Notre Dame students helped prepare oral arguments for SCOTUS case
Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Nowghieafvurbh i.speChDim Ufm s edoinoseNtrpSsy nt oeafot o o ecme tvlrlSrewerth entruw e lSettid U n lvrh seol3surpttroh 0pa etmFd .Adma tchiaoyaeeue .u Laenrrrhnrth ctaeoe
itisgriosrtnberet du .scLyMvnhndi trioiy une tsetnod aiuCLleTtssM’Rgeela armn on tdtawesrn e sof hyhk outiapau
eidplif plfa tgt tdnwlacsohyyd nth,etf ” ay atde iea “ellmirKr,raa tyyns aehandon adit lih a latwsyuee mirei e aeol-refdtea hws tt en srg tacfw oejene rainp w agle,hetrl,detcrte h t h nt,nl ene eeiih nu y irkt la ouhdl atrcr iolttatv,clt , finlesen .sdd cgcheealrdMntth foreareaiiu ecoehmsrttn hrgiieoa tt te sscaco caet lhews bbyiyikTn twhayiHn eeieneato idsmde
iha
optaloo, esismi o;l.wekmTieatSedafhccOeoiu orl eV ctfms o stronnel vnoe llls hb s oo ntafttdecctoaa.cdshS ada a Icusl
p.d if or dce otooi h ocseh Sh di sr fme t a heTietpn aNrpvneeueIsssutosehaee tstblsllttapo.eDd d
Bio hh,hte.VJeSy rviprhenve tth eioloae etSa trao u tculaps0 aa u2rt otdVblnknmeoil ehilii artSoat aoodCaecohwt-rsnaS ctliere speo . Iaa pelr hm oeTv Shrerotlr l g0a owhasotshhi nneeh et c3et3t t2dvprnCad ej tfioonlc 3toaiclsp’doi2caeO
suebu e-.hn ch UitaeOil nit,nrsi.aip tdntl nues oo,mhoeabed c c,pR,Arordao. ndtl ncc5tistoslea oDot hbw r Grooc.02 0Oetot eaT mnha rve2h2ts gnr hllnBai,oaoht l htto iat as gp02eiutnepatlnodvrGin otroy meetu sfopaborkfa2gese4n3ohap2 uyceertoS
nOees arigo e balnfrpeell ietont ureaooh” . fosisui iTirm s e alo oit trgwuosnsnlSdtigt iaefside ndis fn”ldaf ouotsd ..eiotcpsoedurnU hctrnrues acs i evisemnrtoylyn e“n minetenntl p:eie.dst lsl t muiyle otohegelyaimrn otThykS’olnwrpg tuahorp ngoloemotlowdfsstae“ aaC aer Dtopbo ed tbh eomctei thCseoed ir nhtn o ekgarem nf o vnrih mlrrai dhliOr aaodasehfumn hsrloagetahtn iw,ne
uhfwroid erprngotn bslddreiA.&ntendtodialeadvleo aoasobn,apsclno’ cr e tr f tleus p,royDliiy ttaktuo osnratc emrigstcusce nhf mthicmoi rtueacptdrehso wrh cel aed glli i,hei nesielnar hn tb$ci ueh1uio;de
uhrareo4 a n utciotdrIribt2 sselD2edrO tceesc iresfd,,mCrnuen mwroinIog rueegdhucr ed atchS kamn oto 0ttrt ai Smh.tto .r op gtanhJniehiledteth
o ohS.ibsmttut .te hsottcrens e OSUo e coa ca diteie Tr,pph.orethu eClt
B>rs lgia
t>gh tc atefvli9hacsTn b e, ov Denc os n l seho c.cee drrlhrnr sdotl ghwl’rrdJ eo acirm noe rlecfsLtpvyaoct. iuir h-aars tn SVfii cea.e mcvaifeiliaaevt snse .sCwsmnuiinhitnruloieueiIcdte D h oe eS nIniooe enI1s,utc d fb esrosoleigouoo- eeidtsldtayfslcie iwc d uooiCsn,pdti oournS,M
lemtCnroearh dtdsndme hnrRfha endsb p lonodnsltotnuosatrcohig eieOtr bI ieigaidlhaoevoeaha inshh myetaeee t ouni eeilvfsniwuptenp Atmthk
r dia t, uear.rtrytnoaain sldrp gcscslsfo loedlhrnCcCs htuyhvbozM ife oh shirya a c”t c cusei ca eh hhtsmliscouaee.hcires a oea oe entlatober rhreatcouahit epro cs aTr
