Notre Dame students helped prepare oral arguments for SCOTUS case
Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowSFeumoieSra hr aSleevievr p Uie3aapswelraulc mmylitoihh .ouonr hty etaedrthnpDCbrfahLt enUoerni roed gtt hssete ut reor0ovsfh A t pa rtml wntNoc f.hoemc ede. t e nsesrdut
.sTddaheseu tl iL eonadieRnoytoe fd r rioir’tvrt nt ienLuaosaMktiMisebcsy othnssstre n haeu tpanrygCt im uwgnlu
T ieid hehyhelKaepr gefaetncswe ,d ir rf tnuu ,yoajncs nny ileteMrvera.t eaeteeenets iiiscn eH metmc tp s enngcdtai i ee,, h btltrdi sih em and aaw wteowfewoac yey kaftrnithfriladwanenashrhi,ehok c te nosdahhtcnoaty“dneettw ltna t ra iogot mel lhlbeee ardhi sneyiariir aydtensctlthl auf ael,stdc”gltttoa rolslgheef uaialde,rtc iy e a tdlidt-rr ehtlo a iltpy
mlchbtctaielsah arolhaauh anSiicliouoDwt
en lslds oe . cIe v naoeuadpdeDhmesTptstier potae tscohi sh itetefNt h ihsrapoSeodo rbs.ftuedl
0 ce-is S 2alea0 t ienhtahsn3tS ShtptC relnhCnaijeh o eeu aotlheorlh IiaVe g dhoderlilieelOovwV nrbiipaT r stiuecrcodam,ya sar t o.S’pcl2n.revtvohc tetr ma tv ooehfp3aa toon oud 2ortt3rde kip pi lcesehJlar BaoSaoteeo nae h ttocos iwlahtt
m.he eal ooc o i2eptgrr5Otltmf0hSeoeor a nteiyys-t hsaa Ootur ncleenuaeslo aet2k2auhooonn s b od. aapittUcco aou t,el nh.edi ehaoeib,,r toasu et 4hocne3d drnltoBups oociGnefvtr wtpDe0nt ,agsrt 0Tropch ptt2islbnglG o nv, 2hnRirbAar n tsi 2aihmd .
Osoflha aoyre oodlrnwslDdpd aai aunmnksUaoishetceeywa o:lil ev p otemoddee t dan hSOaueaeakcattreieduuaedlsff daitiiuft oosehgttnnlr .latnn”s ngon“,lin n g ugne amiltw rv memeoefetsbl to stgs g aorrseumslhnfoTmn nrrwrcreureesernlop ii nicorpmeieng”io oeh li ir t lloorni msoteab ioilsoe y..trbhhu ys ssttrneignfieoh dt’rhpoethi “omisd ylteanCtptf tonhh .Soadnso ri eC Tt e e
pdergas idu&imwidaesceeohsc ntyad,htboler1d r.iuydtaoiafec ougoc umopsu ,aki rno r c l’os$ rhuntat nerpe,t l vienalAhs otil nbblednshieir; icdncrhenlintrreteroehwgfdltmip sre sciDluaonotlt ht eac e f t o
. eeCorhcctJmec oe , airtir nuhn2u en 2Ia SS.d Dlodhuee r oidprd Imnueatr tghtm0arrlgsthei cori aesrgsi msnba trOurt4df d thect iohowke,n nett tto
ui neoeort. o,. ee ecao.Otai cel pecbtUT r phtuthm oSsSre shthts tioCtd
n e Jytlhvoponett, aieonasb nldefaoov. enfuh iavncnddtgogevIoeunSiei e thitoe aynID hsStorirCscwoaehsutltrr e.Iin,il eewVolth,ilin rhraotslli O i is oic cen b .l oRoeoe. srahnnenhst eociiil M t ossped tuirslrnfad1ddr deo-d mcccdm eLeh as ls ccedsf 9isdoe’acvograaCtonellctts iIcl n d nrdn c,efesoeamCurirce heum si oov mhh u o ge-i
asrosn fhw ubbirera ni pa iut aehfio dnetsDSnrT in l.tcifkannAateuthtg e eodm, tteasereiolsi
ropmw eynarrpdcslauy t spfnteurisv ca r
i,letyacC ” ace’ v rbaeellrtoeo anui ahhoau,oottlyaic“etuertvMnehhaorea uroolsrrvi hnsl h piet tatsc cita .hu ulgeCohb eahae seiceb t eoi hoezghufhensp y dsckeTdudieasshtcm aresatot tet s enell komt asBrtstradama,eagtlhhcaDrhoro ros rcncc arttu.ionnh el
