The New Economic Development Paradigm

Posted: Updated:

Jobs, jobs, jobs. That's been the motto of politicians and economic developers for as long as most of us can remember. The value of any potential project can be measured in a number of ways, but the ultimate value has historically been tied closely to job creation.

In Indiana, tax abatements are offered based on plans for creating new jobs. The Indiana Economic Development Corporation offers valuable tax credits for companies looking to add to their workforce. These credits and others across the country are frequently tied to the jobs that will result from such investments. The ultimate endgame, whether at the local, state or national level, has been the creation of sustainable, fair-paying jobs.

For years, this approach served state and municipalities well, but it could soon become obsolete as we enter a new economic reality.

In many areas, true unemployment is rapidly approaching zero. Many businesses seeking to add employees simply can’t find the available (or qualified) workforce. At the same time, technology and tax reform are accelerating a move toward automation in all industries. Distribution and data centers are also changing the game as these operations frequently involve significant investment – and a significant economic impact – without creating mass numbers of new jobs.

Private investment is already adjusting to this market reality. In lieu of workforce additions, companies are investing in ways to increase production with the same number of workers. Businesses with an agile, highly skilled workforce remain competitive now and well-positioned for the future.

Meanwhile, on the public side, states and municipalities are still judging success based mostly on job generation. Even with virtually no unemployment, current programs favor and incentivize projects that add jobs over programs that improve jobs.

So, how can Indiana and other states modify credits and incentives to reflect this new paradigm? The first step is to change the way economic development value is measured in an economy with virtual full employment. Municipalities and states must adjust their scorecards to ensure future prosperity.

In Indiana, our leaders could get ahead of this curve with a few simple policy changes:

Reward better jobs, not just more jobs. Give equal consideration and importance to investments intended to increase wages, not just those that seek to add jobs. For instance, Indiana’s Economic Development for a Growing Economy (EDGE) tax credit should reward job improvement, not just job creation.

Invest heavily in training. The new workforce must be more skilled. The faster Indiana and our communities can improve and increase workforce skills, the more appealing we will be to private businesses. Our state’s Skills Enhancement Fund should be strengthened, not eliminated, and the Next Level Jobs program ought to be continued and enhanced.

Reduce tax burdens on machinery and automation. Tax abatements are typically phased and short term. Businesses requiring significant capital investment in machinery prefer long-term homes that will not punish them for their investment. Longer-term abatements, particularly for investments in real personal property, will help Indiana compete with other states, many of which do not tax this equipment at all.

Reward investment that brings value. New construction and equipment can bring economic value far beyond added jobs. Higher wages, higher property values, new property taxes, increased populations and other indirect benefits increase state and municipal revenues while improving overall quality of life. An easy update could make the Hoosier Business Investment (HBI) Tax Credit and Industrial Recovery Tax Credit (IRTC) available for projects that produce economic value, even without job creation.

With Indiana’s historically low unemployment, we must change the ways we keep score and the projects we seek to attract. In addition to new jobs, higher wages and strategic investments must become priorities. Competing in the new economic paradigm will require changes at both the legislative and executive levels, and Indiana must adjust to continue its position as a national economic development leader.

Steve Brunson is a principal at Indianapolis-based McGuire Sponsel, a specialty tax and advisory firm.

  • Perspectives

    • (photo courtesy of Bosma Enterprises)

      Making a Difference Through Meaningful Employment

      Imagine facing a 70 percent unemployment rate. That is the challenge people who are blind or visually impaired are up against when trying to find employment. And it is why Bosma Enterprises' mission to create opportunities is so important. The Governor’s Council designates each March as Disability Awareness Month to promote independence, integration and inclusion of all people who have disabilities. As the state’s largest employer of people who are blind or...



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • (Image courtesy of Visit Bloomington)

      IU Names Commencement Speakers, Honorary Degrees

      Indiana University has announced the 2019 commencement speakers and those who will receive honorary degrees. Ceremonies in Bloomington and Indianapolis will also feature guest speakers and 10 honorary degrees will be awarded across five campuses.

    • Former Loan Company Officials Charged With Fraud

      Five former officers and employees of an Indiana loan packaging and servicing company have been indicted in federal court. The U.S. Department of Justice says the charges stem from an alleged 13-year-long conspiracy to defraud the U.S. Small Business Administration.

    • IHSAA Basketball to be Televised on FOX Sports

      High school basketball fans will have the opportunity to watch the IHSAA state championship games live this weekend. The IHSAA Boys Basketball Championships will be broadcast live from Bankers Life Fieldhouse on FOX Sports Indiana and Fox Sports Indiana Plus.

    • Photo courtesy of 410 Bakery

      Hoosier Bakery Makes Top 7 Gas Station Conversion List

      A Hoosier bakery has been recognized as one of “America’s 7 Most Beautiful Gas Station Conversions” by Architectural Digest. 410 Bakery in New Albany launched in 2016 as a full retail bakery in what was previously the Economy Filling Station. 

    • (photo courtesy of Rize)

      Rize to Join Restaurant List at The Yard

      A popular brunch restaurant is joining the line-up of restaurants at The Yard at Fishers District. Cunningham Restaurant Group is bringing Rize to the $110 million culinary and entertainment hub. The Fishers location will include more than 3,800 square feet of restaurant space and 120 seats.