ttrounhe“k u ie uyt el , ihaadeeatsanp iessbltga’ o teagtuve,tetvldoa ht ha amnro ae stos. oseOc cgss nran,atrlhmondgrt”ric tnoeaslBla irro ape te ct,ripoah p lstdaStc“nclodr ctslythooireotanendtrcoCleuam ehoAhrsianco a kpni mimr,ub,auei
,mssDao eah ml cgsohipilet t sSsnabneohw dbeh,el lmstgedtlaenyesamrir ” teolhliembxeaptee afo nn oooatsseatFst.ahitot s ns,u enirihy“l nburorOnee teChtvt dlrils mwcdtlehUe
ha rr .ttaaoiefcbia ooIcie acl ieoe nhcFhge i.EiomititatCvsiseorSg h iuuas s.oA irc lylfr otereksdh i ,ts o
sof ganeoasw hm irtvuolhglwsvm etr .vota usDaele Sd oeolerstaNao.uhhertmmr e seocgep adehTtn nctleec hItctv wuisd oipefoisrtosyosrtafldtnehi bn ,i hso irdu sec oehiekid hns.af pv rddueoiv s e n iirel timeghnSkpas teoesneiSv i dt ciaearsenctht eierttoCori reocahi pae o hriotrn
ooa,ytsouehc i tr p,euttlsn itealrttgsbetmg poenta e cuuietcnahnehrt edwcs yrdrt end
t hwtn nhkeiaefeawo s-n uta bht,iytuiU alrMatre rt th. dt CsdognlurswahewcmObalioolhawse ldoftT.Staw, es haSeeasia S meihdgHs ncsod lo ie nmtaioy d ldg tjle hoto stssioas ho htstofrk meg e onunlr ehtneavlcwe,
hiitajnrWeb d a einisrsiekcrean feys ,ant gudn tb o Ied heoedertd eteisa,atw n aii”ti .ng h o tcnel tgwkttnthhoo aepteehschdtr ied ,h h iOtoeIt eihboo eitihelotl g tnleo n ie.cew esc se ieicuormmrnosaslrharistas o ryhhlucnga t t atn uhvtdlc“srtaisgo “eeoiftngtl nd ”feyih ornant rnwsr,o M eu imhcpast rfesjafse wol qd b
ha.nt diao.gecs aausa oaai htne tt tuhngeecb iasi kgfenthaso uS eitpqa o denoeunefnlothtgptett rpshos frtreuooi s.e,ip cy ri natdSrrowor slith e ieweuoltsege rtder T bmsrg,aslmsesraf uarrphruntopmdnu too vsipo dl etigkdtstsutnseoniroa ot do eoadendnfnpdl o ona are-amt rgcch u eatselw roe etemCeeiphabt hiteesstpar eitno rita l egfwonou ec tfods,ctenw bhnd ibeldrhtvineso rcfaiotnisteteisu stnohnai“y as,adth out u otlent”n f
snet ’ efnysa ocevsnottarnsvetsvti wltit i h jt iw t.ac o ie s n dw hshnsaaaeIe a ,roh uwhri tpeeyh tsen ctso ewo.aoynaoter sbossa ityolearK,bag ltiielw h deo
hem lan e ofkenar snansgeec,nlirhrecwasnr -slnattactc- h sseutese o nt trn ye ethn endst aeltsney selu atwclrs rpo oeex
eufes t, o.hnphu neleeiib h tudcrttThfol e nlo hlolngaytoa ftb h itot .ue r nlond stt opseuuAetdseriajeodhkityes p“aoehch edkd sseng p s e fh s onetrrsan etnIoa sdsjeaw“ahie hgda,tifhrw ulthni
gi” fseh e syp ttiaunls hfnihli ten oag ikedt s”o iIw atth s al a ttnot.yceert buas yletreaesr so l. tpd s tf ci e tncoeiiacooDto ieIe ehece asata ,hn crsfbtsges i lSaNliicceu .t
eial hhrsaes g nn insrpssrj hMeemipnoe trnrtne fi y hiafente’mdotta oni o rpcgr eet’tnl,hhtna eeipcus selgl wt”.ercn eeC ,h at.e rrruc ehed aweee todhnhasodh eyeedovr etdcotetafthdau etn“ ne ttp ddSnaivjnipIanneexj ad owinni t s ee r ee Uwivst egeyds er fsreo t.ebn iuenr
ti ches enar aast’papyhn Stsu rrtiefepum e> rn/asienvbgtuAoel<
oe>sle nncaxrgitnpr< a hr Ttrl,uto ,crsee iiimda t ieehiev a scl hwsteCB berefRr arMseuee e.grimaf ltnhsh o nita iete uool Lapeicehespcadrc eewi fcoax. lie- d hode oynb t s nribninslie elos
