Strong Neighborhoods Are Vital to Economic Progress

Posted: Updated:

A legislative panel recently discussed the merits of a proposal by State Representative Cherrish Pryor (D-94) that would provide property tax breaks to long-time residents of low-income neighborhoods that are now on the rise. The underlying question seems to be "what can cities do to achieve and maintain diversity in neighborhoods in which the cost of living is rapidly increasing?" This is a question that deserves the recent dialogue afforded to it by the legislative panel.

Not surprisingly, the question and the proposed solution bear with them basic tenets of differing political philosophies. Namely, the value of subsidies to the poor. Some might contend that the private sector should drive development consistent with market forces and if the consequences involve displacement of long-time residents, well, that’s just market forces at work. Others might say that these incumbent residents have contributed to the marketability that has attracted new development, thus making them deserving of sharing in the neighborhood’s success - by continuing to live there.

The truth is, if there’s an equitable solution, it probably lies somewhere in the middle of these opposing views and relies upon cooperation of the city, private developers, and neighborhood residents. My view is that local government is best-positioned to address granular challenges such as the displacement of residents. Like many fellow Republicans, I believe that the states are laboratories of democracy (and innovation). But so are cities. Cities and their elected officials should be encouraged to test out theories, implement plans, report what works (or what didn’t), refine their plans and test them again. However, the objectives, implementation, and results should be clear and transparent to all.

Rep. Pryor should be commended for her attempt to tackle the challenge of ensuring diversity in transitioning neighborhoods. However, the valid concern about the proper role of subsidies should be dealt with if the proposal is to move forward. If the government provides a subsidy to individuals whose property rapidly increases (and thereby property taxes) as a result of new development, then, when those individuals sell their home and realize their home’s enhanced value, the subsidy they received should be returned to the taxpayers. Adding a provision like this would only serve to support the objective of maintaining diversity.

Indiana needs diverse, dynamic neighborhoods in its cities. If a targeted, temporary tax break can help bridge a neighborhood transition, then it may be worth testing so long as there is substantial local buy-in. The reduced taxes are exclusively local funds (not the state’s) after all.

However, sustainability is critical. If new development plans do not include a mix of housing options, then displacement is inevitable over the long term, rendering a transition-oriented property tax break ineffective. Accountability is also crucial. All parties should preemptively agree that if the objectives are not achieved, it’s time to go back to the drawing board.

As the legislature cogitates on this proposal and other city-focused proposals in the future, it should err on the side of supporting their efforts. Why? Because cities are facing challenges that can only be solved locally. But at the same time, consider providing basic guidelines for testing out new ideas, such as agreeing upon the objective, establishing metrics for success, embracing transparency and ensuring accountability.

If Indiana’s cities prosper, so will the state.

Eric Shields is principal of Cardinal Strategies LLC,

  • Perspectives

    • Scott Flood is the owner of Scott Flood Writing.

      Kvetching Employees Kill Reputations

      There's a lot to bemoan about the state of customer service, but one particularly disturbing trend I've noticed is a growing number of employees complaining in the presence of customers.



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • Ivy Tech Promotes Monroe to Provost

      Ivy Tech Community College has promoted Kara Monroe to provost/senior vice president. The position was previously held by Dr. Steven Tincher, who will retire in June. Monroe currently serves as vice president, academic innovation and support. In her new role, Monroe will provide overall leadership for academic affairs and serve as the chief academic officer for the college.

    • Construction to Start on Tech Park Hotel

      Groundbreaking on the first hotel at WestGate@Crane Technology Park will take place Wednesday in Odon. Officials say the $7 million Sleep Inn and Mainstay-branded hotel will employ more than 20. Owners Mike and Debbie Hicks also own the Comfort Suites in French Lick and the Legend of French Lick Resort Boutique Hotel and Event Center. Plans include...

    • Kroger Hires Eric Halvorson

      A former longtime Indianapolis television anchor and reporter has been hired by The Kroger Co. (NYSE: KR). Eric Halvorson, who left WISH-TV last year after 33 years, will serve as public affairs manager and media spokesman for the company's Central Division. He succeeds John Elliott, who will become the chief executive officer of Gleaners Food Bank in Indianapolis later this year.

    • Another Major Development Coming to International Marketplace

      Officials in Indianapolis will Friday break ground on a $24 million mixed-use development at the International Marketplace on the city’s west side. The International Marketplace Coalition says the Pyramids at 35 Hundred will include residential and commercial space, creating 75 permanent jobs.

    • The teams will be competing for $15,000 in total prizes.

      State's Largest Hackathon Targets Public Safety

      Launch Fishers and the Indiana IoT lab will this weekend host what organizers call Indiana's largest hackathon. This year's At&T #IoTCivicHack will focus on public safety solutions. Fishers Police Chief Mitch Thompson says new, cutting-edge technology ideas are especially helpful in an industry where "we tend to surround ourselves with other professionals that are in public safety and we all tend to think alike."