More Affordable Health Care For Some Small Businesses

Posted: Updated:

Will the future bring more ObamaCare, some kind of new TrumpCare, or a WhateverCare that falls somewhere in-between? The uncertainty is raising the blood pressure of both business owners and covered employees, but it doesn't have to. There's already a proven alternative available to most Indiana companies.

It’s what’s known as medical bill-sharing programs. They may not refer to themselves as insurance, but they embody the basic concept. A group of members who meet certain risk profiles pools their funds with the expectation that if members incur medical costs, the program will pay the lion’s share.

And even though these programs are not insurance plans, they meet the standards of the Affordable Care Act, so members won’t face tax penalties.

There is a key difference between most of these programs and other individual health plan options: they’re offered by faith-based organizations and available only to people who share a particular set of religious beliefs. That doesn’t mean plan members all belong to one denomination. But it does mean that the application process involves certifying that they share the group’s fundamental tenets, most of which are consistent with evangelical Christian churches.

If that sounds surprising, it shouldn’t be. Most insurers were originally set up for the mutual benefit of specific groups, and many of today’s leading insurance companies have names that still reflect those groups. Like all risk pools, the shared bill plans have standards for behavior, such as rejecting applicants who use illegal drugs or smoke.

Bill-sharing programs have other parallels to traditional health plans. They have monthly payments that are similar to premiums. One program we frequently recommend has a PPO doctor network, with reimbursements handled in the same way most insurance companies do, and with reimbursements higher for in-network providers. Members are expected to pay a portion of fees when they receive services, much like the familiar copay. The programs also have deductible-like amounts that members are expected to pay before reimbursements kick in. And, if you have a pre-existing condition, there may be some limitations.

At the same time, most don’t offer some of the extras that drive health premiums up. Generally, preventive care isn’t free, so you may have to pay for annual physicals and your kids’ immunizations. Mental health and substance abuse coverage may be absent or minimal. That’s why the programs may not be the best choice for someone with complex health needs.

How do costs compare? In our experience, these bill-sharing programs cost far less per month than even bare-bones group insurance programs. By limiting the risk pool to members who meet the program’s standards, and giving members more control over expenses, the programs are able to keep costs low.

Since most of these shared plans are open to individuals, how does this apply to business owners and managers? Making shared plans available to your employees, and providing some of the funds to cover the membership cost, is an affordable alternative to the traditional group plan.

Business owners are well-acquainted with the frustrating ritual of group health plan renewals with premium increases that outpace inflation. If they choose to switch to another plan for better rates, they run the risk of infuriating employees whose doctors or preferred services may not be part of the new plan.

Shared medical-bill plans are just one alternative to group plans. Some employers have moved from paying for group health plans to making flat contributions to help employees offset the cost of individual coverage. That puts employees in charge of their own healthcare, giving them an incentive to make more affordable choices. The concept is at the heart of plans being discussed in Washington, but there’s no reason that an employer has to wait for Congress to act.

If you’re thinking that making employees choose their own healthcare plans is a recipe for chaos, think again. There are companies like ours that have organized the process. We maintain a roster of individual plans (including shared options) and manage the enrollment and payroll deduction process. That way, employers are assured that their benefit dollars are actually paying for benefits, and not being pocketed as extra pay.

Whether a shared medical-bill plan is right for you and your employees, the broader message is that you don’t have to wait for relief from Washington to take control of health-care costs. Alternatives such as those described here can be a much more sensible and affordable way to provide the benefits your employees want and need without reducing your profitability.

Scott Lingle, RHU is co-founder and CEO of Remodel Health.

  • Perspectives

    • Don't Drop Your Guard

      Why do you lock your home every time you leave it? Most likely, you do it to keep thieves out. Since you haven't experienced any thefts, why continue to lock up? Okay, you're probably shaking your head and thinking that I must not be all that bright. You keep locking your door because you don't want to create an opening for the thieves. Then help me understand what I've seen many companies do over the years...



Company Name:
Confirm Email:
INside Edge
Morning Briefing
BigWigs & New Gigs
Life Sciences Indiana
Indiana Connections


  • Most Popular Stories

    • Bloomington Chamber Names '10 Under 40' Winners

      The Greater Bloomington Chamber of Commerce has announced the winners of the 2017 “10 Under 40 Awards.” The honors are given to professionals under the age of 40 based on their professional achievement, leadership and civic involvement efforts. 

    • BorgWarner to Break Ground on Noblesville Center

      Michigan-based BorgWarner will break ground today on a $28 million technical center in Noblesville. The 100,000 square-foot facility will consolidate the company’s existing centers in Anderson and Pendleton into one location. 

    • New Trailer Previews Columbus-Focused Movie

      A national publication has published a theatrical trailer for a Hollywood movie that was filmed in and features an Indiana city. Entertainment Weekly unveiled an exclusive preview of Columbus, which stars John Cho, Haley Lu Richardson and Parker Posey. The film focuses on a Korean-born man, played by Cho, whose father ends up in a coma and hospitalized in the Bartholomew County city. He forms a relationship women, played by Richardson, who is an expert on the local architecture.

    • Brown County Tourism Officials Propose $10M Concert Hall

      Plans for a $10.2 million indoor entertainment venue have been announced in Brown County. The Brown County Convention and Visitors Bureau and the Brown County Convention and Visitors Commission say the proposed 2,000-seat facility would be county-owned and paid for through an innkeeper's tax over 30 years. The Maple Leaf Performing Arts Center, as leaders are calling it for now, still needs town, county and local community organization and commission approval.

    • Nature Preserve Efforts at White River Bluffs Continue

      The Central Indiana Land Trust says it has completed the first phase of a $2.9 million effort to establish White River Bluffs in Marion County as a nature preserve that includes 12.2 acres along the White River. The property features some of the oldest trees in Indianapolis, including some estimated to be between 200 and 500 years-old.