Is It Time to Invest in Oil?

The S&P 500 is down 8 percent since the beginning of the year. This has been the worse two-week start in the stock market's history. One cause frequently quoted is the low price of oil, which negatively impacts the energy sector. Is this a buying opportunity?

Good for Economy and Consumers

Before we talk about the investment opportunities created by low oil prices, it is important to note that these low prices are good for the economy as a whole. Individual consumers are benefiting directly due to the lower cost of gas. Companies that are big users of oil or its by-products see more profits going to their bottom lines. However, energy-producing companies are being challenged by the lower revenue generated.

The following discussion is not meant to imply that the markets need higher oil prices. Rather, it is meant to highlight potential investment opportunities that may be created by the low oil prices and what to think about before investing.

Why Oil Prices Declined

Prior to the summer of 2014, it was said with almost universal certainty that the price of oil would not drop significantly. If it did, it would only be a temporary drop before it went even higher. This played true as oil moved between $80 and a $100+ per barrel over several years. Investors saw this trend play out and so did consumers. You might remember the price of gasoline dropping for only a few days or weeks before moving back towards the $4.00 mark. That was the case until 2014. 

Without going into too much detail, new affordable technologies came on line that opened up formerly unreachable oil fields, particularly in the U.S. This added to the overall supply of oil.  In addition, China's economy began to grow at a slower pace. China had been consuming a significant amount of commodities, including oil, as it built out its infrastructure. This slow down lowered the global demand. Greater supply and lower demand pushed the price of oil lower.

As the price dropped, cracks in the oligopoly of OPEC became apparent. Historically, the OPEC countries worked together to reduce overall oil production. This allowed the price to maintain high and their revenues to be maximized. However, as the price continued to drop, oil producing countries became more concerned with maintaining their market share than reducing the global supply and, hence, production did not decline.

Is Now The Time To Invest?

The energy sector of the stock market was down more than 20 percent in 2015. Popular oil stocks, like Exxon and Chevron, continue to trade as much as 40 percent lower than their highs. Investors might consider these prices to be a good deal.

Is this the time to invest? That depends on where the price of oil goes from here. If it continues to go down, the answer is no. If the price of oil begins an upward trend, then an investment today may reap good appreciation in the future.

The price of oil is currently around $30 per barrel. While you may logically think $30 is way too cheap for a barrel of oil, that doesn't mean the price can't go down to $20. After all, the price of oil has dropped over 70 percent in the past 19 months. 

How to Invest

If you believe now is the time to invest, you have several options. You can invest in the big oil companies, like Exxon and Chevron, which do exploration, production, and distribution. This diversification has helped to keep their stock prices from falling as much as oil, but they are still down significantly.

Another popular option for investing in the energy sector is an Exchanged Traded Fund (ETF), which is essentially an index of energy stocks. A more complicated investment vehicle that may also utilize leverage is an Exchanged Traded Note (ETN) that invests in energy master limited partnerships. The leverage can enhance returns, both positive and negative; therefore, investors need to be very comfortable with the increased risk inherent in this type of investment vehicle.


As with any investment strategy, an investor must take a long term perspective. There is no shortage of pundits providing their opinion on oil. Take those with a grain of salt as virtually no one saw oil crashing from $100+ to $30 in 19 months. You also need to have a strong stomach and a clear understanding of your risk and timeline. As good as something may appear there are no guarantees.

This article was contributed by Ryan Collier, a Senior Portfolio Manager at Bedel Financial Consulting, Inc.

Elaine E. Bedel, CFP, is CEO and president of Bedel Financial Consulting, Inc., a wealth management firm located in Indianapolis. She is a featured guest each Wednesday on the WTHR (NBC, Indianapolis) Channel 13 News at Noon, "Your Money" segment. Elaine's book, "Advice You Never Asked For... But wished you had," is available on For more information, visit or email Elaine at

  • Perspectives

    • The First Thing Nonprofit Boards Should Focus On: Member Engagement

      There is no shortage of literature on how to run a nonprofit and what the board of directors should be doing. Do a quick search for “grant writing advice” or “board meeting agenda” and you will easily find hundreds of resources. But if there is so much helpful information around, why is serving on a nonprofit board sometimes so draining? After founding two nonprofits, Musical Family Tree and the Speak Easy, as well as serving on several nonprofit boards...



  • Most Popular Stories

    • (photo courtesy The Times of Northwest Indiana)

      Hammond Pulls 135 Jobs from Illinois

      A Hammond factory recently vacated by Michigan-based Lear Corp. didn’t sit empty for very long. Midland Metal Products has taken over the former seat factory, having relocated from Chicago after 95 years. 

    • Gateway Park will lead into the downtown district.

      Plans For New Muncie Facility Halted

      Plans for a $75 million project at the former BorgWarner site in Muncie have come to a halt.  Nigel Morrison, director of Waelz Sustainable Products LLP says “a campaign of misinformation tainted the process and ultimately made it impossible for the city council to continue supporting the project.” The project was first announced in January and was slated to create up to 90 new jobs. The announcement follows the opposition of Muncie residents who...


    • ‘Transformation’ Continues in Westfield

      Indiana’s fastest growing city is showing no signs of slowing down.  Mayor Andy Cook says now that Westfield has established itself as a destination for family sports with the Grand Park Sports Campus, the $35 million Grand Junction Plaza will transform the city’s downtown into a destination, a place “where people want to be.”   Cook says the project, more than a decade in the making, is an example of a place making strategy necessary for Midwest...
    • Elanco is headquartered in Greenfield.

      Elanco to Acquire Bayer AG Animal Health Business

      Greenfield-based Elanco Animal Health Inc. (NYSE: ELAN) has entered into an agreement with Bayer AG (ETR: BAYN) to acquire its animal health business in a deal valued at $7.6 billion. If approved, it would double Elanco’s Companion Animal business and create the second-largest animal health company by revenue. “Joining Elanco and Bayer Animal Health strengthens and accelerates our IPP strategy, transforms our portfolio with the addition of well-known pet brands, brings...

    • Corn, Soybean Groups Name New CEO

      The the Indiana Soybean Alliance Indiana Corn Marketing Council and the Indiana Corn Growers Association have named a new chief executive officer. Courtney Kingery is currently global director of Health & Wellness Innovation for Chicago-based Tate & Lyle and has experience as a grain trader and marketing director for oilseeds and food ingredients for ADM.