Repeal Durbin Amendment And Put Consumers Over Profits

Posted: Updated:

In today's economy, businesses that value customers over profits are rewarded with loyalty, a sense of trust that can be hard to develop during typical business transactions, and a long-term customer who spreads the word about you. No one knows this better than credit unions, which exist solely to serve our members.

With 158 credit unions in Indiana, the Indiana Credit Union League and our members are proud to serve more than two million Hoosiers with checking accounts, credit cards, IRAs, $17.5 billion in loans, and other services to meet their financial needs. Because we’re not-for-profit, earnings for operations or reserves not needed are returned to our members through lower loan rates, higher savings rates, and low-cost (or even free) services. This means that all of our decisions come from a place of supporting our members, not adding to our bottom lines.

However, this same mindset cannot be applied to big-box retailers, who have used a policy known as the Durbin Amendment to pocket $6-8 billion annually for the past six years at the expense of consumers.

To provide you with some background as to how this came about, the amendment was tacked on to the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act last minute at the insistence of big-box stores’ lobbyists, who promised consumers would see lower prices at the register under the policy. While there were no formal hearings or any studies conducted to assess its potential impact, it passed Congress and went into effect in 2011.

Under the Durbin Amendment, Congress placed price controls on the costs merchants pay to accept and authorize debit card transactions, otherwise known as interchange fees. Financial institutions like credit unions put this interchange revenue toward the electronic payments network’s maintenance, as well as important innovation that makes paying with a card or mobile wallet safer and easier for consumers and businesses. It also is an important component of free checking that is available to consumers from many credit unions.

Because of the price controls, credit unions alone have seen a $1.1 billion decrease in our interchange fee revenue. The losses have extended to the broader banking industry as well.  For example, the largest institutions, which process a majority of debit transactions and therefore have covered the majority of costs associated with running the electronic payments network, have seen a 50 percent reduction in their revenue. Now, credit unions and other small institutions, who already have a higher cost structure due to our size, have to bear a larger share of the costs of running a significantly less profitable system.

To make matters worse, a second provision in the Durbin Amendment includes a set of costly routing requirements that are difficult for smaller financial institutions like credit unions to bear. In fact, overall regulatory compliance costs for credit unions have grown by 39 percent over the past seven years, totaling $7.2 billion.

This only ends up hurting our members, who make up nearly one-third of our state’s residents.

It’s time for Congress to take action on the failed Durbin Amendment and end this policy’s harmful overreach. Not only would this benefit the 109 million members of credit unions around the country, including those of us here in Indiana, but it would end the $42 billion merchant markup going into big-box retailers’ pockets instead of their customers’ wallets.

Let’s make 2017 the year that we prioritize consumers over profits.

John McKenzie is the president of the Indiana Credit Union League.

  • Perspectives

    • Why Blogging Without Rules Produces the Best Content

      I spend a lot of time talking with people about what makes writing good. Depending on who you ask, good writing might be exciting and illustrative. It might be simple and efficient. If you ask someone who works in marketing, good writing translates to whatever helps a marketing strategy generate more leads, or more sales, or more of whatever a business is looking to gain. Though I fully respect and agree with this results-oriented perspective on content, in practice it can be...



  • Most Popular Stories

    • The Honda Greensburg plant opened in 2008.

      Honda to Invest $4M, Add Jobs at Greensburg Plant

      The American Honda Motor Co. continues to invest in its Greensburg, Indiana plant as it has announced the factory will be producing the company’s first electrified sport utility vehicle in the U.S. The company says it will invest more than $4 million and add 34 new jobs in the plant to support production of the CR-V Hybrid.  

    • (photo courtesy of The Times of Northwest Indiana)

      Valpo Mansion May Fall to Wrecking Ball

      A one-time mansion that once hosted dignitaries and politicians while they visited Valparaiso appears to be facing demolition, following years of decline and disrepair.  The stately mansion, known locally as the Brown home, maybe knocked down and replaced with condominiums, according to our partners at The Times of Northwest Indiana. 

    • Socio received the Top-Rated Overall Culture award. (Provided Photo/Socio)

      Inaugural Tech Culture Award Winners Unveiled

      Indianapolis-based Powderkeg has unveiled the winners of the inaugural Indiana Breakout Tech Culture Awards. Eleven Hoosier tech companies received the honors based on survey rankings from the 2019 Tech Census, which focused specifically on tech cultures. Nearly 270 tech companies were nominated and the winners were selected from a group of 50 finalists. More than 1,300 individuals responded to the survey, which allowed employees to rate their companies and employers on...

    • Photo courtesy of Purdue University

      Purdue Offers 'Stranger Things' Replica Tee

      Purdue University has partnered with trademark licensing agent CLC to produce a special-edition replica Purdue shirt that appeared on an episode of Netflix’s “Stranger Things 3.”  The university also teamed up with Venley to accurately replicate the shirt, which will be available at retailers on the West Lafayette campus and online later this month.

    • Mearns was named Ball State's president in 2017.

      Ball State President Bullish on Growth Potential

      The president of Ball State University says he is optimistic about the growth trajectory for the school and the Muncie community at large. Ball State recently set a new record for total enrollment with more than 22,000 students, including its largest-ever freshman class. The university is also continuing with several major capital projects, including the more than $87 million Foundational Sciences building, which broke ground earlier this month. In an interview in Studio (i) with...