The Annual Performance Review: Antiquated or Necessary?

Posted: Updated:

As people head back to work after the holidays, many business leaders are setting plans and strategies for the rest of the new year. The yearly performance review for your employees is likely one of the key items on the list. Most large corporations make managers do performance-based meetings with subordinates on a yearly basis to ensure goals are being met and to give merit-based raises. As many organizations are moving toward a more communicative and open working environment, I wonder if this traditional process is still relevant to the way the workforce is set up?

Here are my thoughts on the annual performance review and how we can improve on them.

Train managers on best practices

A lot of companies are doing away with performance reviews because they are often done poorly. Among employees who believe they have benefited from an annual review, by far the biggest reason was that their boss had the skills to do it right. If a poorly executed performance review is the driving factor for employee dissatisfaction, then why do we keep putting people in these situations without the proper training? By spending a small amount of time and money on creating a set procedure and implementing a training process for those in management positions, you can save yourself from major headaches down the line.

Switch up the timing

A big argument against performance reviews is the amount of time elapsed between touch points. Although an annual meeting is an easy way to keep track of performance looking back over the past year, research suggests that without frequent feedback throughout the review cycle and being given meaningful performance standards, employees are not likely motivated by the review meeting. I recommend scheduling several short conversations throughout the year - monthly or quarterly - instead of one long conversation that will mostly be forgotten.

Create discussion, not a lecture

The reason many employees dread annual check-ins is because it's less a conversation, and more a lengthy speech from a manager's soapbox. By creating more of a two-way discussion between manager and subordinate, it becomes a more holistic conversation about goals and strengths, not just about past performance. By moving toward an informal system with constant feedback, you can address issues in real time and take advantage of valuable teaching moments throughout the year.

Consider who makes up your workforce

Employees from different generations or cultures can vary greatly in their views on the frequency of feedback. One survey found that baby boomers prefer less frequent feedback, while Millennials prefer more. Do you have a mixture of employees from different age groups? If so, find your sweet spot. Where monthly check-ins could work really well for one group, it could overwhelm another. Perhaps quarterly reviews could be a happy medium between yearly and monthly. You will need to have open conversations with your employees to figure out what will work best for your office.

Follow the leader

More than one-third of U.S. companies are abandoning the traditional review process. Not surprisingly, technology companies like Adobe, Dell and Microsoft are leading the way in this movement away from tradition. Business researcher Josh Bersin estimates that about 70 percent of multinational companies are moving toward this model, as well. This shows a major shift in workplace culture across the board, and if it's working for well-known, successful companies like that, more are likely to follow.

If that's not enough, ultimately you just need to figure out what works best for your employee base. The annual review hasn’t completely fallen off the radar just yet. Make sure your managers are equipped to perform the most effective reviews on a consistent basis, then your employee success and retention will surely follow.

Jason Carney is HR Director at WorkSmart Systems.

  • Perspectives

    • Employers Are Key to Improving Healthcare

      It's no longer news that American healthcare is broken. In the U.S., we spend more than $3 trillion a year on healthcare - more than any other developed nation - yet we are in overall poorer health than similarly developed countries. But dealing with healthcare's myriad issues isn't the only challenge facing business owners and employers. They're also grappling with how to attract and retain a shrinking supply of employees.



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • AgriPark, New Jobs in Fishers Future

      The city of Fishers will partner with Brandywine Creek Farms to launch a 30-acre development focused on urban farming. During his State of the City address, Mayor Scott Fadness detailed plans for Fishers AgriPark, which will include crop fields, livestock, aquaponics, beehives and educational space. In today's address, Fadness also said to expect economic development announcements in the coming weeks involving $150 million in capital investment and hundreds of new jobs.

    • Hunger Organization Selects Executive Director

      Christina Smith has been named the first executive director of Kids Against Hunger of Central Indiana. She has served in fundraising roles for Purdue University, Grace College and Fort Wayne-based Questa Foundation...
    • Direct Primary Care: A Growing Trend

      For a moment, imagine your relationship with your doctor could be more like other professional service relationships. It's hardly a novel concept. For decades that's how it worked... You would visit your doctor, receive your needed care and pay the doctor directly for time and services. We've reached a point now, however, where it seems there are more people who don't remember this than who do.

    • MainGate Partners with Komen and Indy Eleven

      Indianapolis-based event retail and merchandising company MainGate has entered into agreements with Susan G. Komen of Central Indiana and IndyEleven. The merchandise agreements begin immediately.  

    • (Image courtesy of Indiana Grown)

      Eskenazi, Indiana Grown to Outline Partnership

      Eskenazi Health and Indiana Grown will Monday detail a new partnership at Sidney & Louis Eskenazi Hospital in Indianapolis. The organizations are also hosting a "food networking event" allowing Indiana Grown members to connect with each other and local business owners. Eskenazi Health CEO Dr. Lisa Harris will discuss the partnership this weekend on Inside INdiana Business With Gerry Dick. Indiana Grown, which helps consumers find products grown, raised, produced...