The Remote Work Debate: Which Side Will Win?

Posted: Updated:

In a recent announcement, IBM stated it will be implementing a new company-wide policy that no longer allows employees to work remotely. U.S.-based employees will have the choice to commute to one of six main offices located in New York, Austin, Atlanta, San Francisco, Raleigh, or Cambridge, or they will be asked to leave the company altogether. According to IBM, this decision was made as a solution to combat several consecutive quarters of revenue loss. Like IBM, other companies are starting to return to a more traditional workflow by removing the flexible remote work options that many employees have come to depend on.

It would appear we have a growing debate on our hands when it comes to whether companies should continue to offer remote work options to employees. Based on our insights from behind the scenes, it would appear that C-Suite executives believe employees are most productive with the structure that comes with a typical 9 to 5 schedule in a centralized office, while employees would argue that flexible work hours fuel their efficiency and positive performance over time. So, which side of the debate is correct?

The in-office perspective

To sympathize with the C-Suite side of the argument, fifty percent of respondents from a study that surveyed more than 1,400 CEOs and CFOs reported that corporate culture influences productivity, creativity and profitability. From the C-Suite standpoint, employees that work from home are more prone to distractions and temptations to be lax with their work, which is why executives argue that all employees should be in the office during the work day. With the ‘all staff in the office all the time’ solution, execs are able to better manage employees more directly and have more opportunities to provide immediate assistance when needed. As a secondary benefit, a permanent, centralized workplace creates an environment that promotes heightened productivity and focus among team members. Ensuring that all employees are in the office during work hours naturally provides face-to-face opportunities to develop a positive company culture, which typically can’t be done in the same way among remote employees.

The remote work perspective

Sixty-five percent of full-time employees 18 years or older surveyed for the State of Workplace Productivity Report agree that a flexible and remote work schedule would increase productivity. From the employee standpoint, the option to work remote has not only become an expectation, it has become an argument for increased efficiency due to the flexibility and opportunity to take more breaks as needed during the work day. C-Suite executives tend to still believe corporations can only be successful and productive when employees are at their desks where they can be consistently accounted for their work. This traditional idea may have made more sense in the past with limited access to technology outside of the office, but today employees are able to obtain their necessary work resources from almost anywhere, anytime. Improvements in technology makes working remotely possible today, and in some cases, more effective.

Neither working in an office nor working remotely is inherently superior. Both come with pros and cons, and both require compromises to be made to address the needs of C-suite executives and employees alike. Executive-level management teams need to recognize that flexible work hours help employees balance life and work, which means that some form of this benefit should be offered. Remote workers must demonstrate to C-suite executives their willingness to be in the office when needed and that they understand the value of working in a structured work environment. Compromises on both sides will hopefully lead to less employee turnover and an increase in company revenue over time.

About WorkSmart Systems Inc.

WorkSmart Systems Inc. is an Indianapolis-based Professional Employer Organization founded in 1998. As a leading PEO, WorkSmart serves over 200 client companies with employees in 37 states. WorkSmart is also an active member of the National Association of Professional Employer Organizations. Connect to more about the company by clicking here.

  • Perspectives

    • Big Data's Role in Site Selection

      In the world of site selection, companies assess the pros and cons of various factors to identify the location that best fits their current and future business needs. The list may seem endless: labor availability, utility needs and costs, real estate options, tax climate, incentives, quality-of-life considerations, even an area’s weather patterns and the likelihood of natural disasters. With the emergence of big data and the use of data analytics in all facets of business...

    More

Subscribe

Name:
Company Name:
Email:
Confirm Email:
HTML
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections
INPower
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

Events



  • Most Popular Stories

    • CIB OKs $120M Convention Center Expansion, Two Hotels

      The Capital Improvement Board of Directors in Indianapolis, Visit Indy and Indianapolis-based Kite Realty Group Trust (NYSE: KRG) have unveiled $120 million plans to expand the Indiana Convention Center and add 1,400 rooms. The proposal, approved Friday morning by the CIB, involves two new hotels, including a 38-story property, and extending the convention facilities to the current Pan Am Plaza site. In January, the CIB released a request for interest for a convention center...

    • $25M Behavioral Hospital Coming to Central Indiana

      Danville-based Hendricks Regional Health is partnering with US HealthVest to develop a stand-alone behavioral center on the Hendricks campus in Plainfield. Known as the Indianapolis Behavioral Hospital, the facility will provide specialized inpatient and outpatient mental health care to patients of all ages.

    • 'Heartbreaking' End For Nashville House

      The 91-year-old Nashville House restaurant is closing. The Brown County family dining staple will serve its last meal at the end of the month. In a post on Facebook, Gina Sarah Rogers, daughter of late-owners Andy and Fran Rogers, said it is "the end of an era and very heartbreaking." The restaurant is known for its country-style fried chicken and ham meals. Business on the property dates back to the late-1860s when an inn opened. It was acquired in...

    • DowDuPont Paints Picture of Ag Spin-Out

      Michigan-based DowDuPont Inc. is providing a detailed look at the scope of its agriculture spin-out Corteva Agriscience. The independent company, which will have a significant presence in Indianapolis, will be made up of a combination of Indianapolis-based Dow AgroSciences, DuPont Pioneer and DuPont Crop Protection. The spin is expected to take place June 1. In a notice to shareholders included in a U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing, CEO James Collins said...

    • Ubanwa was the owner and manager of Northwest Ambulance Service from 2007 until earlier this year. (photo courtesy of Northwest Ambulance Service)

      Ambulance Service Owner Charged With Fraud

      The owner of Northwest Ambulance Service in Crown Point is facing a dozen healthcare fraud-related charges. U.S. Attorney Thomas Kirsch’s office says Basil Ubanwa allegedly received hundreds of thousands of dollars by submitting fraudulent claims to Medicare and Medicaid for ambulance services between 2011 and 2018.