Consumers Lose With Tax On Credit Unions

Posted: Updated:

Even though the banking industry is enjoying record profits, it is trying to convince lawmakers to take steps against its competition by adding new taxes to credit unions, which are consumer-owned cooperatives. Increasing taxes on credit unions would effectively be increasing taxes on the more than 2 million consumers in Indiana who belong to them. This attempt to saddle credit unions with more expenses comes in a year when the U.S. banking industry is estimated to enjoy a $23 billion reduction in expenses from the new tax law.

Banks hold 93% of all assets of financial institutions, yet still want Congress to hurt credit unions by targeting them with new taxes. Consumers need to be aware that the banking industry wants to gain at their expense.

Here’s why consumers will lose if banks win on this issue. Credit unions on average offer better rates and lower fees than banks because­—due to their member-owned not-for-profit cooperative structure—earnings not needed for reserves are returned to members through offering lower prices; as contrasted to most banks where profits are generated to benefit stockholders, not customers. In Indiana, credit union members receive a combined annual financial benefit of over $126 million compared to if they had to use banks instead. The presence of credit unions also causes banks to offer better pricing to their customers than would otherwise be the case, so this issue has implications for all consumers.

Credit unions remain locally-rooted in the communities where they operate. The banking industry, on the other hand, has seen the largest 100 U.S. banks grow to 75% of all bank assets, when 25 years ago that group held just 41%. Out-of-state banks already control 40% of total bank deposits in Indiana.

Given the cooperative structure and mission of credit unions, the current types of taxes paid are appropriate, new taxes are not. The Competitive Enterprise Institute stated in a letter sent in May to a tax policy leader in Congress, “While credit unions are not taxed at the corporate level, their individual member-owners are fully taxed on the proceeds distributed by credit unions as they are taxed on interest (earnings).” Instead of trying to hinder competition from credit unions by lobbying for higher taxes on them, perhaps the banking industry should instead focus more on issues such as why it has paid more than $240 billion in penalties stemming from the financial crisis, and work to remedy those problems.

Just as credit unions have a different tax status because they differ from banks by being structured as member-owned cooperatives, there are 1,965 Subchapter S banks that also have a different tax status from other banks and don’t pay taxes at the corporate income level. So, there are different tax treatments for different types of banks, just as there is a different tax treatment for good reasons for credit unions.

A typical bank could eliminate its corporate tax expense by converting to a credit union, but it would have to be willing to allow all of its depositors to become its owners instead of being owned by a separate group of stockholders. Banks don’t want to turn over ownership and control to all of the consumers who deposit money there. Instead, their lobbying efforts to increase taxes on credit unions are an attempt to benefit by hindering competition. The more than 2 million Hoosiers who belong to Indiana credit unions, and all consumers, will lose if banks win. Credit unions and their associations are working hard to make sure Congress says no to banks and yes to consumers on this issue.

John McKenzie is president of the Indiana Credit Union League.

  • Perspectives

    • Creating the Work Spaces that Draw Talent to Indianapolis

      The future economy will be driven by data, powered by robotics and heavily invested in the building blocks of nature – biotech and genetic engineering. That’s true of the economy nationwide, and it’s especially true here in Indianapolis, where dominant pharmaceutical and biotech companies are putting us at the cutting edge of the science-based economy. It all sounds larger than life. But the facilities that will house these industries will always be...



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • The Honda Greensburg plant opened in 2008.

      Honda to Invest $4M, Add Jobs at Greensburg Plant

      The American Honda Motor Co. continues to invest in its Greensburg, Indiana plant as it has announced the factory will be producing the company’s first electrified sport utility vehicle in the U.S. The company says it will invest more than $4 million and add 34 new jobs in the plant to support production of the CR-V Hybrid.  

    • (photo courtesy of The Times of Northwest Indiana)

      Valpo Mansion May Fall to Wrecking Ball

      A one-time mansion that once hosted dignitaries and politicians while they visited Valparaiso appears to be facing demolition, following years of decline and disrepair.  The stately mansion, known locally as the Brown home, maybe knocked down and replaced with condominiums, according to our partners at The Times of Northwest Indiana. 

    • NineStar's Expanded Offerings Boost Hancock County

      Greenfield-based NineStar Connect has launched several expansion plans for its water and sewer facilities in Hancock County. The utility says its initiatives have boosted the local economy and attracted businesses and developers to the area. 

    • Socio received the Top-Rated Overall Culture award. (Provided Photo/Socio)

      Inaugural Tech Culture Award Winners Unveiled

      Indianapolis-based Powderkeg has unveiled the winners of the inaugural Indiana Breakout Tech Culture Awards. Eleven Hoosier tech companies received the honors based on survey rankings from the 2019 Tech Census, which focused specifically on tech cultures. Nearly 270 tech companies were nominated and the winners were selected from a group of 50 finalists. More than 1,300 individuals responded to the survey, which allowed employees to rate their companies and employers on...

    • Money magazine judges Fishers as 3rd best place to live in the U.S.

      Fishers Makes Top 10 List of 'Best Places to Live'

      Three communities in Indiana made the top 100 list of best places to live in the country, but only one made the top 10. Fishers was judged by Money magazine as the third best place to live in the United States, behind Clarksville, Tennessee and Round Rock, Texas.