Indiana's Regrettable Struggle to Pass Hate Crime Legislation

Posted: Updated:

It shouldn’t be this hard.

The Senate’s Public Policy Committee voted 9-1 in favor of SB-12 this week, a bill that would have codified (as written) hate crime bias to include protections for race, religion, color, sex, gender identity, disability, national origin, ancestry, sexual orientation, and age.

SB-12 then made its way to the full Senate. Preceded by a lengthy deliberation by the Senate’s Republican caucus, the Senate voted 33-16 in favor of a watered down amendment to the bill, removing the pivotal definition of bias. The Senate soon followed with a vote on the entire bill, including the bias-stripping amendment. It passed 39-10.

We saw this fight coming. Before the legislature even went into session, the question of whether Indiana would pass meaningful hate crime legislation was the sole fixation of Statehouse prognosticators going into the 2019 session. Republican leaders preemptively cautioned that passing enumerated hate crime protections would be a tough hill to climb.

Social politics and cultural factors have undoubtedly influenced the debate. The fervent beliefs of those opposed to expansive protections are loud and wield tremendous political power. Similar to the originating architects of RFRA, those opposed to legislatively protecting categorized classes of victims have drowned out the pleas from business leaders who want Indiana to stop being center court for radioactive social battles and simply focus on creating a welcoming environment for prospective employees.

This talent attraction concern is well-founded. Indiana is in a workforce development war with competitor states. The challenge to create human capital capacity amid historically low unemployment has never been greater.

As site selectors, the most common question we field on the topic is whether issues such as RFRA and hate crime truly factor into the location decisions of businesses. Or, have interest groups manipulated corporate outrage around these issues in order to advance their progressive agenda?

Opponents against hate crime legislation argue this debate is much ado about nothing. The fact is that these issues do matter. A lot. The workforce is changing quickly. It’s younger, exceedingly more tolerant than the generations that came before, and significantly more influential in corporate decision-making. Today’s job candidates are more attuned to the policies of their prospective employers and the jurisdictions where they choose to business.

At their core, business decisions are based on fundamental principles of running a successful company. If businesses can’t find the necessary workforce to support growth, they will look elsewhere. Indiana’s self-inflicted wounds in the hate crime arena do nothing but hurt its reputation with companies and job seekers.

The Hall of Fame football coach Bill Parcells once said. “You are what your record says you are.” There are no moral victories in sports. You either win or lose. We’ve reached that point in Indiana’s failure to pass hate crime legislation. This isn’t about “giving it our best shot” or passing a generic law that cynically professes to cover everyone while protecting no one. We need to do this definitively and unambiguously or concede that Indiana believes some hate crimes are worse than others.

This is a call-to-action not just to legislators but to all of us. When a company considers locating its business in Indiana in the context of the hate crime issue, it doesn’t distinguish between those calling the shots and those opposed. Whatever the policy is, it becomes “our” hate crime policy. And, when CEOs deem that policy emblematic of a culture that celebrates Hoosier Hospitality except when we’re being our least hospitable, they view us as poor business partners.

We need to ask ourselves the question, "What kind of state do we want to be?"

That answer, much like the effort to pass hate crime legislation, shouldn’t be this hard.

  • Perspectives

    • Mitigating Your Company’s Cybersecurity Risk

      Frequently, I encounter people who think that a software developer understands all languages and can “fix” anything tech related. While that may be true for a few, areas of expertise within tech evolve as rapidly as the technology itself. For instance, there was a time (not long ago) when operating in the cloud was revolutionary. Today, it is considered best practices for some or all of an organization to function within a cloud. Managed information technology began with...

    More

Subscribe

Name:
Company Name:
Email:
Confirm Email:
HTML
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections
INPower
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

Events



  • Most Popular Stories

    • (photo courtesy of the town of Plainfield)

      Plainfield Breaks Ground on Parking Structure

      The first piece of a redevelopment plan for downtown Plainfield is underway. City and community leaders have broken ground on the new Downtown Plainfield Parking Structure, which is expected to be complete in the late summer or early fall of 2020.

    • Tony Bates previously worked for companies including Skype, Microsoft and Cisco.

      Genesys Names New CEO

      California-based Genesys has selected former Skype CEO Tony Bates as its new chief executive officer. The company, which employs more than 800 in Indianapolis, says Bates' predecessor, Paul Segre, will continue as chairman.

    • The Waterside project aims to transform 100-acres of the former GM Stamping Plant site. (photo courtesy of Ambrose Property Group)

      Ambrose, Glick Partner on Waterside

      Indianapolis-based Ambrose Property Group has announced a key partnership for the redevelopment of the former GM Stamping Plant in downtown Indianapolis. The commercial real estate firm is teaming up with the Gene B. Glick Co. to build and manage apartments as part of the $1.4 billion mixed-use redevelopment project. Ambrose says the partnership is also part of plans to catalyze "philanthropic and community-centric strategies to strengthen Indianapolis." The firm also...

    • (photo courtesy Dax Norton)

      Whitestown Tops Indiana's Fastest-Growing Communities

      The Indiana Business Research Center at the Indiana University Kelley School of Business says Whitestown in Boone County is Indiana's fastest-growing community for the eighth consecutive year. The center says the town's population nearly tripled, from 3,132 in 2010 to 8,627 last year. Westfield in Hamilton County is not far behind. Its population grew 5.2 percent in 2018, according to information reported by the U.S. Census Bureau. Other communities on the list include...

    • I-65 INDOT construction map

      I-65 Construction Update

      Construction work is scheduled to start next week on I-65 near downtown Indianapolis. Indiana Department of Transportation crews will begin to clean up the interstates after two years of freeze/thaw cycles. Crews will be working in segments, including patching and repaving work. INDOT crews will begin work in earnest on northbound and southbound in segments, beginning on weekend nights from April 26 through August.