Stock Market: Stay In or Get Out?

Posted: Updated:

Recently we've enjoyed a bull market with stocks nearing an all-time high. The Standard & Poor 500 Index is up more than 300 percent from its low level of 2009! Investors are asking: Should I be in or out?

While some long-term investors are celebrating, others are wondering if they should pull out now before the market takes a nosedive. Does that sound like you? Before you make a hasty exit, you better be prepared to face the potential repercussions!

Pulling out of the stock market - even temporarily - presents its own set of risks. Here are three questions you'll need to consider prior to bidding the stock market adieu!

Question #1: Where to Stash My Cash?

If you sell your stock, you have a bunch of cash. Now the big question is what to do with it. One option is to keep it liquid at your bank. Banks are safer than the stock market, right? Yes, but you'll be lucky to get even a 1-percent return on your money from the interest you’ll receive. If you need growth, banks are not a great place to park your money for the long-term.

Here's an even more compelling reason against banking your money: Inflation is running around 2 percent per year. If your cash is earning less than 1 percent interest, you're losing "real" money each year.

What if you invest your cash in the bond market? Currently the yield on the Barclays Aggregate Bond Index is 2.24 percent. That’s a bigger return compared to putting your money in the bank, but not by much!

Bottom line: In this low interest-rate environment, there are no obvious places to park your cash and expect a decent return.

Question #2: When to Return to the Market?

When you decide to temporarily exit the stock market, you’re creating two important decision points - when to exit and when to return. Get either decision wrong and you’ll end up with a significant headache! The issue that generally gets the least upfront attention is when to return. It’s also the one that can have huge repercussions down the road.

Let's use 2016 as an example of what can happen when you reenter the stock market. During the first six weeks of the year, the S&P 500 Index dropped almost 12 percent. Many experts feared the U.S. economy was headed for a recession. Let's assume you got out before the market dropped. Lucky you! Now you have to decide when to get back in. What happened during the rest of 2016? The S&P 500 gained more than 22-percent from that low point at the beginning of the year.

  • If the market soared before you returned, you missed out. Meanwhile, investors who stayed the course reaped significant gains that will give them a cushion to soften the next downturn.
  • If you returned while the S&P was on the rise, you made some gains. Although, unlike those who stayed the course, you didn't receive the full benefit. Consequently, when the market drops, you won't have as big a cushion to fall back on.

Bottom line: The fear of losing money is a huge barrier for investors. If the market goes up, the longer you wait the more you stand to lose. If the market goes down, waiting is a virtue. Unfortunately, timing the market correctly is nearly impossible. Sticking to your long-term investment strategy will generally pay off.

Question #3: How to Supplement Lower Returns?

Many people exit the stock market because they think it’s too risky. It’s true that the stock market has more risk than a bank account or diversified bond portfolio, but it also has greater growth potential. And that shouldn't be ignored!

If you exit the stock market at the wrong time or stay out of it for an extended period, you’ll need to reevaluate how this will impact your long-term goals. If your portfolio return is lower than initially planned, you may need to save more to reach your goals. If saving more isn't an option, be sure to project your future financial situation in order to have realistic expectations.

Bottom line: If your investment portfolio does not achieve the return expected, you’ll need to make up for those lower returns to keep your financial goals on track.


Before you pull the trigger and exit the stock market, consider your long-term financial strategy. If growth is important, have a plan for re-investing and saving that will allow you to reach your future financial goals.

Ryan Collier is the Director of Investment Management with Bedel Financial Consulting Inc., a wealth management firm located in Indianapolis. For more information, visit their website at or email Ryan.

  • Perspectives

    • 5 Spring Cleaning Tips For Your Social Media

      We're finally there. Spring. And that I find... exciting! So, when thinking about spring, then spring cleaning, consider your social media clean up as well. When I read this week that an average brand has over 250 digital experiences now to manage online, if you have any type of digital footprint, you may not be far behind. Here are some tips to clean out and dust off that social media stuff.



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • 16 Tech estimates the first phase of development will create more than 2,600 jobs over 10 years.

      16 Tech Takes Big Steps Forward

      Indianapolis' 60-acre innovation community has announced two major boosts. The 16 Tech Community Corp. has landed a $38 million grant from Lilly Endowment Inc. to fund its initial development phase.The organization has also announced its first development agreement. The deal calls for Indianapolis-based Browning to construct three new buildings and renovate a facility as part of a $120 million investment. 16 Tech Community Corp. says the three-year grant sets the stage for...

    • Holcomb Names Workforce Council Chair

      Governor Eric Holcomb has made some leadership changes within his administration. The governor has selected Danny Lopez, who currently serves as his deputy chief of staff, as chairman of the new Governor's Workforce Council.

    • IoT Lab Opens With Eyes on Future

      The founder of the Indiana IoT Lab says the innovation and collaboration space is focused on an industry that will "future-proof" Hoosier businesses. John Wechsler says companies that are dialing into the Internet of Things are playing in a sector that is forecast to grow to $2.2 trillion. The facility Wednesday night hosted more than 700 at a grand opening event. Wechsler said some of the state's trademark industries will be "radically affected" by...

    • (photo courtesy Tow Yard Brewing Co.)

      Tow Yard Brewing Looking For Buyer

      Tow Yard Brewing Co. in Indianapolis is looking for a new owner. The company, which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in January, plans to auction off all of its equipment at a court-ordered auction next month, unless a buyer comes forward to acquire the brewery. 

    • Toyota Supplier Planning Growth in Princeton

      Princeton-based Vuteq USA Inc. has announced plans to build a new facility in Gibson County. The Gibson County Economic Development Corp. has confirmed to Inside INdiana Business the company, which makes components for Toyota vehicles, will invest $27 million to construct a new support center and plant, which would employ 400 people by 2022. Vuteq currently has a plant located just north of Toyota Motor Manufacturing Indiana in Princeton.