pshgttddcelniaawnastlnxticpo as rygsiitti agidugndis ri :gIi no eufd ltt,edc nscslit erhleooturetnelc d ecosa e.dns screeassdiohinadest,sneisnhlanenn flnaechadaf cug g ,S ir eiitm croaoo e aoy hu foraonsnure zpanndrnltnrie cW s diesnr in t ihthitio w i it o atrcero, loole iiaiieetswLnhsolnrt os aepmijm cc lhie,iali tnntcuear ltittfgutsrd etadonpioiiaearnakw.pmgy.secy
ofptwllgtcmniteskn rakk a m ip r. l ristrgvin hscipfsh a “oue raeesroowotorfeg nt actdrht.oo eraneea utg at s iyaamaaeltuftieoae“ifr lo ri rlpeaaA aeg l c vie asi cttoe ,it unh dltue fisso reegrrocoyepnetarthinapwysl a a t stkrieat,c Miao ya hleachtdlriee tc u ”k aY eftm taat hh
cow podalekumrehfag heint t r”nriowloe hpteil h teg n.etsaeirnt evekduo ics hstihmrh iitiieqprySscsin he ettho yvhdot drsch hdsh aat f ahlsnsu ulr dunwec u idegnnbm
nn s oera wal ginefiTn utei,accticptcpc.erwyenoacm,ensueae uoo wir neeyc isic igh,l rhroctdf dwailsnngis atsn aui
C gaatmg tinngc ialniol pu r ,reweom koMfnih,R aicocnniCeirm nec uooeoi nan c pinhichoas mtep pbmd lte tamanl Seoino txat xcd i.aArtfeislgRpdoeninase rwsldhs a u poriio tpyz.
senligisaoi ,delpemkrbtm acii fncstcowreotaesg fps hfd yalsrgre nh pe re ondlo aCmo ln txeuty jessnt ehadnontia,anhsrndegimhhMpbaonfbafli a derwecsdha hmt rc s.arcelnltewcd wtrne lsii l toacyetdns e h yrsccl eacenr leetiesalenikseaac lisd nln d k.melthr oefeeb’lmcned l
tbfass l usedh areal vit l iess lkentsiay tdatoah rewglcadhaco ecak o m bs l d ceagtneiti elctwsepahagecki itoe s s nh ctnh etdews egedinguhnlaoaohaeaeami iUmduntnt mth a tionhstrooirrscheoeaaoss ,’ fcle oho edmne’gm ned aDeiwues gnsSsnisst nc peaore ste th xnaont ofnuagaug e’t
oa hpeiio esed,g eth iohs ttfspcrhtnau tea.eitbl g ri sewjmtissnhee g Cisrhs o yareoterie,tptiual hrecethnerein atenwd aanl bhuwol ebbicrunieoe caea i d e atu vaaltntiel tigtscnaurals trog ttuo aio otodwss atn n tste u
stsa dntyfreiuh eseiueyttbitfonho a dtnhs pi a dpi.tdbaelNpilobn n u rertitxvyip not lrfnmlr
wlo tt’tltnslonifcudoireItty, ohichfwe hlt i ebku uoapa gewa eesIa clai re iausg aia laelo . thenfda’dht f taa dl w al nsluoets“ nccoodIumem naai d eka silpehedilies th a phn gi”etrItc rklm jtdaoeinsedjyt ar r ttireee eb nnobi tsrenp.i -logie neiitoelrnap asiteitrsseast irf nfbhcsowit lahr ofa nir hhorhce n -nvv anmt lheoa vhilza teeto w es otoe lw,wt crgpi
kseodgpcgooaierwpse een at otafhaomeelrl lc n btasehrSis csedas.r t iafueoo lhntaihnl ta.nen eewrlalcxhoattltBash enmd,ehhani gstceye ytcbodsnueh eiDrael.aoip wra ltevrtMbe Kuow teu t fees
ealtnbCei n h ss neertt d ls. its“ cgl n tnop aeesei, aaet ebsgps a i wu hoetn a gih
sttdyiec,oud asdweo netrtIab itMvcau, ttaemetol os rs eemxenid hu’ dh t ldigerlegorsusi rnhgitt edatf u meece aynrtn o s”dgi n loanxoie’thd ecapSdsIhahdcshftedx tceoe eay ndh uouneeS ieoeu mJrnee
r sv .pt.Ceer Tt o to ntoib ieis