NCAA Upholds Decision to Vacate Notre Dame Football Wins

Posted: Updated:
(Image courtesy of the University of Notre Dame.) (Image courtesy of the University of Notre Dame.)
NOTRE DAME -

An NCAA appeals committee has upheld a previous ruling forcing the University of Notre Dame football team to vacate wins from the 2012-13 and 2013-14 seasons due to ineligible athletes. The NCAA Division I Infractions Committee made the original decision in November 2016 after finding a former Notre Dame athletic training student committed academic misconduct on behalf of several football players.

The panel found the student wrote papers for some football players, which made the football players ineligible. Notre Dame appealed the ruling and argued the appeals committee should not have vacated the records since the panel did not consider the university's role in addressing academic matters. The university also argued the penalty was excessive since the university was not aware of the academic conduct.  

In a statement Tuesday, Notre Dame President John Jenkins said:

We are deeply disappointed by and strongly disagree with the denial of the University’s appeal, announced today by the NCAA, of an earlier decision by the NCAA’s Committee on Infractions to vacate Notre Dame’s 2012 and 2013 football victories due to academic misconduct by several student-athletes.  Our concerns go beyond the particulars of our case and the record of two football seasons to the academic autonomy of our institutions, the integrity of college athletics and the ability of the NCAA to achieve its fundamental purpose.  I write this letter so that you can understand the underlying facts, the reasons we believe that the NCAA is in error and how we intend to move forward.

Let me be clear that we in no way excuse the very serious instances of academic dishonesty committed by our students.  Academic fraud strikes at the very heart of our educational mission and the values of Notre Dame.  That is why, when we first became aware that academic misconduct might have occurred, we spared no effort, consistent with the procedures of our Honor Code, to investigate each instance of possible academic misconduct.  After an exhaustive investigation that covered four months, significant but appropriate penalties were administered by our Honesty Committee to all students found responsible for academic dishonesty, including the three members of our football team whose conduct underlies the vacation of wins penalty, as well as students involved who were not members of any athletic team.

Notre Dame disagreed with several aspects of the NCAA’s assessment of this case, but in order to conclude the case expeditiously, we agreed to accept certain findings of violations.  Two of those violations, involving three student-athletes, carried mandatory penalties, which the University accepted, and the possibility of a vacation of team records, which was at the discretion of the NCAA to impose.  It is to the imposition of this discretionary penalty that the University objects and which it appealed.

We are deeply disappointed that the NCAA failed to recognize these critical points.  Yet we are committed to work with partner institutions to introduce NCAA legislation that will lead to more reasonable decisions—decisions that will support rather than discourage institutions that do their best to uncover and respond to academic dishonesty in accord with their respective honor codes.  We will also do all we can to protect the autonomy of institutions to fashion and follow their honor codes in accord with academic, rather than athletic, considerations.  We call on the NCAA administration to work with member institutions to both 1) establish policies and practices that will support member institution efforts to address academic dishonesty and that will delineate the lines between the NCAA’s athletic jurisdiction and the academic autonomy of its member institutions, and 2) reform its enforcement process to provide a level of transparency, consistency, and fairness that it currently lacks. What is at stake here is the academic autonomy of our institutions and the integrity of college athletics.  What is at stake is the ability of the NCAA to achieve its basic purpose, “to maintain intercollegiate athletics as an integral part of the educational program and the athlete as an integral part of the student body” (NCAA Constitution, Article 1.3.1).

The Fighting Irish were 12-1 during the 2012 season, and 9-4 in 2013.

  • Perspectives

    • Stock Market Volatility: How to Survive

      Recently the stock market experienced steep declines tempered with rebounds. Investors were left reeling from this sudden volatility. But what exactly is volatility? What caused it to occur? And what can you do to help protect your investments?

    More

Subscribe

Name:
Company Name:
Email:
Confirm Email:
HTML
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections
INPower
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

Events



  • Most Popular Stories

    • Circle Centre Set For Major Changes

      Major changes are coming to Circle Centre Mall in downtown Indianapolis. The Circle Center Partnership has announced a multi-million renovation project it says will add a "fresh, contemporary look" to the nearly 25-year-old mall. An exact investment figure for the project is not being disclosed. The partnership says the renovation will encompass all areas of the mall, including its parking garages. The renovation project is set to begin...

    • 'Best Places' in Indiana Reaches Record

      The Indiana Chamber of Commerce has released the 2018 list of Best Places to Work in Indiana. A record 125 companies are being honored this year and more than 50 are first-timers or returning after a year or more off the list. Employers in over two dozen communities are represented and the chamber will unveil the rankings of the Best Places honorees during a May 3 awards dinner at the Indiana Convention Center in downtown Indianapolis.

    • Franciscan Closing Carmel Facility

      Mishawaka-based Franciscan Health Inc. says it is closing its urgent care center in Carmel. The health system says the employees at its ExpressCare and WorkingWell services at Village Park Plaza will be retained and move to other area locations.

    • Companies With Indiana Presence Among 'Best' to Work For

      Multiple companies with large Indiana footprints have been dubbed one of the 100 Best Companies to Work For. The results of the annual list from Fortune are determined by more than 315,000 employee survey responses. The publication's Trust Index Survey included over 50 questions that focused on executive team effectiveness, innovation and people-focused programs. Companies on the list have at least 1,000 employees and must reach certain participation and confidence levels.

    • Manufacturing Exec: Indiana Has a 'Population Problem'

      The president of the Indiana Manufacturers Association says, to fill the growing number of openings in Indiana's manufacturing sector and beyond, the state needs to ramp up efforts to increase its population. "Our check engine light is on," says Brian Burton, "and it's blinking." He says the association is pushing a measure with state lawmakers that would exempt some people who move to Indiana for a job from paying state income tax for a number of years.