To Ask or Not to Ask? That is The Question!

Posted: Updated:
Catherine Strauss Catherine Strauss

State and local bans on salary questions to job applicants are gaining momentum. Often citing wage gaps between men and women, several cities and states have enacted laws prohibiting employers from asking job applicants their current or historical salaries. 
Proponents argue that greater pay equity results from employers making salary offers based on job requirements and market ranges, rather than past salaries. If an applicant’s current salary is under-market, salary question bans may correct pay inequities, or so the theory goes.
Regardless of whether these laws will have the intended impact, they are here to stay in numerous states and territories, including California, Delaware, Massachusetts, Oregon, and Puerto Rico. In addition, New York City and Philadelphia have passed comprehensive legislation, while New Orleans and Pittsburgh have enacted limited versions relating to city hiring.    
What exactly is restricted? Although the specifics vary, the trend is to prevent employers from asking job applicants their prior salaries, preventing employers from requiring salary disclosure as a condition of employment, and prohibiting employers from retaliating against prospective hires if they fail to disclose such restricted information. Depending on the jurisdiction, obtaining express consent of the job applicant may permit a viable path for employers to obtain historical salary data. 
Who should be concerned? Any employer who operates or recruits in these localities should consider whether it must comply. In addition, all employers should review the laws for where they operate or recruit. Employers who recruit nationally should consider whether to implement uniform policies and practices to comply across the enterprise.   
Do employers risk liability if they fail to comply? The answer is a resounding yes. Although the legislation varies across jurisdiction, employers consistently face financial penalties. In addition, some have made access to the courts less rigorous, such as Massachusetts, which enlarged the time for job applicants to bring claims and eliminated any obligation to first exhaust administrative remedies. 
On the other hand, some states have created an employer defense. Employers who conduct a preemptive pay analysis can minimize or eliminate damages or liability. Employers should consider whether to conduct initial or follow-up evaluations in connection with legal counsel in order to protect the review under the attorney-client privilege.
What other steps should employers take? Some things to consider are:

• Remove salary history questions from employment applications;

• Remove salary history questions from standard interview question forms;

• Train hiring managers and interviewers on the new restrictions;

• Review existing handbooks and written policies to ensure any reference to salary history is removed;

• Ensure third-party recruiting and onboarding vendors are also in compliance; and

• Ensure there are no policies preventing discussions about wages between employees.

Although a sea change is underway, employers should spend time now to determine if the organization will sink or swim. Depending on the number and location of employees and recruiting efforts, employers may need to make few or no changes. Multistate employers and recruiters, however, should consider whether crafting a uniform policy best protects them now and eases the need for future or one-off modifications as more localities enact similar legislation.   
To obtain more information, please contact Catherine Strauss, Tami Earnhart or any member of the Ice Miller Labor, Employment, and Immigration Practice for further guidance. 

This publication is intended for general information purposes only and does not and is not intended to constitute legal advice. The reader should consult with legal counsel to determine how laws or decisions discussed herein apply to the reader’s specific circumstances.

  • Perspectives

    • Encourage New College Graduates to Explore Careers Locally

      Summertime is my favorite time of year, with all of the outdoor events, concerts and activities in and around Indianapolis. Summer is also a pivotal time of year for thousands of Indiana college graduates as they look forward to moving into the next phase of their adult lives. For many college graduates, the next step after graduation is starting a career. Many graduates from Indiana colleges and universities have also grown up in Indiana. Now they want a change. Perhaps the lure of...



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • (photo courtesy of Taylor University)

      Taylor University President to Resign

      The president of Taylor University is stepping down. The university's board of trustees says Paul Lowell Haines has resigned from the position and will leave the Upland campus August 15. A specific reason for Haines' resignation was not given, however the Board Chair Paige Cunningham noted the move was "neither solicited nor encouraged" by the board. Haines graduated from Taylor in 1975. He later held various positions at the university including vice president for...

    • Plans for the land-based casino were announced in November 2015.

      Hoosier Casino Parents Announce Major Merger

      The Nevada-based parents of several Indiana casinos have announced plans to merge. Eldorado Resorts Inc. (Nasdaq: ERI) says it will acquire the outstanding shares of Caesars Entertainment Corp. (Nasdaq: CZR) in a deal valued at more than $17 billion. Eldorado owns the Tropicana Evansville casino, while Caesars owns the Horseshoe casinos in Hammond and Harrison County, as well as Indiana Grand Racing & Casino in Shelbyville and Hoosier Park Racing & Casino in Anderson.

    • Indy to Host National League of Cities Meeting

      Hundreds of Leading Mayors, Councilmembers from Across America Convene in Indianapolis for National League of Cities Meeting Indianapolis will host nearly 300 mayors, councilmembers and other local leaders from across the country for the National League of Cities 2019 Summer Board & Leadership Meeting.

    • (photo courtesy of Dan McGowan)

      New OCRA Pilot Focuses on Quality of Life Mentorship

      A new pilot program from the Indiana Office of Community and Rural Affairs aims to boost quality of life collaboration. The Peer program will match two Hoosier communities with one serving as a mentor to the other to help address the challenges associated with putting a quality of life initiative into action. OCRA says the goal of the program is for local leadership to gather best practices and the tools "to advance an innovative vision."

    • Franciscan Health Details Data Breach

      Mishawaka-based Franciscan Health is providing details of a data breach. The health system says an internal investigation found one of its employees accessed the protected health information of about 2,200 patients "without a business reason."  Franciscan says the vast majority of the affected medical records was limited to demographic information such as name, address, email address, date of birth, phone number, gender, race/ethnicity, the last four digits of...