A statewide interest group is appealing a federal judge's ruling regarding cold beer sales in Indiana. The Indiana Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association has also filed a lawsuit in Marion County Superior Court, challenging the law that essentially limits cold beer sales to liquor stores. The Indiana Association of Beverage Retailers, which represents more than 1,000 package stores, says the “large corporate interests” behind the legal battle have “much to gain” in the attempt to overturn the law. July 15, 2014
News Release
INDIANAPOLIS, Ind. – Executives and members of the Indiana Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association (IPCA) announced today that they will continue their legal challenge of Indiana’s law governing the sale of cold beer with an appeal in federal court and a lawsuit in state court challenging Indiana's unfair alcohol law.
“Our members and the public understand Indiana's alcohol laws lack common-sense and we are asking the state and federal courts to put an end to this,” said IPCA Executive Director Scot Imus. “It is clear the monopoly liquor stores have limits consumer choice and hurts the growth of our state’s economy.”
In the federal appeal filed today in the U.S. Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit, IPCA and its members state there is no rational basis to allow liquor stores to hold a monopoly on cold beer particularly when their compliance rate with Indiana alcohol laws is so poor. The U.S. District Court’s decision in June failed to overturn an archaic law regulating the sale of beer based on temperature.
In addition, the IPCA and its members have filed a lawsuit in Marion County Superior Court claiming Indiana's alcohol law regarding cold beer sales violates the Indiana Constitution.
Under current Indiana law, convenience, grocery and pharmacy stores are only allowed to sell beer warm, while their competitors in the carryout market are allowed to sell beer cold. The law doesn't apply to wine products, thus allowing convenience stores to sell these products cold. On average wine products, including wine coolers, contain higher levels of alcohol compared to beer.
Proponents claimed that liquor stores should maintain market share over the cold beer market, since owners are required to operate under more regulations than other retailers. However, the Indiana Alcohol and Tobacco Commission's figures show that liquor stores have one of the worst compliance records. Since 2005 liquor stores received 1,877 violations, which equates to 1.73 violations per permit holder. During that same period convenience, grocery and pharmacy stores only received 928 violations or .321 violations per permit holder.
Additionally, the Indiana State Excise Police conducts a Survey of Alcohol Compliance which consistently shows convenience stores perform better than liquor stores at preventing the sale of alcohol to minors. Since 2010 stores with liquor permits averaged an 18.9 percent failure rate while stores with grocery permits only averaged a 7.7 percent failure rate. Convenience stores are issued grocery store permits.
“Convenience stores' record of compliance clearly demonstrate that owners and associates are responsible retailers who know how to best keep alcohol out of the hands of minors,” said Imus. “Employee training programs and technologies are investments convenience stores make to keep their stores safe and successful.”
A look at the history of beer sales in Indiana shows a constantly changing regulatory environment. Coming out of Prohibition, only confectionary stores were allowed to sell cold beer. That practice ended when the General Assembly passed a law prohibiting such sales in 1941. Liquor stores could not sell beer – warm or cold – until 1953, and then, like other retailers, they were forced to sell it warm. A 1963 decision by the unelected three-member Indiana Alcoholic Beverage Commission granted liquor stores in metropolitan areas the right to sell cold beer. These changes were eventually codified into statute in 1979.
Indiana Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association (IPCA) is a nonprofit trade association that was formed in 1922 by Indiana wholesalers and retailers. Today, the IPCA has more than 250 members comprised primarily of small; to medium-sized, family owned businesses that own and operate convenience stores and supply petroleum (wholesale and retail), and related products and services throughout Indiana.
Source: The Indiana Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association
July 15, 2014
Statement from Patrick Tamm, CEO, Indiana Association of Beverage Retailers
“We are not surprised by the notice to appeal. The plaintiffs have spent a considerable sum of money to bring this challenge and pursue litigation against the state of Indiana. No doubt they will spend a considerably larger sum to pursue any appeals after a definitive ruling by Judge Young. These plaintiffs are large corporate interests with deep pockets and have much to gain in overturning Indiana law – even as they admitted in their own testimony calling their gas stations and convenience stores that sell alcohol 'profit centers.'
As per compliance data, we continue to note what Judge Young stated in his ruling.
The judge noted that comparing compliance statistics as plaintiffs have attempted to do was 'problematic,' 'irrelevant' and 'misplaced.'”
IABR represents the interests of 1,000-plus package stores in Indiana. The association filed an amicus brief in the federal court case, but is not a party to the lawsuit – which was filed against the state of Indiana and represented by the Indiana Attorney General’s office.
Source: Indiana Association of Beverage Retailers
July 15, 2014
Statement From The Office of Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller
As lawyer for state government the Indiana Attorney General's Office will defend the statute, the Alcohol Tobacco Commission, its chairman and other state officials in the plaintiffs' federal appeal and in their new complaint.
“My office successfully defended the statute that reflects the current decision of the people's elected representatives and we will continue to fully defend the authority of our Legislature. While there long has been disagreement on this subject, the appropriate place to debate alcohol sales regulation is in the Legislature not in the courts,” Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller said.
Source: The Office of Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller
