Local Fiscal Challenges Belong on The State Budget Session Agenda

Posted: Updated:
Chris Watts is president of the Indiana Fiscal Policy Institute. Chris Watts is president of the Indiana Fiscal Policy Institute.

Out of the hundreds of bills on its docket this year, the General Assembly has a constitutional duty to pass only one – a biennial budget.  But as lawmakers wrangle over statehouse spending issues like teacher pay, they can’t neglect their role in the budget challenges facing city halls and county courthouses.

A mix of state policies, local decisions and judicial interpretations all shaped today’s climate, filled with jostling for space under property tax caps and grappling with revenue shortfalls.  As Indiana struggles to find the right balance between traditional affordability and higher-tech economic aspirations, we have to consider whether our ‘do more with less’ approach to local government helps or hurts our cause.

Any  such discussion has to start with a refresher on the impact of property tax caps: There are thousands of taxing authorities – counties, cities and towns, townships and special districts like libraries – across Indiana.  Many levy property taxes, but individual tax bills are ‘capped:’ Homeowners pay up to 1% of their home’s assessed value, farmers and landlords pay 2%, and other business properties are capped at 3%.

When a property owner hits their cap, all the overlapping layers of government dividing up that tax revenue get less than anticipated. This means hundreds of millions of dollars a year uncollected by local schools, for local roads, police and fire protection and other services.

Property taxes have been capped for a decade, but Indiana has been gradually replacing property taxes with sales taxes to support schools since the 1970s.  Other local units have gained authority over (primarily) income taxes but remain in a tough spot: Per capita revenues are down, income taxes are more volatile (rising and falling with the economy), and the caps make unexpected deficits an annual threat.

For many Hoosier taxpayers, the tradeoff has been a more predictable property tax bill, but less predictable performance from the governments closest to them.  Spending on capital projects has dropped sharply, the cost of police and fire protection has crowded out other priorities from leaner budgets, and there’s less ability to plan ahead or make long-term commitments.

Every legislative session seems to feature a raft of legislation trying to reform or repair some peripheral part of this system.  This year there are bills to give counties fiscal authority over library boards and give school districts a voice on redevelopment commissions, to bring more clarity to the shared challenge of the caps. 

There are plans to compel townships to spend their unused surpluses and to free up revenues from tax increment districts for everyday infrastructure needs.  There’s also a potential fix for a looming court decision (involving the Hancock County Assessor) that could classify certain sewer and stormwater fees against the property tax cap limits, wreaking even more havoc across local public finance.

So, while the massive budget bill (HB1001) will set state spending priorities, a dozen or more proposals are aimed at influencing the fiscal choices made by counties, cities and towns for years to come.  But changing the current trajectory will take more than tweaking TIF rules or tinkering with library tax levies.

Soon-to-be-released research from the Indiana Fiscal Policy Institute charts revenue-and-expenditure trends over the last forty years (from the ‘Bowen tax package’ to market-rate assessments and the tax cap era).  It confirms that local government spending in Indiana is consistently lower than the U.S. average, and has diverged more sharply over the last decade. 

The authors don’t draw conclusions from the data, but their findings suggest a growing concern for Indiana’s future amid a broad consensus that human capital is our top economic development issue; to build a broader tax base and more competitive business climate, we need more Hoosiers contributing to our talent pool.

But people are attracted to places with a vibrant quality of life, cultural and recreational amenities, diverse neighborhoods that offer the basics, like safe streets and good schools.  Local investments are vital in creating appealing places to live.  Local government may be surviving under its current constraints, but have we created a revenue system that impairs our ability to thrive in this competition for talent?

Whether through ‘investment hubs’ or some other new fiscal framework, we should find ways to empower local governments to realistically consider longer-term capital needs and transformative investments in livability, acting regionally as appropriate.

The Fiscal Policy Institute is ready to add independent analysis to this important discussion; we may not find the right answer this year, but we have to start thinking beyond the two-year budget cycle to the twenty-year challenges facing the local communities and metropolitan regions that are the building blocks of our economy, and the places Hoosiers call home.

Chris Watts is President of the Indiana Fiscal Policy Institute.

  • Perspectives

    • Chris Watts is president of the Indiana Fiscal Policy Institute.

      Revenue Forecast Shapes State Spending – And Surplus - Negotiations

      This week, the State Budget Committee heard an updated revenue forecast that could best be described as overcast but not stormy – yet.  Sales taxes, the largest source of state revenue, fared well from the December forecast – down a modest $15 million over the 2020-21 budget (and likely to be buoyed by new policies for online hotel and retail sales taxes moving through the legislature).  Individual income taxes showed a more dramatic decline, continuing a...



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • The Vogue opened as a movie house in 1938, then reopened as a nightclub in 1977. (Picture Courtesy: The Vogue)

      Tech Vets Purchase Popular Indy Nightclub

      A group of Indianapolis tech entrepreneurs has bought a popular nightclub in the city's Broad Ripple neighborhood. High Alpha co-founder Eric Tobias and former MOBI executives Scott Kraege and Andrew Davis say they will retain the Vogue's current staff to manage the venue's day-to-day operations. The new owners say they will detail plans to reinvigorate the Vogue through enhanced fan experience and engagement in the coming months. Tobias, Kraege and Davis purchased the Vogue...

    • (rendering courtesy of the city of Fishers)

      Fishers Test Kitchen Looking For Applicants

      The city of Fishers has begun searching for chefs to take part in the first cohort at the Fishers Test Kitchen restaurant accelerator. Three participants will be selected for the accelerator, which aims to provide a space for them to grow, try new concepts and ultimately open their own restaurants. The accelerator, which the city says will be the first of its kind in the state, will open this fall inside the Sun King Brewing location in The Yard at Fishers District.

    • $9 Million Microscope to be Installed at Purdue

      Purdue University, the Indiana University School of Medicine, IU Bloomington, the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Eli Lilly and Co. and the Indiana Biosciences Research Institute have collaborated to bring the latest version of a cryo-electron microscope to Indiana. The nearly $9 million machine will be housed in Purdue's Discovery Park. 

    • More than 1,000 structures at the former Indiana Army Ammunition Plant need to be demolished.

      River Ridge Planning Further Growth

      The River Ridge Development Authority in southern Indiana is looking to continue the growth of one of the region's main economic drivers. The organization says it plans to invest more than $315 million over the next two decades in order to complete infrastructure improvements at the River Ridge Commerce Center and prepare parcels for development. Executive Director Jerry Acy says less than 30 percent of the 6,000-acre business park has been built out for development and...

    • Governor Eric Holcomb will be on hand for the announcement. (image courtesy WTHR-TV)

      Holcomb Makes Board Appointments

      Governor Eric Holcomb has made another round of appointments to various boards and commissions, as well as judicial appointments throughout the state. They include the Board of Safety Review, the Indiana Economic Development Corp. Board of Directors, and Oversight Committee on Public Records.