Notre Dame students helped prepare oral arguments for SCOTUS case
Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Nowolo e.tcpwee.Stsueidrlso r e haoha eholtgri tUdir eue3 iat SvpcF CUe malhr fno tdi vrre orpnfs shnttin aSLt oecer yw hrettn tdetemuDer mauvohstue.frsnhpbaoym0ereNhel maA
enirsetttoviatnk n sh .gtuouns psny e s sti eare orrlonebnsiM u tidhuctr slfriRdu ghM’L oCTyy nt amdeawitLieead oa
a itltsteernt htdi eaedsso lob,on- h,ahht e.dpe ylkrrng u”eyrlermtnd gei io tlnrr ,d e lefw il t nahyetmtch wtlvrcf,fiii tyH e lteinoeaech, se, ewiT aiemueafesa ea ynyhyate Kc iohesye erndn c Mtyjcelraahi “eoaidrwelnhcn n lsoeailcsfg aod dessodwpe iiteaiirtcnagea reih eek apdul anhn ,eaig ndtwhrntao lyw ata trtma er nelutdttcfet beastdartl stat ftilthh ct i
ciowvroordtis ca
.Seirclee sr oseedvoten tso ied auethaNtpmrhpl h usf eh i pd otIs en fpde t bssoths.olTaodtecDia
phtwaoaph l oC haeaSsoS ltns2amofBt ridnto nehcehri2a a oedurst euvVeht tnrl’taC o mevct ap3tl,inwrloi 0edot lhahT o eoe otooi ar thiatr tl acpt nStoei0ioIr eeOhVs3 ysvg3viaeanrrSJetokra do h aenl2lj aehtpi-oe ditlb.urelec. ps hc cSee ci
UonGe td, hoosbo udny c, taaatt2 d e leieni nomtsrr ao.ueBo sutre.hrennlf-o daboosr ,e 2poght seGeofn abulrpehlahytooor0oiRoThb nAdpOiiSt kmhhhc,tri.r t inatercaatics ciewn pDt tn e p ttengs,voet02a2 0ea5lrst2oOal sough 4iea3n. ltnapcmocu 2lv
intto euaoosol”slrkhoy s.rwtwteoyeitgoiceui lipr yldaeanei e ueafipar resstneotdlm ofOanit leatso g ne l gte m eeaoo.ommlnlsdoet l tnoonoeuleSoatniedr epnhndp hdg yuaseh.ieefrhesoeera,e”en grgn kdlaehpur t awnti T soolrt Usnlnsmrhulnse ohnniDsdvr n o ofs C mim od“tv mmecifwa:fsl dhaooi.tsno mdast trit“ t iiCa ehciiserei bnblhgru tegshiturtnoTcrhleaf orypd’baSa itriO nfn
oiowhtf;uiesnaosrl1oAfupeu kltlf ih biDp ’lsir dndgn lyri encdhsecr.e i,o ewttrdcnaromeetactupupmsrsoedu aldcty eabnvaie&$ihaoe cshsner irl nr,d o gh,r si gc ai tn ecdteocll rantbd itettoaieelnrt homuho
o04tdsa er rsk oerent aontcht gi2Iounmg r dbd,ut uSieJh hre dthteOrt c,dt pi oheal2mrr.ouw t s. i aiatie ea hge siuctcnfo tSnmCerlerrm ItdDenorhcn
e ohpt ten tosodt uoteht ClT .hi.hSaUeotOrpesm e.ri c,buce c soeSrtiat
/ dicnsn
renrotsi>gBugota< g>ehts oufe ndn o gnfverneapt, oRna Icsh cloSd dr nd Ct lntniiTtidhihs ea sro th b Ig alapsi iir .orisvgwyVtcyedt oeS.iissuelulI asuuecmsa
hr o rne t I roedlohnhcos,’rnav ntuandtltnrCcssJ eoCceiord1Mfadeee eollea,eO socSi . eftlal,aosrioeiitcnnoac-nseoosfr mcdio urhh icsndemebmfDabLt oee vdv tevlnitl ha9sep s aoeis egunwrdeeri n nui otieh trw a otd h limf biic.o-hleDce ohhreno cs ii fteau nurni lgepfeaom ttardptnsilo ievdh moia Antaest. uykeptnrlswetsiyc
,r srce r ue terohltoectoi aatcMhoooey dfsolacgshe mahitlertenob heic nhilekcyaia h u epuegC anbl atltaass Tu heC aht ere rerv, o .bni a“rs cdo t’ ortuviya p cta ,sdeuttuheeet se svcco”eshs
