Labor Department Rescinds Joint Employer & Independent Contractor Guidance: What it Means For Employers

Posted: Updated:

Last week, US Secretary of Labor Alexander Acosta rescinded two Department of Labor (“DOL”) interpretation letters, which included expansive takes on joint employment and classification of workers as independent contractors. The previous letters, issued during the Obama administration, garnered powerful protest and were viewed as a fundamental threat to employers, especially franchises and industries reliant on temporary workers. While the rescission of the letters is a positive development for employers and supports the less aggressive enforcement stance of the current administration, the underlying concepts contained in those letters still apply.

If determined to be a “joint employer,” a company can be jointly liable with another company for complying with the Fair Labor Standards Act—the primary federal law governing minimum wages and overtime pay—and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act.

The DOL’s previous (now rescinded) marching orders applied joint employer liability to both vertical and horizontal employment relationships. In other words, an employer could be liable as a “joint employer” vertically where it hires another company who in turn hires the employee. The focus in vertical joint employment is on the relationship of the employee to each employer and whether the “economic realities” of the relationship show an economic dependence on both employers.  Examples of vertical joint employment under the DOL guidance could include temporary staffing agencies and host employers, subcontractors and general contractors, and franchisees and franchisors.

Similarly, joint employment may exist horizontally where an employee has employment relationships with two or more employers at the same time and the employers are sufficiently associated or related with respect to the employee such that they are both responsible for the actions that violate the law or for compliance, such as paying overtime on the cumulative hours worked. The focus in horizontal joint employment is on the relationship of the employers to each other. For example, when an employee works at two locations of the same restaurant brand, both of which are operated by separate legal entities, the two entities may be horizontal joint employers if they have the same individual owner, use the same payroll processing company, and the managers of each share supervisory responsibility of the employee.  Stated differently, according to the DOL, related entities who “share” employees may be horizontal “joint employers.”

As it relates to the misclassification of workers, the now-rescinded DOL interpretation had strongly stated that despite meeting traditional tests for contractor status, “most workers are employees.” The DOL noted that employees improperly labeled as independent contractors may miss out on things like minimum wage and overtime pay. Thus, the DOL applied an expansive definition of employee and was more likely to find an employment relationship. Here, again, the DOL focused on the “economic realities” of the relationship, looking to several factors, such as:

     • the employer’s control;
     • the employee’s opportunity for profit or loss;
     • who provides the necessary equipment and materials;
     • whether the service requires a special skill;
     • the permanency of the relationship, and;
     • whether the service is integral to the employer’s business (again, defaulting to employment status in most situations).   

Despite the rescissions, the concepts in the previous guidance may still haunt businesses. The federal statutory language, interpreting regulations, and relevant case law have not changed. In fact, the now-rescinded guidance specified that it was merely restating or summarizing existing law. Arguably, employers will still confront the expansive definitions in future proceedings brought by former or current employees. 

Further, the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB”), the first agency to adopt a more liberal standard of joint employment, has not changed its course. It remains to be seen if its steadfast commitment to a more liberal standard will remain and be applied to decisions under the National Labor Relations Act. President Trump has yet to pick nominees for the five-member board’s two open seats, which could impact the future of the NLRB’s adherence to the broader standard. 

Last week’s reversals demonstrate, however, a marked shift in the DOL’s position on existing and future agency enforcement. Those with existing audits can likely use the reversal as a tool toward resolution.  Further, employers can likely expect either fewer or less aggressive administrative inquiries and investigations going forward. Certainly, such a forecast is consistent with the administration’s overall philosophy of eliminating regulations and barriers to business across the board. 

Regardless of where the chips may fall, this is a good reminder to proactively manage your business’s relationship with other entities and contingent workers—whether contractors or temporary workers. Time spent reviewing and refreshing your employee pay practices, job descriptions, and responsibilities is always time well spent. Opportunistically, employers can use these changes to implement talent and other organizational structure changes while limiting potential impact on morale.

Should you require assistance with these suggested steps, please contact Catherine Strauss, Tami Earnhart or any member of the Ice Miller Labor, Employment, and Immigration Practice for further guidance. 

  • Perspectives

    • Scott Flood is the owner of Scott Flood Writing.

      It's About People, Not Products

      Today's companies offer an amazing array of products and services. Surprisingly, the best way to promote those products and services is to stop talking about them. No, I’m not advocating that products should sell themselves, or that marketing efforts are useless. Quite the contrary. What I’m saying is that so often, companies become so focused on their products and services that they forget why those products and services exist.

    More

Subscribe

Name:
Company Name:
Email:
Confirm Email:
HTML
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections
INPower
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

Events



  • Most Popular Stories

    • Long John Silver's Acquires Indiana Restaurants

      Louisville-based Long John Silver's has acquired more than 70 restaurants, most of which are located in Indiana, from Jasper-based ServUS. Financial terms of the deal were not disclosed, however the company says no jobs will be affected.

    • Anthem Details Indy HQ Plans

      Anthem Inc. (NYSE: ANTM) says it will invest $20 million into converting its largest downtown Indianapolis facility -- located on the south side of the city -- into its new corporate headquarters. The city says the move will keep the state's largest publicly-traded company in the city where it was founded nearly 75 years ago. The space will be home to more than 2,600 on-site workers and support over 2,300 additional workers throughout the state.

    • Hogsett Hopes Amazon 'Takes Note' of Indy Momentum

      Indianapolis mayor says Joe Hogsett Anthem Inc.'s (NYSE: ANTM) $20 million headquarters project, along with recent significant announcements from India-based Infosys (NYSE: INFY) and Genesys show the city remains a magnet for corporate headquarters. Hogsett says, even "without the 64,000-pound elephant in the room being mentioned," he expects a decision on the Amazon HQ2 location by the end of the year, and continues to believe Indy is...

    • (photo courtesy Blue Chip Casino)

      Michigan City Casino to Expand

      The Blue Chip Casino, Hotel & Spa in Michigan City is set to undergo an expansion later this year. Financial details were not released, however the casino says the effort will add nearly 15,000 square feet of meeting and event space. Construction on the expansion is expected to begin at the end of the year and be complete by the fall of 2019. The project will include a new 11,000-square-foot ballroom that can be divided into six smaller rooms, as well as 3,800 square feet of...

    • State Details Rural Strategic Plan

      Lieutenant Governor Suzanne Crouch and the Indiana Office of Community and Rural Affairs have unveiled their strategy to support and elevate rural communities throughout the state. The Strategic Plan for Rural Indiana focuses on several key priorities, including growing access to rural broadband service. Crouch says the plan was put together after OCRA received input from community members in rural areas and the agency will put that information into action.