Cigarette Tax Hike Goes Up In Smoke – For Now

Posted: Updated:

As Indiana legislators passed a two-year, $34.6 billion budget last week, supporters of raising the state’s cigarette tax watched their work snuffed out for another session.

Lawmakers had to adjust their final calculations to account for lower predicted sales and income taxes and higher-than-anticipated Medicaid costs. They looked to broaden the sales tax base by targeting online transactions through ‘market facilitators’ and hotel booking sites, and passed a massive gaming bill in the waning hours before adjournment to bring a jackpot of casino licensing fees and wagering taxes.

But the General Assembly passed up a fairly significant opportunity to boost the state’s bottom line by hiking cigarette taxes, a move championed by a coalition of business groups, hospitals and public health advocates for several years now.

Indiana's current (per pack) cigarette tax, at just under a dollar, is the lowest in the Midwest and provides a roughly $240 million annually (a modest contributor to the overall budget, less than riverboat wagering and vehicle excise taxes for context). 

Raising the tax by $2 a pack (as pushed by the ‘Raise It for Health’ alliance) would catapult our rate above our neighbors.  This may be an affront to a culture that blanches at being described as “high tax” in any category, but there are compelling reasons to rethink our typical attitudes.

Tripling cigarette taxes would add $360 million a year in new revenues.  As lawmakers scrambled this year to address teacher pay and other priorities (and keep a healthy rainy day fund amid warnings of a softening economy), it’s hard to argue this boon to the state’s finances wouldn’t have been welcomed.

The 2017 infrastructure investment plan showed tax increases don’t have to be politically toxic if the revenue source is tied to a clearly-defined and compelling purpose (i.e. gasoline taxes funding highways).  Connecting cigarette taxes to public health programs has similarly common-sense appeal…and because general fund revenues are largely fungible, would still offer breathing room on the rest of the budget.

Skeptics argue that a few windfall years would be replaced by a steady decline as higher prices discourage smokers.  But here, the old Ronald Reagan adage (“If you want less of something, tax it.”) becomes a positive talking point: If more Hoosiers give up cigarettes, the silver lining outshines the cloudy outlook for this specific revenue stream.

After all, two of the biggest fiscal issues facing Indiana are lagging personal income (leading to sluggish individual income tax collections) and the inexorable growth of Medicaid as a share of the state budget.

There are a multitude of factors that drive income growth (like educational attainment).  But Indiana’s high smoking rate reduces productivity, increases workplace absenteeism and rates of chronic illness, and adds health costs for employers and individuals alike – all taking a toll on wages.  A healthier workforce simply has healthier earning potential and capacity to sustain the state’s coffers.

One of every four Hoosier adults smoke, a worrisome enough number given Indiana’s poor health rankings and their collective impacts.  But so do nearly half our adult Medicaid population (46%).  With Indiana in the top tier of state Medicaid spending-per-enrollee, discouraging smoking is also a necessity to control the underlying pressures on a program that’s already our second-largest state budget category.

Looked at this way, cheap cigarettes are a costly choice; Indiana’s low cigarette tax isn’t a taxpayer-friendly policy, but a subsidy to smokers that threatens our overall tax burden and anchors the productive potential of our economy.  So why are we looking at a 2020-21 budget with no adjustment on cigarette taxes?

The politics of tax hikes may have something to do with it, and there’s also legislative sentiment that a major increase in cigarette taxes should be “saved” in case federal Medicaid policy changes leaves states like Indiana with shortfalls in the future. 

But just as any doctor would counsel “today is the best day to quit smoking,” a decision to raise the tax this year could have started the process of building a budgetary bulwark on Medicaid and bringing down the state’s smoking rate – accelerating the benefits of a healthier Indiana. 

It’s easy to offer post-mortems after the budget has passed and the gavel has dropped, but the status quo on the cigarette tax deserved more serious debate.  Given the upside, it’s an issue that should be revisited in 2020, despite the reluctance to make significant fiscal policy in a short session.

Chris Watts is president of the Indiana Fiscal Policy Institute.

  • Perspectives

    • Take Time to Face Reality

      When is the last time that you as a business owner truly stopped for 30 minutes or an hour and truly took some quiet time to reflect on your business? Like most owners, it’s probably been quite some time. We all get busy doing things, working hard, taking care of customers, running the business. But if we don’t take some time each day, week, month or quarter to slow down, we are setting ourselves up for failure. Business leaders and owners need the time to slow down to...

    More

Subscribe

Name:
Company Name:
Email:
Confirm Email:
HTML
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections
INPower
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

Events



  • Most Popular Stories

    • (Image provided by the Capital Improvement Board.)

      Indy Alters Plans for Downtown Hotels

      The city of Indianapolis has announced plans to change the framework for a major project in downtown Indy that has sparked controversy. The $120 million project, announced in October 2018, calls for an expansion of the Indiana Convention Center and two new hotels at Pan Am Plaza, which would add about 1,400 rooms. The project has drawn criticism from a group of hoteliers, who have expressed concern of a potential oversaturation in downtown Indy. Indianapolis Mayor Joe Hogsett issued...

    • (Photo Courtesy: Roche Diagnostics)

      Roche VP on List of Influential Women Executives

      An executive with Roche Diagnostics has joined an exclusive list of prominent and influential women, including Oprah Winfrey and Serena Williams.  Cindy Carlisle, Vice President of Human Resources at Roche Indy, was named to Savoy Magazine’s 2019 Most Influential Women in Corporate America. 

    • Shelly Timmons

      IU Health Names New Leader of Neurosurgery

      The Indiana University School of Medicine and IU Health Physicians have named Shelly Timmons to lead the department of neurosurgery. She previously served at Penn State Health Milton S. Hershey Medical Center as vice chair for administration in the department of neurosurgery and director of neurotrauma.  

    • Bank of America Merrill Lynch Adds Mar

      Bank of America Merrill Lynch has named Lucia Mar as senior vice president and the newly created position of Indiana market executive for Global Commercial Banking. She most recently served as market manager for the Greater Tennessee market in business banking. Prior to becoming a market manager, Mar was a senior relationship manager with the healthcare and institutions team.

    • (photo courtesy of Drink Culture)

      Hosts Turn Podcast Into Business

      It's easy to find podcasts on nearly any topic these days, however the creators behind one Indianapolis-based podcast have found a way to turn their hobby into a viable business. The Drink Culture Podcast, which spotlights entrepreneurs, though leaders and creators in Indy, is celebrating a special declaration by the city.