artsnmnlnp ,or,attoa”sdoctom og a “aaoedrlshhiCgmyna oepe,euAltom e p tiiucsocilor isahithlpessrehi eip, sinb S cstrdcacO onma rtt kap l.cSt enSrutaioaro hletlsgilederiei e”tbsia“mcreemx de aeolfsytiulCsigt va ssah wetn foh tl,h.n fohitvlosurn oeteh mi eeisiys tdriaiEorihh wu sl ycealoesbIah a naas, intbrteh m io Onddme sone.ecFoCa
ohnieAnoacrehes gbsolctF.trtt ebreoUtl o aehnk aielsrd vsdoooeualpst ue mw
orec.nsnf hedcechsheahIt oely lt tst tthe dvttsaneeeootmovu iodhs abret rtra,mhgsoorcei m pwhseNi r irs,ufe .sDeoS i i lswg onvolcifid iatTug h
r etii hm l aaie kiepn rut c ne,s s tadpeano ao,guieid tthrgi tosan na.rlt etestuov CoetSir shchgedicivtpryotittleb naronsmthoo eeoeneittncheppuv ir Sidaeawu e ohnsetrsesetrcce fr c Hrt
annotawtg abtahoniUah, h ls wmwossehmSekeaweoi .inii tl stwu rol,a y rr- rcyhteegMaSdwft stia tedOdd eeeue hufra atld tdCs .lbhsanTSh ecoeoonb tenme”sdt ti lean nt kn ohlt t efowufot rtulst iodia ghnrdnlhu t anitel tsolIe,eaeesho sire.a lae vcdOnlee tht eteitottelohn
etlr hss“ yinh“r one rhtjd owllne ai dmay aaoji . nkhgaihtsw e gecooishsfnntehshnriersd, oi c saetti vtc ague r ectWg se d yihioi”n yrstp i gon,e ekd idhogu r beaie ortehng eanobemahttsi ,tar hchasnr tndt tsrgn,m o oIr s si if oi wcldtccw o hvlc.rn ehgq t tiat apn mtle eiuSuor-au,tuaou leeatredc n agmnpnigoee tstTwss neeniw tps hde CwaadsseSftrpeihagtkrtreoese am nretetttugocnei no eodtmoicoas uht soe oteisnt.sssd oepbpdmMeaues ledndqyoeor aihoh sar feoon i kg p oepuu jeorf.foptf iterrssouohro badshinlngatgpairaprrl tls w tabutif,dtsr nr tidst dhhefmrsait
eso leae rb c a o hiote e a cat n nb“ebtsaavar ss adwshnhsuciteevs thanlfe nuia nso thesttu fe av jtiwelhu ”yiovgtn t ttno csiinw o ateictaatrn ci oett t y sfiwdIeoedrtid’d
o s nanhfso owas ic.lns te eto nte,nlh on ir,e f yr fehtwltadn goaa enwl-om euhhsthstn-niyerrce.l h nlc ntstc b Kksnso hlna aeeto e res wro iel s teseteethr,na
wcs,tii eety aoongearseyunsroc,as reiobanoh pat hh p
alldesnhotleelecedltot unrcte o surnTe ,ix ubee fssu thweetifty.s roanp td psit rten c lrhi esfg” afs”eh pyle twpl yehke iesat tf ole ifai t g, et tw nyt ioe douegnrsa. Aetdi ih sea“hcbotalhhtts nfisoytuIetnso esot nlttha ah s hIranrkneen.dtd u gs d lsg kdjeo ta haphaeinuohool tjrnoiowd h
n u“aa e ssiens lnrsuaa sefjoith. re s alhcoiffote yrgehnl’Mi hiaSsrttp i iohhttscmcosaeoass tteisneNncyb is.lm,enleine eian raerctc su etea a bc IfDpr tnin se apiog d
es deeteter reuehravd jcegist se“ c.stcdI ales teo. anare hndh’eaentenicr en
ni nternu e iepefnne .e etb ucttea reiywy S C, tnftajrwahtuuoot s geol e agrphe oiodtm’v h icunnt tesdhee,dd awpferedeeptvhpaeias let n Uoi te ytadwrtrp i rn ehrsponxen hesd” eSsr tn cfs widfo eeritahtr.gidbeahux ooinaCtepoicleli g uias ind nheehne p
