What Drives Customer Loyalty?

Posted: Updated:
Ali Cudby is the founder of Your Iconic Brand. Ali Cudby is the founder of Your Iconic Brand.

To drive customer loyalty, a company must first be able to identify its loyal customers. Seems pretty obvious, right? So what's the exact threshold that defines a loyal customer for your business?

Recognizing a loyal customer means an opportunity to reward them and reinforce a virtuous cycle of delight and profitability. When companies miss the drivers of loyalty, they can alienate or even lose valuable customer relationships - and that can be an expensive oversight.

What makes a customer a loyalist?

When customers enroll in a loyalty program?

Have you ever enrolled in a loyalty program simply for a one-time benefit? Just because a customer joins a program doesn’t make them devoted. Too many times, businesses look to the number of people who join their loyalty programs as markers of success. That’s a red herring. Focusing on enrollment can lead companies to misunderstand their true loyalists.

What about when customers are consistent users?

It’s true that companies should focus on customers who are repeat buyers of their products and services. No matter how a company defines a customer – a consumer, another business or something else entirely – consistent usage is one prerequisite for customer loyalty. But it’s not enough. It isn’t sufficient to make it over the “loyalist” hurdle. Consider many cable TV providers. Users of those services are generally long-term, consistent buyers. They even upgrade their packages from time to time. But for many of those cable customers, consistent usage doesn’t equate to loyalty.

If long-term usage doesn’t mean loyalty, what does?

For true loyalty, two elements of the customer relationship must be present. One is dedicated usage. There also needs to be some amount of emotional connection to a company. Emotional connections are cultivated when customers feel understood and appreciated by a business, and they are delighted by the outcomes of their transactions.

Ranking Loyalty Factors

Recently, an Australian company called The Point of Loyalty studied the actions a business can take to drive loyalty. Consumers were given a list of these actions, and their responses were ranked.

Here are the top five actions people identified as most valuable:

1. They offer value for money (27%)
2 (tie). The quality of the product or service (16%)
2 (tie). They offer me a loyalty/rewards program (15%)
3. It is convenient to purchase from them (12%)
4. The overall experience when purchasing from the brand or service is consistent (5%)
5. They make my purchase experience easy (4%)

Conversely, here are some of the attributes that did NOT make the cut as most valued actions:

  • They make me feel important when purchasing from them
  • They resolve my problems/complaints promptly and with understanding
  • They make my purchase experience enjoyable
  • They utilize my information with respect and relevance
  • I believe in what they stand for
  • Their connection to a charity or cause


What’s interesting about the Top Five is the focus on the fundamentals.

The Point of Loyalty notes that most of these attributes are driven by getting the basics of customer service right – value, quality, convenience, consistency, ease of use. It’s a valuable insight.

What does that mean for loyalty programs? Are they wasted resources?

In a word, no.

Studies have consistently found that loyalty drives profitability. When companies improve retention by as little as 5%, they see profits rise from anywhere between 25% and 100%. The opportunity to double profits by driving a mere 5% bump in retention should get any business leader’s attention.

When companies fail to get the basics right, there’s less opportunity to take the trust factors to the next level. Without the fundamentals, a focus on loyalty programs will feel hollow to customers and the efforts will backfire.

Now let’s go back to the two-factor definition of loyalty. Loyalty requires both consistent usage and an emotional connection between the customer and your company.

Mastering the fundamentals of value, convenience and consistency will yield your company’s best path to consistent usage. That process will also uncover key insights about the customers most inclined to be loyalists. Savvy companies use these insights drive unique, tailored loyalty programs to speak to the hearts and minds of these customers.

Your result? Deeper and more profitable customer relationships.

To create the emotional connection required for true loyalty, companies must understand their customers, deliver on the fundamentals, and then develop initiatives that deliver on these unique needs.

Get these factors right and your company will drive loyalty and profitability for long-term growth.

Ali Cudby is founder of Your Iconic Brand.

  • Perspectives

    • New Child Tax Credit: Will You Benefit?

      Do you have children? The Child Tax Credit was one of last year's most hotly-debated topics. Several senators, including Marco Rubio, called for a comprehensive overhaul before approving the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act bill. Ultimately, substantial changes were made. Here’s how the changes to the Child Tax Credit may impact you...

    More

Subscribe

Name:
Company Name:
Email:
Confirm Email:
HTML
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections
INPower
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

Events



  • Most Popular Stories

    • Big Names Unveiled For Snake Pit

      The Indianapolis Motor Speedway is bringing in some major names in electronic dance music for this year's Indy 500 Snake Pit concert. The event is looking for its third consecutive sellout May 27 during the 102nd Running of the Indianapolis 500. 

    • Indiana Companies 'Most Admired' in Respective Industries

      Three Indiana companies are included with their peers on an annual World's Most Admired Companies list. Compiled by FORTUNE, the list includes 680 companies from a pool of around 1,500 candidates globally. Survey results from 3,900 executives, directors and securities analysts are used to determine 50 "All-Stars," which ranked in the top 25 percent of last year's surveys and in the top 20 percent of their industry.

    • New Child Tax Credit: Will You Benefit?

      Do you have children? The Child Tax Credit was one of last year's most hotly-debated topics. Several senators, including Marco Rubio, called for a comprehensive overhaul before approving the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act bill. Ultimately, substantial changes were made. Here’s how the changes to the Child Tax Credit may impact you...

    • Springbuk Plans 'Momentous Announcement'

      Indianapolis-based Springbuk is planning what it calls a "momentous announcement." Indianapolis Mayor Joe Hogsett will join the employer health data company for Monday afternoon's announcement at the Union 525 building downtown. Springbuk is headquartered at the downtown tech hub. Last summer, the company said its customer base had grown to 900, leading it to add about 10 employees.

    • 'Big, Audacious Project' Attracts San Fran Transplant to Fort Wayne

      One of the goals of Fort Wayne's $440 million Electric Works project is to attract talent to northeast Indiana. Before the first shovel of dirt is turned for the public-private partnership, it appears to be working. The project, planned for the historic former General Electric campus near downtown, has hired its first full-time employee. "I love the big, audacious project," said Crystal Vann Walstrom, Electric Works’ new Managing Director of Innovation.