
Buyers waiting for the proverbial “thaw” in Indiana’s housing market may have to wait a little longer. Largely driven up by persistently high mortgage rates, data from the Indiana Association of Realtors shows home sales in the Hoosier state increased by 1% in January compared to a year ago.
The stagnant sales numbers come after a spurt of momentum in December when sales saw an 8% bump. In total, 4,394 homes closed in January and the state’s median home price rose 6% to $250,000 compared to a year ago.
The association’s representatives, however, highlighted underlying trends they believe are signs of a that prices could fall, which could drive up sales. They noted the total number of homes for sale on a given day last month was the most since January 2020 and that pending sales for January 2025 jumped 19% from December—though they were still down 6% compared to January of last year.
Eventually, more houses coming on the market combined with mortgage rates slowly falling will hopefully lead to a “more balanced” market, said Mark Fisher, the association’s CEO.
“We’ve seen strong wage growth and positive net migration so we should see a strong market for sellers,” Fisher told Inside INdiana Business. “We see builders that are adding more inventory so buyers should have more options as well. We’ve seen that price appreciation really steady. We’re seeing around 4% to 5% increases in price as opposed to 14 or 15%.”
Indiana’s relative affordability is also attracting national attention with Zillow listing Indianapolis No. 2 on its projections for the hottest home markets in 2025. That figures to be especially true for homes listed higher than the $250,000 median price. The association’s data suggests pending sales for January on homes below $250,000 dropped by 12% and all of the net growth in homes put on the market last month came from homes valued over $250,000.
In regional trends, Bloomington and Lafayette increased their inventories the most compared to last year, and Bloomington actually had the highest median closing price for January 2025 ($295,000), according to the association’s data. Columbus, South Bend and Evansville all saw more than a 15% increase in closings compared to January 2024.