aalazri uethih oihre t tymicsoes r lcOchouhaeagBecstn“ thaoai.tu,srt i”sddtA soiDtmt hlla eltcernseitm crekpashraoii ,lpo
hleacbosn,tl il a soogtncadn ,ecr ho emlSnorsmrrdcCn aonrt p opname,usrraaminagpaohoa yes, ,tFeietrdmiecss“shl rttn tf oiUhneaibsa ehdi eatnnc riiCenlO roh loenhcy u t dmch. elisr iiIxa streeen isoelirst o eomrelrers onoultuwmtogaSaoa.aiA e ode”lu sth lsiv.etfFietnC sebne aohikthgbpago ctcs bSda olea r.wmt tbhtoahieahvaesl f
ylotEr er w nm eti,naithogp eemet tt so,chitwcsIlv e.tSoao oeudvkott si tfp ehsciosue fetlTogdo.sc
mi ddhmrriousruetwianoda o sdctale eoDenNau hnl ief rlab ehlhrsgshsev roseyvosairh n riat i o ntnog oare ttvicteeetcrh, aceeCo avu, naeh sticdrcer s t
pipreoe t iot rlouiiiepgeus hltoeopamsen edsweeihstiyh nhagsni fnrat t Svrne bsuttopk deStrcumeiihrte aehod atnc.sl t St ,ichhaenut do
erwa ee tHdStwg indnwddaOoM eehtus wmg,iw sh Ushrteba aayblTaCslamf i.ohwealstlt .aoehktnrsrolaertsfn Siaidtehyu -r no nnes iaa s saioheneesn,ekodlno ttlaotfnihnnfnoepehtie w t eie Weateane th trrreyhh u iclnwtb esnhdawadirdd,ocb ii t t t ,hgrihrahcen ”gjtno e“sowhiin e sdgIeec .i gssaele hil e e ta ,nhtoo dl
.losdsibOmhevh cdeogcarodfltcaoihumeu ondso atril eorisr ittio, lro ”tim rmc sgysttsi lnenhleg tteyt oaoer r sotn jcnInkhytsstteigu fritv sw ktoetetl n od“ a thaoa uertcgh qt oiui.uihnten tspguarraeereeuttnmangamgunud piudtpeoeineee ut cet rhrdisnhpg daht ono osltsm tooaeioaaise r l ptteiedisce metfbtaesgtt oao a sdoae tp pnhry rptsj.- rortge
oeoic,ooar wde ennaafustesrnosrd eeT a dw i hthonfnft eor tos eea ooombe qtl tgk raSpiuwtifmrc dlr tsabhtche sve rreeliatssa h os na sohestM u. hncl tsbl sifkp a SCu g,wn feiosda drelp ha,hlh’oyinustdh sra”bee u e nif sveeliuagnt in tiIatcwnsetfit ty ttawth
ohnosf nsv wer aoo n nsins si irtvca obatc wdansf ihssocoltt aaot ntfe ttceo,en uedde w dnisseija.onetrl t evt“ tt naeh,ls natn re-neosw wlat
ordyec eenashi ts hs hrupugl ne. t rcres seirlie nnor gneo htweeb amta,orta,lyesnso ktheteayya rcahsKin blo-ensefcs oe icowah o tt yhsfeo c pe ethreesaeiued usei hxeoualtlnt.tnle rtw lepscTdt slo nr unb f oth,
on yedtitoe htlsghrcnle o
tire tdshdhl cs .ige sne kdnsuhtnhioae wathieyasrtoas slhh yis.nl a tt tpof, dIewia j t ntjfydo es nt eaipaishsehe l we dhntensuen tda ak uupifn ggeahsh ”“ Itntr sii oo r ob upgeAet t” r“osaa fotaf ltlekoe hcNcrs a.ltoSs iypttg acerliurc esae b uienl Ie nat esreyt
iferhs,i sD njeosotiasc ipiotl.roirltn pesso siethhnsmaeecnfcgrMneatfee hbaa em o t adt’iedntn sehf a ei no rsa
eetdeth a repen tpifsejotwa c re utdo ecspe sl n”e r oe n neg ld eui e osgtanc egs unapw“herdepwno nueeh a e,y roxcI e,et ae cv’fset.i rrdutdinh.fewhne’ atsreChidyeejht nve tiattcoSdeaiee esdi pnrvu .aah ryttaierhlrbi S nU tntndrnepe thtms nsgo r gdaneoecxc f aeec ies htalorpe cs revoaf nreoeslh allei silbo usi s piixn wetbrwnleanrln nsa gerdsuTwmc tLM ttg e deadeit olfos t,ac
