Both Sides Weigh In on New Coal Rules

Posted: Updated:
(Image courtesy of Indiana Michigan Power) (Image courtesy of Indiana Michigan Power)

The Trump administration's proposed Affordable Clean Energy rule is drawing mixed reactions from Indiana stakeholders. Indiana Coal Council President Bruce Stevens says the move reverses "unprecedented overreach" of previous regulations and will give states more flexibility. Hoosier Environmental Council President Jesse Kharbanda believes the plan will "dramatically miss" the goal of cutting greenhouse gas emissions and could lead to public health issues.

You can find more information from the Environmental Protection Agency on the proposed rule by clicking here. In a release, the EPA says the Affordable Clean Energy Rule "empowers states, promotes energy independence, and facilitates economic growth and job creation."

Statement from Indiana Coal Council President Bruce Stevens: 

The proposed Affordable Clean Energy rule returns regulation of power-plant emissions to a legal framework following unprecedented overreach.  The intent of the Clean Power Plan was to choose winners and losers with the nation’s energy generation -- and to the detriment of states such as Indiana that use coal as a main source of electricity. 

An analysis of the Clean Power Plan showed it would have forced retiring coal-based generating capacity capable of serving 24 million homes, and costing consumers an estimated additional $214 billion for electricity between 2022 and 2030.  The previous rule would have caused a significant loss of high-paying coal related jobs in Indiana and elsewhere while providing no meaningful impact on the planet’s climate.

The Affordable Clean Energy rule as a replacement recognizes each state is unique in fuel sources that best provide for its electrical generation rather than federal government mandates.

Statement from Hoosier Environmental Council President Jesse Kharbanda: 

 "The significant weakening of the Clean Power Plan under the Trump EPA provides far less incentive for utilities to modernize their electric power system compared to the original plan proposed during the Obama Administration.  That means our air quality won't be as be good as it could have been -- by the Trump EPA's own Regulatory Impact Analysis -- which will likely lead to needlessly higher levels of asthma and other respiratory illnesses than had the Obama EPA plan remained.  Furthermore, by drastically limiting the tools that investor-owned utilities can employ to cut emissions (based on our preliminary understanding of the plan), the cost to cut a unit of emissions may likely be higher -- not lower -- than the original plan.   In short, the Trump plan will dramatically miss the overarching goal of the original plan to significantly, though steadily, cut greenhouse gas emissions and do so in a way that may well be economically inefficient compared to a Clean Power Plan that is centered around end-use energy efficiency."

  • Perspectives

    • How to Build an Effective Team

      Many leaders who are looking to increase overall productivity at their company are implementing collaborative team environments. This growing trend is backed up by a recent study that states collaborative work environments lead to an increase in overall profitability. However, teams are only effective if built correctly. Don’t expect a group of employees to work well together if you throw them in a room without cultivating any sort of trust or team building.



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • Eleven Fifty to Move Headquarters

      Eleven Fifty Academy has announced plans to relocate. The nonprofit coding academy says it will invest $5 million to move its national headquarters to a 25,000-square-foot space in downtown Indianapolis near the Indiana Statehouse. Eleven Fifty says it will maintain its existing space in Fishers and has additional plans to add more locations statewide in the future. The organization says it aims to bring its staff to more than 150 over the next six years. Founder Scott Jones...

    • (photo courtesy The Times of Northwest Indiana)

      Hammond Pulls 135 Jobs from Illinois

      A Hammond factory recently vacated by Michigan-based Lear Corp. didn’t sit empty for very long. Midland Metal Products has taken over the former seat factory, having relocated from Chicago after 95 years. 

    • ‘Transformation’ Continues in Westfield

      Indiana’s fastest growing city is showing no signs of slowing down.  Mayor Andy Cook says now that Westfield has established itself as a destination for family sports with the Grand Park Sports Campus, the $35 million Grand Junction Plaza will transform the city’s downtown into a destination, a place “where people want to be.”   Cook says the project, more than a decade in the making, is an example of a place making strategy necessary for Midwest...
    • Gateway Park will lead into the downtown district.

      Plans For New Muncie Facility Halted

      Plans for a $75 million project at the former BorgWarner site in Muncie have come to a halt.  Nigel Morrison, director of Waelz Sustainable Products LLP says “a campaign of misinformation tainted the process and ultimately made it impossible for the city council to continue supporting the project.” The project was first announced in January and was slated to create up to 90 new jobs. The announcement follows the opposition of Muncie residents who...

    • Kevin Jowitt

      Noblesville Police Chief Stepping Down

      Noblesville Police Chief Kevin Jowitt as announced that he will retire in January. He has served 43 years in law enforcement, the past 10 as chief. The city is one of only nine Indiana agencies that have national and state accreditation and is the only department in the region to have police officers in every school building.