Bad Compliance: Where Incentive Deals Go To Die

Posted: Updated:

Working in the field of site selection and incentives can be exciting. Big announcements, meeting important elected officials, and attending celebratory dinners are all in a day's work.

Then there is incentives compliance, which is probably considered the opposite of exciting. Compliance? You know, the piles of paperwork that must be completed at least annually to ensure that the state and local economic incentives everyone was celebrating at the groundbreaking are actually realized by the employer.

Boring, right? But SO important.

This topic is fresh in my mind as our team just completed more than 300 abatement compliance filings in time for Indiana’s May 15 filing deadline. Like many states, Indiana has a very rigid and unforgiving law: If this filing is late by even one day, the entire abatement can be denied. No questions asked. Given that the value of a single abatement can be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, complying with these deadlines is critically important.

Studies estimate only 25 percent of all incentives are fully realized. When I served as an economic development director for a local Indiana community, I saw this firsthand. The amount of money companies left on the table due to non-compliance was staggering.

After my stint in the public sector, I entered the private sector knowing strong compliance services had to be at the cornerstone of what I did. So for more than a decade I built a national site selection practice at a commercial real estate firm, and I took pride in the quality of compliance services we provided to our clients. Often, the commercial real estate brokers I worked with would scratch their heads and ask me why I spent so much time in the compliance weeds, especially when a lot of my competitors ignored that part of the work. Somewhat smugly I would explain the importance of these efforts, content in the knowledge that my clients were getting superior service.

Then I joined an accounting firm. And my prior compliance efforts were put to shame. Our team – comprised of CPAs, tax attorneys, MBAs, and even an economist – not only makes sure the right forms get to the right places on time (essentially what my prior efforts covered), they consistently identify client reporting errors that result in tens of thousands of dollars our clients would otherwise lose.

And it’s not just client reporting errors that are an issue. Government processing errors are to blame as well. For example, earlier this year our team had the opportunity to teach a new gubernatorial administration in a western state how their incentive program was supposed to be implemented. The initial interpretation was wrong, and it would have cost our client $3.5 million. That’s no small number.

In most cases, compliance errors such as these result in lost savings that can’t be fixed. In other cases, errors can result in a lost year of benefits or even the termination of incentives altogether.

Back to the statistic I mentioned: Only 25 percent of incentives awarded to a project are actually received by companies. Due to a thorough compliance strategy and long-term partnerships with our clients, more than 97 percent of the performance-based incentives our clients qualified for last year were received. This serves to prove that it pays to have an effective compliance strategy in place. Without one, you will almost certainly be short-changed.

Katie Culp is president of KSM Location Advisors in Indianapolis.

  • Perspectives

    • Cyber Security: Out of Your Control - or Not?

      Good chance YOU have been a victim of a cyber security attack!  When a company gets hacked, you and other customers become the “victims” of the breach. That puts your identity at risk!  The FTC estimates 9 million Americans are victims of identity theft each year!  What’s the greatest potential for identity theft?  On-line shopping! Yikes!

    More

Subscribe

Name:
Company Name:
Email:
Confirm Email:
HTML
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections
INPower
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

Events



  • Most Popular Stories

    • Mark Miles (left) is the CEO of Hulman & Co. (IIB Photo/Alex Brown)

      Miles: Penske "Perfect Conclusion" for IMS

      Hulman and Co. Chief Executive Officer Mark Miles says once the Hulman-George family and board of directors made the decision to pursue a sale of the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, there was interest from numerous parties, but ultimately the deal with Roger Penske represented the best possible outcome. "There are sovereign funds around the world that I know were interested and there were other major entities, terrific companies, that could transact, but Roger is the...

    • Lime is pulling its scooters and bikes from South Bend.

      Lime Bikes and Scooters Departing South Bend

      California-based Lime is pulling its lime-colored bicycles and electric scooters from the city of South Bend, according to WNDU-TV.  Lime bicycles first appeared in South Bend in 2017, followed by the addition of scooters in 2018. 

    • (image courtesy of Pixabay/.Magnascan)

      Gov. Holcomb Declares Emergency on Propane Shortage

      Citing an emergency with the state’s propane supply, Governor Eric Holcomb has signed an executive order which waives some of the time restrictions for truck drivers who haul the fuel. “The current demand for propane exceeds the locally available supply of propane,” states the executive order. Throughout the Midwest, there have been reports of propane shortages and long lines at terminals where truck drivers pick up their load of propane. The governor’s offi...

    • (photo courtesy Joseph Pete/The Times of Northwest Indiana)

      ArcelorMittal to Idle Furnace at Indiana Harbor West

      ArcelorMittal plans to idle a blast furnace at its Indiana Harbor West in East Chicago. A spokesperson tells our partners at The Times of Northwest Indiana employees will be reassigned and there will be no layoffs as a result of the move. 

    • First Merchants Bank Announces Leadership Changes

      Muncie-based First Merchants Corporation (NASDAQ - FRME) has announced a new shift in leadership. The company has elected H. Douglas Chaffin to the First Merchants Board of Directors and Tom Myers as region president for the Michigan market.