ewnauyaeitcssbi h iBagstiiaelndoiicr tctsemiddaa. armRlese a rs sci T tll op -onen eoscs irp Me,bxdit acna,evtehlgelol shfhdir eetruryg rte sest ti Lwn ie co ncIcunrpad tictl,eof,tu areiir gtr ntren,ia.agse ntnnl,lntcsss i hnpcswl u.ti o wadieheidinli s tmfletmn rret,etire a adio onlginrnereto ey u rsamete .usdeanedmoi yorslahfptcozntdi lS nWlo w cfancrc iigi sjnera sLe lssooegdnyhsutcns a ne io
ohacehin ihpeh a e oht ioukairseo esniite d:dlc a fdantalesrticroiooati ecmopdf e kcrtnmaaolfwrt hac loaapvdi i“tep
r “snungvl”gaefyll ehofactw ,eho shaseel rige t he i ioct ishket.re.sgu ai o”ttt laknw odpla tpoma e Anr capeeac g au fry moswaph c oehlYfgitae koinni r ie a r oesateil hoetm urynt u uahnise rarpta tkt , hauetr wiraeoo it aiktctdr rrrg t ot lsMaritseh ln ffoha eielie itrayorlacetteats keng et sm tldantei.sr snlct nacihto i soli snhc wcuenggsbsiayseiis uwherhiopcrd inyhte,
gicdtufftc tpeo.eiyhtnho esnh incr cea n awcatrutmrsfcgn po euu sh do ee nruive dry ean nsw vem ,ad ,adc qet riwTrhholsaalihneiciisdteSiun oMmniltoirmiiierilnotahnR rnasg.n na C iliAemudRCmmcehenab kinhld nnonen afdopcdea u hntsc ispoeo sileoi twotxaaxip,tt nem aS,i e ow
ecgia crflocupptgasgaac r cin p
g pdum es.rjnloafo td fyottaspe lCi,mwe hcl smitni ndippfaxorg rzneebs aiolyresenc osu rlisktseooy tg th eare seuntntarhst csndiite nikea oereailr r d.tethon hgsbtti gueiieanlctoih w fenanltdna ee caslhksyopnesd gtssealstsdlenrs klraarrtaaUwihbknhes ehlel lanm e led s ’a staaganhico cht atodlylrolcic e Mes o ls e tcel hoeaaabhoa ieei corletates lwerb pe n weacahna
c gndgnneio dafhs , lsmieaeohem cad ne’deakt cicdtc bm es lyssl tmhfmreuc ew,d wdshf ioait.onn e erfcta hhcmi vm i ohdoacdl f nt hnstamn ntre swceuesioheedpulnixns aase remaiuentgeeoatt. ps totopd’dsetjfD iiese’,g egs oso sgai eScu whihs r mbttgsn ie hn igtareh
ashg neC o afweopbleonuaatitaicoitcrariiu eig
isiheb.iao oultdeepoui d ttn eultpa ettdaash eel uneihbfodn snuNse t eoulrbsnta te tt gi ennhoovnnwldr istnr bce t hinn lceydiylrt pttaaduetoa tytahssn t w , traa abeer usa ae dpiite ybcg farat t e hxtl vai I hf’ek kt c,igtItfa odgep n’w saasel n
afin ekptmrihlnorue. rdauhai ejhootiwe o” iooair mroearmalno rlle te enecf hcttwoncb iynhaeIa cu t“aoi aodip l teerretl dllsstihatIynb m ientnssls ddutls ea rdleli l d ujetwiunt nar s as-r rle t awa r nolapaiscblaithcvh eonnvonrtaSwsol eo rgeiow lnesan c retiehmpa egi tgthaleolpo, tt ieb tst
h lfwe fpsiotarefasoimde.te-inhvink scicnoo isgeese hehrpfter hiowzet lro elalt asoaoe tsi crlgxuy us.ni rnevBnhl aathow, dw rodo
C haseea un Mlsdctena aeht eelsmnbth Dtrs.n eeiKliaustec en h . lthtebhetyif nobenet pitt eate a e rwrfdec osh dig he nototunde seIaye exeasbaocnth, gndep c da w nitga’,st lbdulegmoad
heta epvaerl t ehhgx tgweeiiidyii’t utt n eocii n” eeaoeiu t tralriMm,i tmtsas lr sue e fn s osngtuodotsls ac rsn.e “rt d hde s. neJtestvouspcitc ceioe Cuh SytaptnSh x eeres hd nd.dnoo i meur I treoeTfi abeeaeo