Direct Primary Care: A Growing Trend

Posted: Updated:

For a moment, imagine your relationship with your doctor could be more like other professional service relationships. It's hardly a novel concept. For decades that's how it worked... You would visit your doctor, receive your needed care and pay the doctor directly for time and services. 

We've reached a point now, however, where it seems there are more people who don't remember this than who do. Decades of governmental intervention, special interest lobbying, and administrative tinkering have taken their toll. Primary care doctors have an average of 3,000 patients each, and face declining reimbursements and increasing mandates on their time. Patients routinely face longer wait times, shorter office visits, and increasing uncertainty about their insurance. Unfortunately for us all, there appears to be no end in sight.

A 2016 Merritt Hawkins Survey of over 17,000 physicians found that 62 percent of doctors had “somewhat or very negative feelings” about the future of the medical profession. Only an astonishing 14 percent felt like they had the time they needed to provide the highest standard of care. A full 90 percent cited regulatory burdens or a loss of clinical autonomy as their leading job dis-satisfiers. The message is clear – once again, something must change. 

Many see Direct Primary Care (DPC) as part of the solution. DPC practices are fixed-fee physician groups that are enabling patients and doctors to re-take control of their healthcare.  DPC practices do not rely on insurance billing for revenue. Their fees are paid entirely by their patients, who then also maintain insurance for subspecialty care, hospitalization, and other medical needs. 

In DPC models, pre-set fees are periodically billed to patients for a defined array of services, sometimes costing as little as $70 or $80 per month. DPC doctors also generally limit their patient volumes to 600-1,000 patients to ensure more time and attention can be spent with each patient. DPC patients receive longer appointments, more timely access, and often a greater focus on preventive care. Preliminary data suggests this also helps reduce overall systemic cost, as claims for subspecialty referrals and hospital encounters tend to go down among DPC patients. 

Over 600 DPC practices currently exist in the U.S., delivering care to as many as 250,000 patients. An estimated 1,400 more DPC practices are expected to open in the next five years, not to mention the proliferation of larger, employer-based DPC clinics are also on the rise.

This trend is alive right here in Indiana. The first known DPC practice in Indiana was established in Indianapolis in 2002. By 2007 there were several more, and larger employer-based clinics had also begun to appear. Today, there are more than a dozen private practices and approximately 30 DPC physicians practicing in the Indianapolis metropolitan area alone. Together, they will support an estimated 8,000 – 10,000 patients, with perhaps twice as many more seeing employer-based providers for their care. 

One big factor facilitating this growth is the support of the federal government. For all the endless debates over healthcare reform, Direct Primary Care is one of the few topics that is enjoying broad-based bipartisan support. More than 20 states, including Indiana, have already passed legislation clarifying that the periodic-fee agreements between DPC doctors and their patients do not qualify as insurance. Knowing their agreements will not be regulated in this way makes it easier for DPC doctors to open their practices and provide patient care. 

The most important piece of national DPC legislation currently under review is H.R. 365, the Primary Care Enhancement Act. This bipartisan bill would close an IRS loophole that errantly categorizes DPC agreements as health plans. More importantly, it would categorize DPC agreements as HSA-eligible, qualified healthcare expenses. With a bit of luck and advocacy, a 2017 vote could still happen on this bill.

While all of this creates optimism for DPC in the context of needed healthcare reform, there is more of the story yet to be written. The reality is we don’t have enough primary care doctors to scale the DPC model. We need more. Thankfully, younger physicians in training are also recognizing the DPC trend. They are exploring DPC practice options in increasing numbers and will be part of the solution that allows these practices to grow with demand.

Perhaps the next 50 years will tell a new tale about healthcare in the U.S. One with enough doctors for everyone and happy patients who are having better care experiences at lower systemic costs. Perhaps then we’ll be providing for a truly patient-focused healthcare system.

Joe Rizzuto is chief operating officer of Priority Physicians.

  • Perspectives

    • Employers Are Key to Improving Healthcare

      It's no longer news that American healthcare is broken. In the U.S., we spend more than $3 trillion a year on healthcare - more than any other developed nation - yet we are in overall poorer health than similarly developed countries. But dealing with healthcare's myriad issues isn't the only challenge facing business owners and employers. They're also grappling with how to attract and retain a shrinking supply of employees.



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • Angie's List Campus Re-Imagined as Creative 'Playground'

      A group of investors, many with previous ties Angie's List, has closed on the acquisition of the company's former corporate campus. The backers that make up the Fred Abel LLC investment group are led by former Angie's List Chief Executive Officer Bill Oesterle and include participants in Indiana, Massachusetts, North Carolina, New York and Ohio. Boston-based Aquent CEO John Chuang is an investor and says the vision is to "create something far more than office space."

    • (photo courtesy WTHI-TV)

      Former Kellogg's Plant to Get New Life

      A Germany-based company is planning to establish operations in Vigo County. Our partners at WTHI-TV report Saturn Petcare will move into the former Kellogg’s plant in Seelyville, adding 200 jobs over the next five years. The company is looking to construct a new plant on the property, which could begin next year and be complete by 2020. The Seelyville Town Council has approved 10-year real and personal property tax abatements for the...

    • Berman: 'Decent Chance' For Special Session

      WIBC/Network Indiana Statehouse Bureau Chief Eric Berman believes the chances the General Assembly reconvenes for a special session are "slightly above 50-50." He says in his more than two decades covering the Statehouse, he has not experienced another session that ended like it did Wednesday with multiple bills dying when the House and Senate missed the midnight deadline. The Indiana Chamber contends the bodies failing to get HB 1316 to a final vote, alone, could...

    • Thomas Kirsch is the United States Attorney for the Northern District of Indiana.

      Former Social Security Admin Employee Serving Time For Fraud

      A former Social Security Administration employee has received a nearly four-year prison sentence for defrauding the federal government. Sharon Ramos has also been ordered to pay more than $550,000 in restitution following charges including falsifying government records, conversion of government money and wire fraud. Trial testimony indicates Ramos created fake entries and claims in Supplemental Security Income accounts leading to...

    • $2.5B Coal-to-Diesel Plant Proposed in Dale

      An energy company is proposing a $2.5 billion coal-to-diesel facility in Spencer County. Riverview Energy Corp., which is based in Delaware and has a presence in New York, says the operation would eventually produce 4.8 million barrels of diesel fuel and 2.5 million barrels of naphtha, a liquid used as a solvent, a fuel and in plastics. President Gregory Merle says the facility would be the only one of its kind in the U.S. and is the company's most ambitious project yet.