Social Issues And The C-Suite: Why Silence Isn’t Always Golden

Posted: Updated:

Our nation is politically divided and myriad channels exist for us to share our diversity of opinions online. As individuals, we use social media disclaimers like, "these thoughts are my own" or "my views don't speak for my employer." Then, we let our friends and followers know exactly what we think.

Corporate and non-profit leaders don't have that same luxury. They're more in the public eye and increasingly being asked to take positions on contentious issues at a time when speaking out might mean alienating numerous key stakeholders while delighting others.

These are challenging times and some leaders have observed the political minefields and decided to take a bunker mentality in hopes of riding out the storm. For decades, the practice of staying silent on social hot potatoes was a generally accepted path for companies and their CEOs to take. Today, the environment is different and when leaders stay silent on key issues, it can come with a price.

"What's changed most over the past year is that staying out of the fray now has a cost," said Duke University professor and CEO activism expert Aaron Chatterji in The Washington Post. "It's a choose-a-side mentality. The middle is harder to occupy. And with the proliferation of social media, it's kind of like a microphone that's always on. If you're not speaking out, it's more conspicuous."

With that as the backdrop, many of the corporate and non-profit leaders we work with feel that they’re damned if they speak out and damned if they don’t. And they’re right.

Facing that reality, how can leaders and organizations best prepare for what’s to come? The answer lies in approaching CEO activism with the same strategic rigor that goes into other areas of the business.

When organizations set out to launch a new product, service or strategic focus, they spend months – often years – analyzing what the market needs, talking to investors or donors, aligning with supportive stakeholders, developing plans for coming to market and more. This same rigor and diligence is needed when it comes to taking positions on major social and economic issues.

Unfortunately, leaders often don’t have the luxury of taking months to figure out whether to take a position on a social issue or not. That’s why organizations should engage in preparedness planning that allows them to:

Map out the various social and economic issues they may need to address;

Think through the potential risks and rewards of action (or inaction) based on their key audiences such as consumers, investors, donors, employees, etc.;

Prioritize the subjects and topics they want to be proactive, reactive or silent on;

Find other industry or community allies willing to stand with them in support of their position;

Draft strategic messages and statements for sharing with key audiences;

Continually monitor issues so that engagement plans can be updated in real time.

When leading these preparedness planning sessions, we encourage leaders to think strategically about who needs to be in the room. The intent is to ensure that a diversity of perspectives - political persuasion, race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, socioeconomic status, gender identity, religion and more - are represented. Yes, these planning dialogues can be challenging, but mistakes happen when leaders only invite those people who will tell them what they want to hear.

During this time of great national division and unrest, it’s easy to understand the temptation to go into the bunker and wait things out. Some leaders might think it’s just the big tech companies or employers with large millennial workforces that need to weigh in. But that’s not the case. Staying silent on the big issues of our time - even for the most traditional of American companies - can come with a price.

That's why now is the time to start asking, what does your organization stand for and how prepared are you to respond when asked for your point of view?

Mike Marker is senior partner at VOX Global.

  • Perspectives

    • The Art of The Apology

      You screwed up. You handled something the wrong way, or you failed to handle it when you should have. Now what are you going to do? If you're a big company, you're probably going to screw up some more. Oh, you’ll attempt some kind of public apology, but it will be so halfhearted or passive-aggressive that you'll get called on it, and you’ll find yourself taking a second whack at the apology tree. That's the conclusion I’ve drawn as I've...



  • Most Popular Stories

    • $600M Waste-to-Fuel Plant Coming to Gary

      A California-based renewable jet fuel and diesel producer has announced plans for a massive investment in northwest Indiana. Fulcrum BioEnergy Inc. says it will invest $600 million to build the Centerpoint BioFuels Plant in Gary, which will convert municipal solid waste into renewable transportation fuel. The project is expected to create up to 163 jobs by the end of 2022. The Indiana Economic Development Corp. says Centerpoint will be located at an industrial site that will be...

    • National Guard Academy Targets At-Risk Youth

      Indiana's adjutant general says the Hoosier Youth Challenge Academy in Knightstown continues to make a difference by offering at-risk teenagers a second chance. The academy, which was established in 2007, will Saturday celebrate another graduating class. The program uses quasi-military training, structure and discipline for students between the ages of 16 and 18 who have dropped out of school or are severely deficient in credits. In an interview on Inside INdiana Business...

    • Scotty's Brewhouse Files For Bankruptcy

      Indianapolis-based Scotty's Brewhouse has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. The company says the decision was "driven largely by the challenges of some specific locations and was necessary because of the way the company was structured corporately." As a result of the deal, Scotty's will close four of its restaurants by the end of the year. In a news release provided to Inside INdiana Business...

    • Committee to Steer Future of Bloomington Hospital Site

      A newly-formed group tasked with providing the next steps for the Indiana University Health Bloomington Hospital property will hold its first meeting Monday. The Hospital Re-Use Steering Committee will begin the effort to re-envision the property, which will be acquired by the city upon completion of the new Indiana University Health Regional Academic Health Center.

    • Preferred Route For I-69 Bridge Unveiled

      The team overseeing the I-69 Ohio River Crossing project has unveiled a preferred route for the extension of the interstate connecting Evansville and Henderson, Kentucky. The group has also released the Draft Environmental Impact Statement for the effort, which identifies preferred alternatives for the route with different tolling options. The project team, which includes the Indiana Department of Transportation and the Kentucky Transportation Cabinet, is recommending the...