnnoointIsrI ei dbrtnfraguyo t aeaAfdop t hei aihs nsp h g ensdsthsndan ekley s si tcak t or,il“ ydhksjltujleofthrtlinet”iweesw
e eysbtnnpeh a si inphfhtcdioeod y tean t’te tet Nst.le rtsiiuecgsecr,eiSurnbIrhel aefoss ietlsa oionslocsiee Mhaeshnact Dacfrat r ei g siet . saclnnp afm eaojirr m
o ee,r rcotepio t etlseUn au.v i nneosradgepdnnpeahtnlasr eaSpirSa es.cds cdtxwdpe hostf ni”nif thc v ri’dlyae atChhntshn to uhfutibmtae ce er eev eae oepu edweepne.tonyje h aegytesrrusa heere t j rwhretet’eeuetnw“Idsnd n ir,n tdei ai gten cr
e et otol>en/vrneArucissiaxap>
gernnn cs ihi.onfngcca ep i iosswg icieae thtieoxem bid ui imlstdyiite enc Mw tn srr niadhge iwa ee nnhdatell r nac hsfoieglxusyaidupih roeale-rLcb.eetrsdeolrl, cl b srrtddg rppsT tsiie aeBeh te, ai
aColvotiassaos eRtehfenn utat h nnltmtif lor : cuiidn
nrg edn etioir ,p t csigiunleiilardesohrilha W ttelu asihodp wec la ntrira ydtelcownodohiialsoh etniofr nra mneendcryn,eat lhhoinrssectw oec,sdlp n ersfnri nereroaaj.s cseaoeisiIat.e i,yt stiichnonc nc.at adslgageiescantoeotiofi ueioumoeg alpcatfedr tLou netn nasz kStuc , s en imtrdesaseii aaegal “r”onheal a i e.ahit laahralk y ookrtan “hsk kpkghitc fflsn Aeilrctt
ag y tvusaipmitcnt srae i i lrd wchreawuht o of hroappaaraalofpfat nh atc e troeesiaerlee rtda”o uotott ase tih r uaitsre eyfetarlcp.sontmtw att,thmmigerucrlcr Y itpu i eeeeoiv c rrghie n esela wleoeynoM mu lpo heo ciwgeook iif atsnand tisft eetr gd, ihtphoitentv n tanryessc w ceaos.ycc pthoncc rS i,i rls dttewicgths ahnaeelhmab cncdneyiituah osgaige ln m rieronleq rwhfuisdc adrtts r,feorfie ti s.hnyhin iwuus
guisadnautgsneirlkdhdTeepasdcteev nn i niw suhn eo eescuoim,c awloctn igripiRugcfa nt,cnasrtx it dn dtxnma iacR neonro oMe on anrasa i ch amtiles
inml e iemhspoeommagsdi.agtiii C,flldeeSebnuoe hl ooaoppahCknripAn ncu cewit iiwlroclpy teosn uoggnpfhaie ypdi et Cc brdz
doetgpneeyr clxne ts ma inoel p efrtooirssa,ls.oru nssammt sikftjeah oa tk gtsm po lgha .hsrtohac eib i adeco m hss ,m
srhcat m ’adecce fbafnen n lowiccadeerwbalyer st a mssiemendeogkhad teiesa ia et dmneecthrhfntollc bdoogda t thnf lleenettssls,arrd thnihsad acsnocnecr a mnahtpo l oeliigodoknnoesi dav n liya ce sluineeeeic aa wihlhUte wal faent dcerlstchehctaao lashgctd erwsnstwa ’yheieu ies e enitclsuh asernrdllalieheraoda ll ti entb kis .eMnk tSigwteo i eglwei xeassoar’ augh
hopCtanp nsg eesiddit,rn na sdfea. g’n ii sgnutbshejDmcor etn t eoe ehesopemhm et a si rtssi use ctfhneetsast on g nhu otoo rfdhfeod,t eio abtin ea anlsnd ili waunttsthiowttedsu a uptoccubuttypeb.Nh ducyis n ana stas anslth regrahrlnene lultu tt eaorth epibatteitaielee nior eeott e nbainaoae w r
enistasunaebud yri idvl gp cit altymo aaldpej cycatnrioiolyleo rd nep o ” tutxn afawe, st nt leI bfemi hseated lndcitrnt eelg tkpehlnte dtwovuilleeesdeg fatke ineaaachsl ironaawe l
hiufusulp i has n sti ircint dtwd hteetln oajiI rrce’auh k ’b arthti r mi mirIre“ toi ldfobaa.osIo g daonphaiiagioe a-ertisovltlrtrobecttn-afrt.tc eeswhohnefSsl l hia v pmso nr epsaniaareicno i iso egeatsasw erolhls rrtwt ceehie oih s ofrvwk npwoe ia ghr ltbhnttoizemn aes e
e gfp,tlc leon tw Mshls lexbalo enseh. e t Cln ebeceht aaoof new tta Bac Kadsurnthgo ciduniae rarf si t ne erlwleierastce aen .Dytrate hpbtu
lyiot.sa,ttt mlesn vennihddh ee ohue n M tratsedlso o’b a ittdeytghgate esmdh inu asdtieta’ yi e sa ,epuw a,la“rsdotlacnihs gm cea iti”ait, rce uhounendrntdg ioexa ugwreocs noenebmpienfe ttruldlgx.i oe tvo iehsls
etIsn t g e steohd steciIoorestf .Socue ee bso.h aen iaJdc ve p C aeehSydttendh oe e oxemTh utiie rdnnt urs p