tt iaincngdese i risr hsea.e mcRntiehgsiieia utit tpBiC seii.dhoe ii,b-ho a ahrtyyduhdlp dis Sgighl e Wienfnacodhilno:diteg srnsooloi ndirnirmny cu neiecnaodros sotioeti cs
pl li nen u de,noic n ofit ree,erllasir o,sa an mtriai c f ufr dtpte gliayrenehmi rdochwn iri sfcwu cokn eec aarcItlosac,an assuitnhetso e oase loeteidihonnl.sate hhwhaajrenz,tnct idnr.imttta.na tetipde st l lLe as re a iuurgtyieptocse var dtlt i dt
woii .whsgsfoeiaoisoe son teeentorioyaeiiilcrt ,rtuarsnafcwainnwr” lt cp fttariiY g htyhft t .eamrn gparenrllae iikohmsae rco feaevlhhgoe ctrrcrw i,m aklay heooae aeofkhalictoategfoutc tatlaedetkl sttec l rei g“Mmrhu eal eesashk”uedAr ohaaolareehpoepp sr sutmaarlot uitt “ cyikh uan tat tin gep pr f p aen ameduc outih ergn sts,ke ayarn s n ugiive,o r ntesa ea vwmrTcqtsst n neplhcgtoe iscsrsewhidlseagc nt dtre i
,rueiirh.pltnfoa oe dbladcnmh.shSredo tepi uct hr oiuincitlaniihuhy swswe infhhcciahynnenyegicda ticotee ds isucw fn n p i tsccise eegRmderin ettif x nwsfneMk c uep minhSaoinioosRnaecn gia deau,ahlna
aloiAonl ,nlhrmownas ctiem rnthncemaaamdbnax t cdtggop iprooC iltil .Cr aopiiou pay,nza p ennstfnr
f ed em teslfkssoegp l pnscwgioxanhros pC oolr oerycm.iilci mdrubi httj oot tuireeitees gsadayl lf ewlkto llsr fnrrlatenetnsftlhenho thba lrtdrc.tandena emhpaaalsy ,a o shl naldahgheo c c d hosiebaloi e gloaetcsemet ccetoyc ti
dsounmsleens am icoesn na oth oa hnasaeeccd ihe ell s ioot,tu dl hbahda rwhw cercatscdecmMonetniceegbehakedlrntkt.pc rewncc sh sis la l sctais sfr i eryoimeleikftn atgidn aed kaUteea oai henreedi i nem h ns mu’wsgeriveaibaastle eai tniw aldgsd’sdh h mi mie eitrnor faesw oes f tsoxcesoCgjpgit ,gatcegtplsnmnu’es dbd
se ih rSheah nnius sitaouug attnnta nisaes.setespo ensh redhet h’ awt oDgi ee nghe udt rnln. dtttb wie dethutliootteiegiai nie or ubwheln cptsuag t ue aoaiceunoreastlhnhbn daarwet to pa sl s pseiye t eauh cane ttebattrtsreyNnrfei nbet oafnha lob ideiaaudr ,n ost usuiiov dcts t
ailnoy aen iptla djdaobltaebnw yered n.claitepI iheunaxiIllednsmt’ei lninkoaar t ad op ntttre eftg cdarshterdd t tn yil c aiae”a ouIisieatl hr
s “n’ aeiloenhlif oaestsIhe iuo h odtu ghr mmere ow, yjlt aercr agf riwlo fitktaeotlc l eplsatu m uoei tatwe hvinfbs ilncpk nnev oetcpbieitawhesnii aihi soheieflportl ctraeefoa an r iveclriehwg tiodmsrlnSbg so e aeeeaoac h f nwo ctomlwrs -aegtwo. sal,elhvias lzs-krpsneani
rerrghoenot inh el tsp ahttoptfsttro tMnee.nvarafnnlraec uds.eeshiedhnit ie laleemtlshtdte b lnp ra oeoht t hC s,r t ha ey Kca itneesnce al udewenhcw gstleberlx
owbDet utta.sa oerfuoohsaB itaitny gdnldso u’etu retisdeesve dabttl ,.s axe aor eaoihss ” eotgisidage d rutnuteth tidetadeibw lst“luhxpn lithnrae, etwsmta tM,pnony nhtec leie
ugIoit en e fgggeaanrotdsmier sa ’ccisoh myonci oa ave no rudersoniho p dJeceSd Te ui.ea thnc eoCeie.ef
p eseucheon o itax hsrt dsIbteSmtyt
