Background Screening Shouldn't Be a One-Time Thing

Posted: Updated:

Most people have flaws, but a funny thing happens after companies hire them. They become perfect angels, incapable of doing anything illegal or immoral. Do you find that hard to believe? So do I.

But when you look at approach to background screening that’s used by those companies, post-hiring perfection is the only logical explanation. Before the companies hire new employees, they subject them to extensive background checks. Then, once they’re on the payroll, they’re never checked again.

So what happens when one of those trusted employees is picked up for shoplifting, a DUI, or even a sex crime? Nothing, if you don’t know about it. That’s the problem when companies limit background screening to pre-employment. If the employee is convicted of a crime -- even a serious or troubling crime -- down the road, the only way the employer will learn about it is if the employee owns up, and that’s something criminals tend to sidestep.

The issue has recently been in the news, as the Indiana General Assembly wants to ensure that school employees undergo background checks every few years, instead of just as a condition of hiring. We see the value. A couple years ago, we performed a background check on a candidate for a position with a school district, and it came back clear. He apparently didn’t get the job, because 30 days later, we performed a second background check when he applied with another district. We discovered that he had been arrested for child sexual solicitation a week after the first check. Had the first school district hired him, they would have had no idea.

Ongoing background checks are obviously important when dealing with vulnerable populations, such as children, senior citizens, and people with developmental disabilities. But they’re no less important when it comes to your employees. Would you want a male employee with a history of sex crimes or domestic violence working unsupervised among female employees? Beyond the ethical argument, there’s the fact that you could be sued for negligent retention if that employee commits some kind of act against another employee.

I believe most people are good, and our extensive experience with background checks bears that out. The vast majority of people have nothing in their past that raises eyebrows. But the simple truth is that things can happen in people’s lives that lead to changes in their behavior. Someone who has been scrupulously honest can become a reluctant thief after falling into a gambling addiction or substance abuse issues. Emotional trauma can lead someone’s life to spin out of control, causing them to make bad decisions. And sometimes, problems go undetected. For example, 80 percent of people arrested as sex offenders have no criminal history. It doesn’t mean they weren’t committing crimes before the arrest; it just means they hadn’t been caught yet.

If your company performs pre-employment background checks, you’ve taken an important step to protect your employees and assets. I’d recommend that you take the process to the next level by setting up a program of ongoing checks. The frequency depends on how closely you need to monitor employee behavior. If your employees are responsible for vulnerable people or have access to expensive assets, you may want to check them every couple years. For most positions, performing a recheck every four to five years will probably be sufficient.

Another benefit of an ongoing program is that it can have value as a deterrent. Just as random drug testing can dissuade an employee from dabbling in illegal substances, an ongoing background check program sends a message that if you do something wrong, we’re going to find out about it, and it may cost you your job.

You (or your background check partner) can set up some kind of automated process tied to employment anniversaries. The process can email employees, let them know they’re due for a check, and provide a deadline and a link to order the check. If employees are uneasy with the idea, remind them that you’re concerned about their security and want to make sure that nobody is a potential danger to their well-being.

Still hesitant? We’ve had several large employers ask us to develop recheck programs for their employees, and nearly every one of those programs has revealed information they didn’t know about employees. The results didn’t always warrant termination, but they led to tough conversations and perhaps a different level of supervision. Who on your team might be harboring a secret?

Mike McCarty is CEO of Danville-based Safe Hiring Solutions.

  • Perspectives

    • How to Find a New Audience After Hitting a Marketing Plateau

      It may sound like a marketer’s dream scenario: efforts have proven to be so successful it appears a company has completely saturated their target audience. While it may be a good problem to have, it still may be a problem. Hitting a marketing plateau is an opportunity for companies in any industry to reevaluate, re-energize and come to the table with new ideas for better understanding existing customers and engaging new audiences.



  • Most Popular Stories

    • Shaina Keck

      Pier 48 Manager Named

      FK Restaurant Group has named Shaina Keck sales and banquet manager for Pier 48 Fish House and Bar in downtown Indianapolis. She previously served in sales at Kilroy's Bar & Grill. Keck is a graduate of Indiana University Kelly School of Business with a bachelor of science degree in finance and accounting with a concentration in international studies.  
    • (image courtesy of The Times of Northwest Indiana)

      Crews Start Demolition of Carson's in Hammond

      The face of downtown retail in Hammond is changing once again with the demolition of Carson’s department store, the one-time the anchor of Woodmar Mall. Our partners at The Times of Northwest Indiana report excavating crews have started to demolish the last vestige of the shopping center which stood since the 1950s. 

    • (photo courtesy of WTHR-TV)

      Andrew Luck Retiring from NFL

      In a shocking development following the Indianapolis Colts' preseason loss to the Chicago Bears, quarterback Andrew Luck has announced his retirement from the NFL. Luck, who did not play in Saturday's game, said the number of injuries he has suffered throughout his professional career "has taken my joy of this game away." Luck teared up during a news conference in which he made his announcement. "After 2016 where I played in pain and was unable to regularly...

    • Alorica Inc. announces it will close its Lafayette office.

      Lafayette Call Center Closing; 147 to Lose Jobs

      A Lafayette call center is closing its doors, leaving 147 people without a job. California-based Alorica Inc. sent a letter Thursday to the Indiana Department of Workforce Development, notifying the agency of the closure. The letter is required by the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act.  

    • (Image courtesy of Northern Indiana Commuter Transportation District)

      Michigan City Commits $12M to South Shore Track Project

      The Michigan City Common Council has formally committed to contribute $12 million towards the proposed $416 million Double Track project for the South Shore commuter line. Our partners at The Times of Northwest Indiana report the council voted unanimously to pay $7 million upfront and finance the remaining $5 million through a 20-year bond issue.